Sontheimer's Country Bakery

Sadly where I live there are NO decent bakeries left, so I've accepted that I will have to drive at least an hour to get good dessert. Let me tell you, this place is worth the drive!! I've been here only once but I am planning to come back soon, everything I tried was great, but the orange crescents and the sweet maple rolls are 😍😍😍 I might have to just get a dozen of those when I visit next because they are irresistable. Clark's Donuts are the best ones available in my area and they're decent but they have NOTHING on the sweets from Sontheimer's!!!

The family that owns this bakery are sooo friendly and I was shocked at how low the prices are for the amazing quality you get. Can't wait to visit again and fill my car up with delicous desserts and bread.

PSA: They only accept cash here, make sure you bring your friends Washington, Lincoln, Jefferson and Jackson with you. In my case I probably need to bring Benjamin too, because I just want to bring the whole menu home with me. 🍞🥐🥖🍩🍰

Nice bakery prices are responsible.

Pastry and cakes are phenomenal. Erie's metro area's best kept secret.

Fabulous bakery items... Cakes, cookies, brownies, orange and lemon crescents, are AMAZING!!!🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

Great homemade bake goods , will visit again soon

Have loved this old-fashioned bakery since the 1960s. My favorites are the cinnamon raisin rolls, but it's all good. It's always a stop if I'm in Erie -- take extra home, wrap it well, and keep in freezer. ❤️

Phenomenal baked goods! Highly recommend, everything we purchased was fresh, homemade, and truly ambrosial.
Super unique and an extensive selection, see photos. Everything is fresh and absolutely delicious. Will continue to stop by anytime we are in the area, this place is a hidden gem! We were at a lacrosse play day and stopped by at a time between

Amazing atmosphere, wonderful guy at the register as well! Very tasty will be back!!

My coworkers and I were given a variety of the bakery goods as a thank you. It was my first time having the tasty treats. I'm very impressed at the quality of the items. I can't wait to visit the bakery for more!

If you want fresh Delicious baked goods, look no further than Sontheimer’s , this has been an Erie favorite for many years

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice people & Erie tradition, no added chemicals just real ingredients and amazing variety of breads, rolls, cookies, cakes, danish, sweet breads & nut breads, etc. A real treat!

First time here, and while it smelled so good, there was so little available. We left without purchase. They don't take debit or credit cards, so if you have no cash or checks, you're out of luck.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Best cake we've had in a very long time, whipped cream cake

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tons of baked items at excellent prices. The staff is patient and helpful. Don't miss the orange crescents or the croissants. Everything is amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great fresh baked goods. A local treasure. Just remember that it is cash only.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5