Sarah's Creamery
121 S Main St, Dover
(717) 292-1400
Customers' Favorites
Death by Chocolate with Toppings
Pre Packed Vegan Ice Cream
Hand Dipped Ice Cream
Chocolate Marshmallow
Mint Chocolate Chip
State Coffee Break
Brownie Sundae
Butter Pecan
Banana Split
Waffle
Menu
Photos
+52 photos
+51 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
If I am in the area, I always stop at Sarah's Creamery. My son graduated from Penn State, and we got hooked on Penn State Ice Cream. Sarah's is the only place I know that has Penn State Ice Cream other than Penn State! My favorite is "Peachy Paterno"! I stopped in Sarah's Creamery today and got my Peachy Paterno Ice cream cone. It's the best treat ever! If you are ever in the area, you must stop in Sarah's Creamery and try the Penn State Ice...
The best ice cream ever there! I would recommend Penn State Grilled Stickies and chocolate lava cake. They also have vegan and sugar free ice cream! The staff and owner are very friendly! Would definitely recommend if you have kids!
Definitely recommend Sarah’s, and especially recommend the monkey business . The staff is super nice and helpful. Especially when it came to dietary restrictions. My mom has restrictions on gluten and dairy items and the staff was very helpful on picking out what she can have and it was still delicious.
You May Also Like
Moonlight Cafe - 4140 Carlisle Rd
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian
Greer’s Burger Garage - 121 S Main St
![]()
American, Burgers, Hot Dogs, Hamburger
China One - 2146 Palomino Rd
![]()
Chinese