Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

What a let down. Pizza dough wasn’t fully cooked. If someone asked me I’d tell them the head cook doesn’t know how to cook a proper pizza. This place would be packed if the owner cared more about the food they were selling. Wing were rubbery and not good.
It was clear whoever runs this place either doesn’t care or has given up. Here’s to another week eating at Aviva pizza. At least Aviva is edible and doesn’t fall apart while I eat.
I want you guys to have good food so badly. Such nice staff and good drinks. But if youre gonna run a pizza joint you should try it before feeding it to everyone.

Establishment was extremely clean. Waitress was very communicative. Pizza was just ok. Not a whole lot of flavor to it. Nothing mind blowing or worth finishing the whole pizza. There is much better pizza in the area. (I got the margarita pizza and my boyfriend got the paulie pizza).

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Was expecting more from this restaurant but left somewhat disappointed. We waited 18 minutes just to get our order taken. The waitress walked past us several times. She apparently was the only waitress that evening. Pizza was ok but not enough sauce or cheese. Lemonade was great. Guess we will keep looking for a good pizza joint.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

I’m sorry this pizza is just not good. Maybe it’s because I got pepperoni, but the dough was so soggy and greasy, and the char on the bottom was excessive. Felt like I was eating charcoal. Flavor really isn’t that great either. Certainly not worth 20 dollars nor the calories.

Food: 1

Originally, I complained about a screwed-up order. The kitchen manager (who was very polite) told me to stop back in to get a corrected sandwich. I get it, it happens. Upon doing so and having explained it to the bartender, she took up a nasty tone and attitude. Pity, as I think your food is dynamite. Yet, I'll not be subjected to that kind of reaction from one of your employees. Not nice...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

So, we just tried Anthony’s for the first time. What a big mistake that was. Let me give background. I’m from the New York area and I’m currently a Pittsburgh transplant. Your odds of finding really good New York style pizza in the Pittsburgh area is about as high as being able to rob Fort Knox without being noticed.

I’ve been here for about a year and have found a couple of passable places. While in Cranberry Pennsylvania, I noticed this place from the street that advertised coal fired Pizza. That got my attention because one of my favorite places in the world is Frank Pepe’s Pizza, from the New Haven area, which is also coal fired.

Longing for a really good pizza, I finally stumbled into Anthony’s. After my first bite of pizza, I actually choked up and got emotional. That’s how good this place is. That’s how good the pizza is.

In the middle of our dinner, I told my wife that I was going to give this place a terrible review. The reason for that is because whenever I give a glowing review to a place, I can never get back into it because it’s always so overcrowded due to the recommendation.

To be kind, I’m gonna give this place an extremely high and glowing review. The Pizza was first class. The pizza has a crispy coal fired crust and the toppings are first rate. So yes, I’m going to give a great review, but I really want you to stay away from this place and not go! I mean it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Great atmosphere, great pizza, good wait staff, excellent chefs. We will definitely visit again.

I love the crisp burnt pizza and long finger hot peppers are plenty hot!
Great Mediterranean type salads and the baked wings are very good, nice bar too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Maria's Meatballs with Ricotta, Chicken Wings

The food is always good. Came out fast. The service was fast and the girl was friendly. My wife is very specific on her order, the manager came by and asked us if everything was ok afterward. Couldnt be happier.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 5 Pieces of Chicken Wings, Anthony's Classic Italian Salad, White Pizza

Service and wings were outta this world! My server KATIE knew and anticipated everything that I needed! I'll bring friends next time for pizza! She went above and beyond! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Not a fan of burnt crust pizza. No real sauce, just crushed tomatoes.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

We were staying at a hotel nearby on our way home from Florida. We ordered a 16 inch pizza for pickup. Ingredients used are good but the pizza crust was not cooked. The outside looked cooked but the dough was raw inside. My understanding is that a coal fired oven is very hot. in my opinion the crust was too thick. They pre-cook the vegetables that go on the pizza likely because the pizza doesn't spend enough time in the oven to fully cook these...should be the same for the crust. Service was good. The restaurant itself looked good and was clean.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Traditional Pie with Cheese

Got take out last night. We ordered 10 of the honey wings. Very dry and very little flavor. 1-half and half pizza. Frozen pizza would have tasted better. 1 half was supposed to be margherita. There was not one piece of basil on it like there was in the picture on the website. We also got 2 salads. Chop salad was very good, but to be a pizza place and have that be the worse thing we ordered was very disappointing. Our wings, small pizza, and 2 salads came to $75 without tip. I will not be going back.

Food: 2

I ordered a takeout pizza with sausage and mushrooms. There were hardly any topings and they were expensive! I have had their pizza before and was pleased with it. I thought this place was going to be my go to but I don't like eating expensive cheese pizza. I will have to get it elsewhere.

Food: 2

We grabbed pizza while driving across country and it was AMAZING. I don’t know who made it but perfect amount of burn, perfect crust, even amount of toppings with bites of fresh tomato ?. Only sad thing is that we woke up 200 miles away and wanted to drive back for more. We’ll definitely be back!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5