Ice House Pizzeria & Grille

390 Water St, Conneaut Lake
(814) 213-0076

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Hayleigh Orr

I recently ordered a custom cake for my husband's birthday and Gary really nailed it. Not only did it taste absolutely amazing but it looked stunning as well. Gary puts his heart into his orders, is great with communication, very reasonably priced, and he truly cares about the quality of his product before it leaves his bakery. I have reccomended him to friends and family and encourage anyone to try something he creates...you will not be disappointed!

Ethan Rimolt

Gary did the wedding cakes for my cousins wedding. PHENOMENAL. He made the cakes with love and care and they were absolutely incredible to eat. We also came twice for breakfast during our weekend here and once for dinner. You can’t miss on this menu. Go out of your comfort zone and try a crazy pizza, you won’t regret it. We will ABSOLUTELY be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brad Logel

Awesome donuts, rolls, pizza and anything else. If you haven't, you NEED to try it. I'm a regular when we're in town.

Food: 5

David Lynch

First time eating there. The food was good. Service was good. Reasonably priced. Very extensive menu.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Crystal Martin

The pizza is good here, but the real gem is the pastries and cakes! Must try lava cakes, heated slightly!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

joseph mast

My go to meal is the Jalapeño Ranch Steak “strip district”sub!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kim stein

Absolutely the best! I have been coming here weekly for over a year now and have not had anything that I did not like. Everything is delicious and very reasonable! I had a rasberry birthday cake done and it was absolutely fantastic!! My husband loves their gluten free items and always gets those since he has gluten issues! Can not say enough about the great food and service they provide!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rodney Warnick

If you ate ever in the area, ice house pizza is a wonderful place and inexpensive place to eat. Great pizza and other foods as well as desserts. We will always return for their food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Baker

Amazing food and service you won't regret stopping here !!!

Molly Fike

The young blonde girl walking around with no shoes on was so incredibly rude. When she came out with our plates and forks she threw them down. And when she came out with our food she threw them down and said “here”. She was side eyeing us the whole time and has a very sour attitude. We also had to wait an hour for the food.

And for the food aspect, it wasn’t truely bad. But I wouldn’t ever go there again for food. It didn't taste so bad I had to spit it out. I didn’t get to try their large selection of deserts but they looked pretty good.

So would I recommend anyone coming here? Well If you don’t mind waiting an hour for your food, having a rude girl serve you, and want to eat food that has no seasoning or taste than I’d recommend this place for you.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Kattie Priebe

Amazing menu!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Pierogi Pizza, Cannoli, Chicken Ranch Pickle Pizza, Taco Pizza, Doughnut

Jodi Seeley Ulmer

I had a custom order for sliders, fruit tray, salads for 20 people- Was fantastic- Easy pick up, everything was nicely wrapped, tongs and spoons included- Will be using again next year for family get together- Chicken Salad was amazing

Etta Miller

So much to chose from. Come hungry because the subs are full and delicious

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cannoli

Rooster Hooch

Spectacular service. The owners ACTUALLY care about your experience. Some of the best service I have ever received in a restaurant. The food was delicious, and the gourmet dessert selection was insane. Worth every minute to get there and every penny spent.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Pies, Pierogi Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Ranch Pickle Pizza, Taco Pizza, Meatball Lovers Calzone, Pizza Rolls, Comes with Salad

Elsbeth Upton

Hands down some of the best service I have ever received in a restaurant. The food was excellent, the menu was so extensive it required a binder and the dessert selection was nothing short of breathtaking. If you are local or if you can make a detour, it's beyond worth the trip. Do yourself a favor and give them a try.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Pies, Pierogi Pizza, Cannoli, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Ranch Pickle Pizza, Taco Pizza, Meatball Lovers Calzone, Pizza Rolls, Cupcake

Loading...