Mim's Mighty Meaty Hoagies

423 W Main St, Fayetteville
(717) 352-3935

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Andrea Baker

Highlights: My family has supported small business owners (as we say today) for many years. ** Mim's is no exception. ** Have been a supporter for more than 45 plus years. Not only the friendship, hospitality of food, an employer. I WOULD RECOMMEND THIS HOGIE SHOP TO ALL WHO LOVE HOME TOWN ATMOSPHERE. ❤️

Andrea Baker Hammaker

Highlights: My family has supported small business owners (as we say today) for many years. ** Mim's is no exception. ** Have been a supporter for more than 45 plus years. Not only the friendship, hospitality of food, an employer. I WOULD RECOMMEND THIS HOGIE SHOP TO ALL WHO LOVE HOME TOWN ATMOSPHERE. ❤️

Tina Sullivan

We got our food delivered! The sub rolls were like hot dog rolls but a little longer, poor quality high price never again!

Food: 1

Autumn dies

We had been ordering like every other week but I ordered the other night and the hoagie rolls were different from normal a lot skinner or something and the tuna one looked like they just put a can of tuna on it and didn’t even mix any mayonnaise with it was super sad with what we ended up with

April Shultz

I've been going there for years n the last time I went there our hoagies was so soggy fries was nasty not done never ever had food from them like this I always loved there hoagies never thought I'd ever get food like this don't think I'll ever go back

Michele Holden

I came to eat there for the first time last Sat 8/10/24. Never been there before and got a coupon so wanted to try it out. Brought my mom with me. Food was pretty good ,but there were 2 men cooking in the kitchen who were so rude and argumentative with the lady taking our order. Who was there that day to help out she said because of a callout. She mentioned she hadn't been in there for months due to a couple of surgeries. She made a small mistake on my order (not a big deal at all) but when she took it to one of the men preparing food he said" why did you put bacon on this order if she didn't ask for bacon. Heavy sigh and walked away. I felt sorry for her because she was in there helping them out and he was very RUDE. I asked for a box to take left overs and when she went to get me a box the other man preparing food snapped at her and said we don't use those anymore" put his kitchen tool down and grumbled when he walked away. They treated her like she was an idiot and getting scolded in front of customers was UNCALLED FOR!! i was please with my sub but don't think I will be returning because if that's how they treat their employees its no place I want to eat. And i love supporting our local Mom and Pop shopes.
Sounds like they have been in business for years and been successful but treatment of employees needs to change.

Parking: parking is free and right next to the building

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Turkey Hoagie, Fries

TS C0BRA

Honestly I have never been so positive I was being served food that was made in the trunk of a 1996 Sebring. The “cheesesteak” was literally served on hot dog buns. Like store bought cheapest on the shelves hot dog buns. A 12” sub with about 2 oz of meat in two hotdog buns cut and made to look like a single bun…. No onions and it seems as if the selection of cheeses are really suggestions that Mim and the gang will surely just ignore for whatever dollar store white trash they are gonna put on your “steak ums on hot dog bun”

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason Biggins

Had a not so great at Mim’s and they reached out to me immediately. They made it more than right and I appreciate it. I even feel like they went above and beyond. I will be going back as soon as I’m back in the area to thank them and patronize their business. Can’t say enough about how quick they reached out and made it right. Thank you.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Kelley Johnson

You would think a veggie sub would have some veggies on it. I opened it to find massive bread with lettuce and tomato and a little bit of onion. No one asked me if I wanted additional veggies; I assumed it would come with peppers, olives, maybe some cucumber?also the chicken ranch sandwich was 80% lettuce with a little chickens scattered among the lettuce.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Danielle Henry

This is amazing i would definitely check this out if you come to the area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

jeri acosta

This little gem is owned by locals for 52 yrs. Everything is cooked fresh!! We ordered Philly cheesesteak sandwiches on hoagie bread with fresh cut fries and was delicious!!! They also own meat market down the road!!! If passing this way don’t hesitate to stop!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Schaffer

Really good hoagies. Mighty and meaty is right. My "go to" place for hoagies AND cheese steaks.Daily specials...and good folk.

Nuno Urbiznis (Dragineez)

Very friendly and funny people. These are PACKED hoagies. Don't order extra of anything. It's already on there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Cheesesteak

Jared

Food here is good, but they always find a way to mess up my order about every other time I go here. I never say anything because I'm not someone who speaks up about things like that. Plus I always take my food home. I usually order either a ham or a turkey hoagie with lettuce, onions, and mayonnaise. Most recently my turkey sub had tomatoes on it. So I picked them off, but then I noticed they forgot the onions. Little things like that they manage to get wrong. The workers just need to pay better attention.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Candice Biegon

First time eating here and we got the cheeseburger hoagie, bacon cheeseburger hoagie, a small pizza and a chicken strip basket. It was amazing!! The reviews don’t do this place justice, great service and great food, will be back again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...