Tonino's Pizza

1327, 730 Milford Rd #11, East Stroudsburg
(570) 424-7373

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+13 photos
+12 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I'm a Sicilian guy. You can tell a good pizzaria by their Sicilians. I was impressed with toninos. I tried just about all the Sicilians in the area but Toninos was the best. The Sicilian slices are thick and not flat like the others. There's a good ratio of cheese and tomato sauce on top. The middle is soft and airy. At the very bottom there's a thin crisp. I recommend this place. The traditional slices are good too 👍
I’m going to say everyone here is friendly and kind love this place! Love the pizza I’ve been a loyal customer since I moved to Stroudsburg in 2023 however recently moved but I still travel 40 min just to come here to get pizza because they’re the best in town! Recently took a break from pizza for a little. but love everyone here

From Stephon
I called to make a pick up order. I had to repeat myself multiple times as to what pasta I wanted, had them repeat the order back to me, went to pick up the order and we still got the wrong pasta and it didn’t come with chicken like we asked. I don’t even understand how you mess that up when you literally repeated it back to me.

More Reviews