Hamilton Restaurant
55 W High St, Carlisle
(717) 249-4410
Customers' Favorites
Side Order of Home Fries
Fries with Chicken Gravy
Chicken Sandwich Platter
Fries with Beef Gravy
Chili Cheese Fries
Hotchee Dog Combo
Chili Cheese Dog
2 Eggs and Toast
Hotchie Burgers
Hotchee Burger
Menu
Photos
+78 photos
+77 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
First time here and was somehow overwhelmed and underwhelmed at the same time. Wife’s hot beef sandwich with fries covered in gravy was great while my bacon cheeseburger was small and down right flavorless. The small drinks glasses had me waiting for refills. The atmosphere was high energy an everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. The strangest part was when I received a “check” with just a four digit number on it that seemed high and without prices for sides or soda...
A great old style lunch counter eatery in downtown Carlisle! The Hamilton restaurant serves up very nice diner fare. The service was excellent and our server kept our drinks topped off the entire time! The burger and hot dog was fantastic- especially the delicious tomatoes! I would definitely recommend this place for people looking for a nice local place to eat for breakfast and lunch.
First timers and it was wonderful. All the servers & staff work around each other like a well oiled machine. Breakfast Food was great, service was wonderful. Will definitely be back when we’re in the area again to try to Hochee! (Pictured)
You May Also Like
Issei Noodle - 54 W High St
![]()
Asian, Japanese, Vegetarian, Noodles, Gluten-Free
Pitt Street Station - 10 N Pitt St
![]()
Comfort Food, Bar
Café Bruges - 16 N Pitt St
![]()
Belgian, Vegan, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly