Ice House Pizzeria & Subs
$ • Pizza, Bakery
Hours:
390 Water St, Conneaut Lake
(814) 213-0076
About Ice House Pizzeria & Subs
Customers' Favorites
Ice House Pizzeria & Subs Reviews
Share your opinion about Ice House Pizzeria & Subs
I recently ordered a custom cake for my husband's birthday and Gary really nailed it. Not only did it taste absolutely amazing but it looked stunning as well. Gary puts his heart into his orders, is great with communication, very reasonably priced, and he truly cares about the quality of his product before it leaves his bakery. I have reccomended him to friends and family and encourage anyone to try something he creates...you will not be disappointed!
I had a custom order for sliders, fruit tray, salads for 20 people- Was fantastic- Easy pick up, everything was nicely wrapped, tongs and spoons included- Will be using again next year for family get together- Chicken Salad was amazing
First time here today, I ordered at Gyro salad and added fries to it. Best salad I have had in awhile! 10/10 recommend. I will be returning
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 2 - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 2 - 7PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 7PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 7PM |
People in Conneaut Lake Also Viewed
Ice House Pizzeria & Subs is a great, family-owned place in Conneaut Lake across from the sheets on the corner by the light. It is an experience and absolutely the best. The people who man the place are great, very friendly, and look like they know everyone in the community. The owner is a real multitasker who views his business as having fun with food, loving what he does, and working “outside the box.”
The menu is the most extensive menu ever seen, with lots of pizza, subs, creative dishes, and clever and fun pizza toppings. They have dinners for the day posted up behind the cash register. The food is great, delicious, and everything is made fresh, with a wait time of about 15-20 minutes. The pizza sauce has more tomatoes than sugar. The price point is great and very reasonable, with all prices including tax. They also have a bakery with cookies of all sorts, cannoli's, muffins of every kind, donuts, and huge specialty freshly baked cookies, all made fresh daily. Fresh fruit salads are made right below the cash register. They also offer local jams, salsas, pickled vegetables, and more at much lower than grocery store prices.
Custom cakes and wedding cakes are phenomenal, made with love and care, absolutely incredible to eat, stunning, and absolutely fantastic. The bakery also provides delicious gluten free items. The service is great. It is definitely worth the stop and visitors will walk out completely satisfied.