1794 The Whiskey Rebellion

10 S Hanover St, Carlisle
(717) 960-1000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Carmella

A comfortable, cozy atmosphere. Ryan was an excellent server who went into detail with us on a few menu items. He was great! My husband and I each had the delicious Prime Rib offered only on Friday & Saturday. Not to be missed! Try the whiskey flight and the nice wine options. Everything was perfect!

Christopher Jacobs

First time eating at 1794 and I was really impressed. The food was perfect and the service was excellent. We ending up out on the patio due to the car show being in town. It was a little noisy but we were seated out front by the road. Will be returning again to be seated in the dining room which looked inviting. Recommend you try this restaurant.

TruReview

Food was great and service was incredible. However the restaurant was extremely hot and uncomfortable for all. Need to have additional AC

Handel

My girlfriend and I were driving home from Pittsburgh and decided to come here based on other great reviews. Grateful we did. It's such a lovely gem as is the entire staff. Our meals and drinks were very memorable too.

Jeffrey Gilmore

This is a top notch place! The atmosphere was welcoming. The service was exceptional. The food was fabulous. And the selection of bourbon is beyond comparison.

kathleen lombardo

Hidden gem! Food was delicious and staff was courteous

Steven

This place was much better in the past. The whiskey sour drinks have gone downhill and did not taste much like a whiskey sour anymore. Not sure what it was that killed the drink. Maybe I should have ordered an old fashion instead. But I think they should figure that out for sure because in the last they were great. The food prices are good but I found the burgers and steak to be too salty. But overall not a bad meal and menu options are good. The fried onion appetizer was good.

Beth Miller

We celebrated my husband's birthday at 1794 yesterday, 6/17/2025.
Everything was absolutely wonderful, our waitress Megan K was very helpful, attentive and checked on us regularly. I had the Medallions and Hasselback potato and a Caesar Salad which was very fresh and fresh shaved parmesan cheese. I added grilled shrimp (I ate 2 of them before I took the picture). Not pictured, my husband had the Wagyu steak and mushrooms and grilled veggies and of course a bourbon flight.
It was a great experience and plan to return soon.

Matt Jones

What a great little spot with phenomenal food. Super convenient if you're staying at the hotel. Waitress was great and very knowledgeable of the menu.

Tracy Zink

Wonderful restaurant and service. Jacob our waiter was outstanding 👏 Definitely make a stop to experience great food and drinks.

bob

Pros: Angels Envy in the bourbon flight was amazing. The mashed potatoes and gravy along with the sautéed asparagus were really tasty. The server was pleasant. Cons: the Stroganoff was short on flavor. The prime rib was anything but prime. It was tasteless and tough. I was really excited to try this restaurant but was very disappointed.

Joy

The food was amazing. Cocktails were unique and very enjoyable. All the Waitstaff and hostesses were extremely friendly. Loved the atmosphere. Very accommodating with our food allergies. We had a great time. Definitely recommend and look forward to returning.

Lon

Entrees tasted great and good portions. Salads tasted good too but were too small for sharing. The dessert was too small to share as well. Great drink menu. Good service and ambience outside on the porch. Would have liked some decaf coffee with dessert but they simply didn't have any fresh coffee made, and were not making anymore that evening.

Joe

Food was very good. Poutine needed gravy. Medallions were great with sweet potato fries, but sauce was not tasty at all. Bangers and mash were very well done and tasty, especially the sausage.

Rosemary

We had a hard time finding the restaurant, because we didn't know it was in the Comfort Inn. That needs to be made more clear. There's a parking garage close by, so that was convenient. The atmosphere was nice and the service was great. The beef medallions were excellent. My friends had the shepherd's pie, which was delicious and the beef stroganoff, which was good but not really a traditional stroganoff. Overall, the experience was good. Would recommend it.

Loading...