Delicious as usual. Wonderful staff as usual. I have never been disappointed!
Darci Engelman
This is such a damn shame!! You really should be e ashamed of yourselves... So today a homeless man (older maybe 85yrs old) was walking by, he went in to ask for a cup of water, he stopped me and goes it's a damn shame I'm older than the hills and they make you pay for water!! I didn't want to not believe him but I was wondering so I went and try get him a cup of just something that is actually free and should be free in this world, especially for the elderly! She was gonna charge me 2.75 for a cup of water... You know when it comes to the older generation it should be without doubt we should be taking care of them!! I hope the waitress that denied this old man sees this... I hope you know that this old man almost died from heat stroke and you guys couldn't even bother to help him out! Have a damn heart!!
Collin Miller
Awesome food! Just remember to bring cash
Deisi Jaimes
When you're craving a diner hotdog, you go here. Chili, cheese, onion and amazing dogs on a bun!
Jason Cluggish
Classic diner, exactly what I expected. Great food, service and ambience.
Carolyn King
Food was great! Finally found a place in downtown Carlisle that has food I like! (Grilled cheese and French fries). And it was ready so fast!
Ro C
Great food and great people. Will absolutely stop back in when I am in town again.
Brad W
I've lived in Carlisle for most of my life but had never been to The Hamilton. After more than four decades of peer pressure, I finally made an appearance, lol.. the service was fantastic and the burger was cooked too perfection. I'm still not a fan of in town parking but...I will be back.
Sasha Young
A Love Letter to Hamilton: Where History, Heart, and Home Fries Collide
Step into Hamilton in Carlisle, PA, and you’ll feel as though you’ve time-traveled—not into the past, but into a parallel universe where good vibes and fast service reign supreme. This isn’t just a diner; it’s a living, breathing piece of history, where locals and lucky wanderers gather to break bread (or toast) in a space dripping with character.
Let’s be clear: Hamilton doesn’t do fancy. But what it does, it does with flair. The menu reads like a greatest hits of diner classics—no frills, no nonsense, but packed with the kind of flavor that reminds you why comfort food exists. The home fries? Crispy and buttery goodness. The Hotchee burgers? Juicy and unapologetically greasy in the best possible way. And the Diet Coke? Their crushed ice and the brew is everything. Keep in mind they do charge for refills. Last but not least, their pies. Their Oreo pie is what dreams are made of.
The real magic, though, is the atmosphere and the people. The walls seem to hum with decades of stories, from first dates to late-night soul-searching sessions over pie. The service is lightning-quick but never rushed, and the staff strike that perfect balance of friendly and efficient. It’s the kind of place where regulars are greeted like old friends, and newcomers like long-lost cousins.
Hamilton doesn’t try to impress you with truffle oil or avocado foam—it wows you with heart, history, and a vibe that’s downright contagious. It’s not just a diner; it’s a slice of Carlisle’s soul, served with a side of crispy bacon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Burger
Robert Henry
Excellent service with excellent historic Hot-Chee Dogs - hot dog, cheese, onions, and chili. The fries were delicious, hot and fresh while the Cole slaw was tasty and cool. Highly recommend this Carlisle classic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Dog, Coleslaw, French Fries, Fries
$7.40 for 2 hot dogs is absolutely ridiculous. They could at least throw in a drink for that crazy price.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Dog
Ratskin Canoe
A Carlise Classic! Gotta get the hotchee dogs. They always give you a nice cold glass of water with the nice little ice cubes. Good local family diner. Old school vibes
JonBon Kiner
Love love love it here
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Dog, 2 Eggs and Toast, Sausage
Corie Prosser
There food is wonderful, staff is extremelynice and very good prices. It reminds me when i was young being there! A great family restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchie Burgers, Hotchee Dog, Fries with Chicken Gravy, Strawberry, 2 Eggs and Toast, Toast, French Toast, Sausage, French Fries, Hotchi Dog
Michael Cochrane
I've dined at the Hamilton Restaurant 4 times during a trip to Carlisle. The food is delicious and the portions are generous. The waitresses are so friendly. They only accept cash for payment.
