I always purchase Shirley's cookies from Sheetz in Centre Hall PA. My favorite is the black raspberry filled cookies. Absolutely to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
HAYKAY 47
I use to be healthy and in shape until I found a box of Whoopie Pies made by Shirley. Now I’m a fat divorced 50 yr old man who sits alone in his mom’s basement eating these pies. AND ITS TOTALLY WORTH IT!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brendan King
Got at local grocery store here in Illinois. The pumpkin ones are freaking amazing! Whoopi pies !!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Judy Denison
Purchased mini peanut butter no bake cookies that were as good as the ones I make.
Mary Kim Chiodo-Berry
I guessing no one knows how to read....I ordered strawberry whoopie pies and got red velvet.
Edward Soback
Bought the Peanut Butter Chocolate no bake cookies. Terrible. Very bland. Almost a "dusty" after taste. No sweet peanut butter or chocolate taste.
The ones from Walmart are way better.
Sarah Ann
I would not recommend these cookies at all! We bought the sugar cookies because they looked so moist on the outside. Yah I was horribly mistaken and looks CAN be deceiving! They were dry!!!!!! They also tasted terrible! Something was definitely lacking in this cookie recipe! Bought at Cantinis Village market in Rock Creek Ohio
melinda fisher
I bought some peanut butter chocolate no bake cookies today and you can tell they didn't cook long enough on the stove. They cooled in weird shapes and there are fingerprints in them and some even squeezed almost in half.
Heather Corley
Great cookies. Friendly staff. Clean and happy atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Cookies, Confetti Cookies
No bake cookie are terrible! I bought them at Save a lot in Cleveland,Ohio. They are dried out and hard as a brick and not even close to expiration date.
Marilyn D
On 10/7/23 I bought the Chocolate Peanut Butter No Bake cookies at a local grocery store in Michigan. They had odd taste, didn’t taste chocolate or peanut butter. The date on them is 10/21/23. Expensive cookies for $5.99 for 9 cookies that do not taste good.
Marilyn Dake
On 10/7/23 I bought the Chocolate Peanut Butter No Bake cookies at a local grocery store in Michigan. They had odd taste, didn’t taste chocolate or peanut butter. The date on them is 10/21/23. Expensive cookies for $5.99 for 9 cookies that do not taste good.
Grace keller
The raisin filled used to be so fresh and full of filling. I bought a box at Lykens in Beech Creek PA. So dry they fell apart. Hardly any filling. These cookies were almost flat. Why are you no longer at Sams?
I haven't seen those sugar cookies in my city in years. I used to tear them up 😩
Food: 4
I always purchase Shirley's cookies from Sheetz in Centre Hall PA. My favorite is the black raspberry filled cookies. Absolutely to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I use to be healthy and in shape until I found a box of Whoopie Pies made by Shirley. Now I’m a fat divorced 50 yr old man who sits alone in his mom’s basement eating these pies. AND ITS TOTALLY WORTH IT!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got at local grocery store here in Illinois. The pumpkin ones are freaking amazing! Whoopi pies !!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Purchased mini peanut butter no bake cookies that were as good as the ones I make.
I guessing no one knows how to read....I ordered strawberry whoopie pies and got red velvet.
Bought the Peanut Butter Chocolate no bake cookies. Terrible. Very bland. Almost a "dusty" after taste. No sweet peanut butter or chocolate taste. The ones from Walmart are way better.
I would not recommend these cookies at all! We bought the sugar cookies because they looked so moist on the outside. Yah I was horribly mistaken and looks CAN be deceiving! They were dry!!!!!! They also tasted terrible! Something was definitely lacking in this cookie recipe! Bought at Cantinis Village market in Rock Creek Ohio
I bought some peanut butter chocolate no bake cookies today and you can tell they didn't cook long enough on the stove. They cooled in weird shapes and there are fingerprints in them and some even squeezed almost in half.
Great cookies. Friendly staff. Clean and happy atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Cookies, Confetti Cookies
Restaurantji Recommends
No bake cookie are terrible! I bought them at Save a lot in Cleveland,Ohio. They are dried out and hard as a brick and not even close to expiration date.
On 10/7/23 I bought the Chocolate Peanut Butter No Bake cookies at a local grocery store in Michigan. They had odd taste, didn’t taste chocolate or peanut butter. The date on them is 10/21/23. Expensive cookies for $5.99 for 9 cookies that do not taste good.
On 10/7/23 I bought the Chocolate Peanut Butter No Bake cookies at a local grocery store in Michigan. They had odd taste, didn’t taste chocolate or peanut butter. The date on them is 10/21/23. Expensive cookies for $5.99 for 9 cookies that do not taste good.
The raisin filled used to be so fresh and full of filling. I bought a box at Lykens in Beech Creek PA. So dry they fell apart. Hardly any filling. These cookies were almost flat. Why are you no longer at Sams?
I cannot get enough of this stuff! ?
Loading...