Sage Cafe

22 W Pomfret St, Carlisle
(717) 701-8624

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Oh Aces

Great food. Great staff. And they were careful about our daughter's food allergies. I was blown away by the pizza as well, and I grew up eating the best pizza in NYC.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chrylann Deck

They have the best black bean soup I ever had. It's hearty and fresh with a little heat. Perfect! The hummus plate is a whole meal and tastes homemade. I'll be back.

Vegetarian options: A great hummus appetizer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Black Bean Soup

Cliff Eckhart

Came here for our anniversary, looking for a unique, upscale but tasty meal. Sage hit it! Food was delicious, the staff was very friendly, and the prices are reasonable for quality offering. We sat in the sun room/glassed-in porch, which is beautiful but the hard wood floors and brick interior wall make it a bit echoey and loud.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy Rada

I’ve been to Sage a few times and I have really enjoyed their food. Yesterday I ordered a mushroom pizza and I found two pieces of long hair in my food. They gave me a free meal and dessert and were very apologetic.

Erin Depew

We had a bridal shower for my sister in law here today and I cannot say enough good things about it!! It is clean and welcoming and the food was delicious. Our server, Jenna, was so friendly and attentive. Everyone has a great time. The parking garage right across the street is very convenient when street parking is not available.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries

Miss Val

I stopped in on a Saturday early evening for dinner and sat out on the patio. This was my first visit but won’t be my last. I saw a very good looking shrimp dish on their Instagram and intended on getting that but when I saw their full menu I had trouble deciding. I ended up getting the salmon tirana. It was very very good. Everything tasted very fresh. That piece of bread was delicious. I almost tried dessert but I was too full. The server did tell me that they make the desserts in house daily. I considered getting a piece of cake to go but didn’t. The patio was nice. It is not enclosed so if you like sitting outside you will like it but if you’d rather be under cover and out of the elements sit inside. Prices were fair. The service staff were attentive, friendly and personable. Parking is on the street and metered but free after a certain time and on weekends. Definitely recommend trying them if you are in the area. Save room for dessert and let me know how it is!

Parking: Street parking with meters. Free after a certain time. I think the meters are coin-operated but not sure, I didn’t actually look. I just know the rest of the town is free after 4p and on weekends.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Mark Greenawalt

It's a great place for good unique dishes. My office goes here for lunch often and I brought my family in last Friday for dinner. Our server was excellent. Mistakes were made in the kitchen but server was more than accommodating

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shana Halteman

Our server was very helpful and the service was great! The food was tasty and nice serving size. The personal pizzas are sharable size! And the chia latte was delish.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jason Peter

Traveler’s review: This place is such a hidden gem. It’s on a small lane but oh my, the food was fantastic. The Chicken and Shrimp Salerno was the best I’ve tasted and I’ve had my fair share of good food. The chicken nor shrimp was over cooked and the sauce was packed with flavor.I went in for a super early dinner so the place was quiet and peaceful. Great spot for a family meal, a date, or to hang out with friends.I would’ve loved a glass of wine with my food but it’s more of a café vibe so I understand.

Cindy Cowan

From appetizers to dessert everything was prepared wonderfully. Even their English Fog tea was spot on. I had the manicotti as my main dish and the ingredients were perfectly balanced. The staff was very friendly and attentive.

Chrissy England

Excellent time out with friends. The dinner was exquisite. I had the stuffed beef tenderloin and would recommend it! The staff was friendly, attentive, and and recommend the London Fog as an after dinner. Looking forward to going back!

Lisa

Outstanding service and food was superb! Black bean Soup was very flavorful. Chicken Tortellini Soup was equally yummy- VEGES were perfect, nicely seasoned. Had the Sunset Chicken, deliciously seasoned and cooked to perfection. stuffed beef tenderloin was absolutely on point, very rich in flavor! The food was next level delish!!! Love the BYOB, popped around the corner to Castlerrigg for a bottle of wine. Parked at the ground lot just past the POMFRET Street Garage. All within a very easy walk! Great place for a date or fine dining excursion. Well Done Sage! WELL DONE! We will definitely be back!!!

Parking: Option of on street, parking garage or ground lot.

Wheelchair accessibility: Has large wheelchair concrete ramp. Very accessible.

Somma Family

Service was 5 stars! Nutty chicken sandwich was delicious, but it could have used more sauce. Burger was delicious, but ordered medium rare and it was well done.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza crust

Amber Moreland

My husband and I found this gem on our way to Hershey. We stopped for lunch and it was fabulous! We had fried pickles which were hand breaded and they were so yummy. I had the crab soup and he had the sage chicken sandwich and both were great. The atmosphere was relaxing yet elegant! Definitely 5 stars!

Lindsay de Bien

The food was absolutely delicious and the service was great. We weren't paying attention to prices and were honestly pretty blown away when the check came, but you can easily avoid that if you ask how much the specials cost. Just because "cafe" is in the name, don't assume you'll just be getting sandwiches ... The menu and atmosphere are definitely date-night quality!

Loading...