Delicious as usual. Wonderful staff as usual. I have never been disappointed!
This is such a damn shame!! You really should be e ashamed of yourselves... So today a homeless man (older maybe 85yrs old) was walking by, he went in to ask for a cup of water, he stopped me and goes it's a damn shame I'm older than the hills and they make you pay for water!! I didn't want to not believe him but I was wondering so I went and try get him a cup of just something that is actually free and should be free in this world, especially for the elderly! She was gonna charge me 2.75 for a cup of water... You know when it comes to the older generation it should be without doubt we should be taking care of them!! I hope the waitress that denied this old man sees this... I hope you know that this old man almost died from heat stroke and you guys couldn't even bother to help him out! Have a damn heart!!
Awesome food! Just remember to bring cash
When you're craving a diner hotdog, you go here. Chili, cheese, onion and amazing dogs on a bun!
Classic diner, exactly what I expected. Great food, service and ambience.
Food was great! Finally found a place in downtown Carlisle that has food I like! (Grilled cheese and French fries). And it was ready so fast!
Great food and great people. Will absolutely stop back in when I am in town again.
I've lived in Carlisle for most of my life but had never been to The Hamilton. After more than four decades of peer pressure, I finally made an appearance, lol.. the service was fantastic and the burger was cooked too perfection. I'm still not a fan of in town parking but...I will be back.
A Love Letter to Hamilton: Where History, Heart, and Home Fries Collide
Step into Hamilton in Carlisle, PA, and you’ll feel as though you’ve time-traveled—not into the past, but into a parallel universe where good vibes and fast service reign supreme. This isn’t just a diner; it’s a living, breathing piece of history, where locals and lucky wanderers gather to break bread (or toast) in a space dripping with character.
Let’s be clear: Hamilton doesn’t do fancy. But what it does, it does with flair. The menu reads like a greatest hits of diner classics—no frills, no nonsense, but packed with the kind of flavor that reminds you why comfort food exists. The home fries? Crispy and buttery goodness. The Hotchee burgers? Juicy and unapologetically greasy in the best possible way. And the Diet Coke? Their crushed ice and the brew is everything. Keep in mind they do charge for refills. Last but not least, their pies. Their Oreo pie is what dreams are made of.
The real magic, though, is the atmosphere and the people. The walls seem to hum with decades of stories, from first dates to late-night soul-searching sessions over pie. The service is lightning-quick but never rushed, and the staff strike that perfect balance of friendly and efficient. It’s the kind of place where regulars are greeted like old friends, and newcomers like long-lost cousins.
Hamilton doesn’t try to impress you with truffle oil or avocado foam—it wows you with heart, history, and a vibe that’s downright contagious. It’s not just a diner; it’s a slice of Carlisle’s soul, served with a side of crispy bacon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Burger
Excellent service with excellent historic Hot-Chee Dogs - hot dog, cheese, onions, and chili. The fries were delicious, hot and fresh while the Cole slaw was tasty and cool. Highly recommend this Carlisle classic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Dog, Coleslaw, French Fries, Fries
Restaurantji Recommends
$7.40 for 2 hot dogs is absolutely ridiculous. They could at least throw in a drink for that crazy price.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Dog
A Carlise Classic! Gotta get the hotchee dogs. They always give you a nice cold glass of water with the nice little ice cubes. Good local family diner. Old school vibes
Love love love it here
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchee Dog, 2 Eggs and Toast, Sausage
There food is wonderful, staff is extremelynice and very good prices. It reminds me when i was young being there! A great family restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hotchie Burgers, Hotchee Dog, Fries with Chicken Gravy, Strawberry, 2 Eggs and Toast, Toast, French Toast, Sausage, French Fries, Hotchi Dog
I've dined at the Hamilton Restaurant 4 times during a trip to Carlisle. The food is delicious and the portions are generous. The waitresses are so friendly. They only accept cash for payment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...