Baltimore Hill Creamery Ice Cream Parlor

We went searching for ice cream and came upon this cute tucked away off the street shop that was sandwiched between The Maryland Sutler & Ladies & Gents 1863 Boutique. There were some delicious sounding choices so we went with a flight of 6 scoops. What a great idea!!! The ice cream is creamy and the flavors are pronounced.

We stopped here on 30 Sept 2025 after finding Lulu’s closed for no posted reason.
My brother-in-law had Cookies and Cream and I had Chocolate Marshmallow in a Waffle Cone. Total bill $11
Very smooth product for my tastebuds.
The receipt still shows the Merchantile Museum address on it.
They also decorated for Halloween so don’t be scared walking to the side of the building to get your treats!

This ice cream is average at best. Ordered butter pecan I cream and could not find pecans. The one I found were few and small crumbs. The flavor was average. My wife makes better homemade butter pecan.
Very disappointed, do better. I thought it was Mr G's, not even close

The ice cream was AMAZING. In my opinion the best around. the owner was so welcoming and the counter help was just the same. Do yourself a favor and try this place

Ice cream amazing! We walked and arrived after closing…. And the ice cream lady still accommodated us… Great ice cream and great service..

Wonderful service! Great ice cream and the owner was super sweet!

I really like the ice cream here I've tried it a couple times. I really like that Olde timey ice cream bicycle that sells ice cream

Ice cream is great. You can order flights and try several flavors at once which we thought was really creative

Terrible experience. Service was poor. Closed around us at 8:45 even though they are supposed to close at 9:30 on Friday. Asked to leave the outside porch at 8:55 because they were closed. Ugh. Never again.

I’ve had nothing but good experiences here. Until today, the gentleman working had such an attitude for absolutely no reason. With everyone in front of me. I noticed on my receipt it said blueberry when I ordered banana. No big deal I wanna make sure I’m getting what I asked for. “Well that’s what I put it in as…” ok man I’m just making sure again I’m getting what I asked for. Well as he proceeds to finish my order he gently slams it on the counter and says “there’s your order.” I’m not one to complain and honestly this is my first google review I’ve ever left. But I’ve worked in customer service and food that that not how you treat a customer.

Well worth the money for a double scoop . Been to every ice cream shop in gettyburg their double scoop is the biggest,the chocolate chip cookie dough has alot more chocolate chips and big peices of cookie dough says my daughter lol.

Great little ice cream shop in Gettysburg. Good flavors and ice cream was tasty.

Nice shady spot! Good ice cream & milkshakes!

Vey tasty

Long wait for ice cream. I think there was only one person working. I had the pateiot sundae....was very melty when I got it. I cant explain why....and it was small.