Baltimore Hill Creamery Ice Cream Parlor
252 Baltimore St, Gettysburg
(717) 398-4658
Customers' Favorites
Ice Cream Flight
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We went searching for ice cream and came upon this cute tucked away off the street shop that was sandwiched between The Maryland Sutler & Ladies & Gents 1863 Boutique. There were some delicious sounding choices so we went with a flight of 6 scoops. What a great idea!!! The ice cream is creamy and the flavors are pronounced.
We stopped here on 30 Sept 2025 after finding Lulu’s closed for no posted reason.
My brother-in-law had Cookies and Cream and I had Chocolate Marshmallow in a Waffle Cone. Total bill $11
Very smooth product for my tastebuds.
The receipt still shows the Merchantile Museum address on it.
They also decorated for Halloween so don’t be scared walking to the side of the building to get your treats!
My brother-in-law had Cookies and Cream and I had Chocolate Marshmallow in a Waffle Cone. Total bill $11
Very smooth product for my tastebuds.
The receipt still shows the Merchantile Museum address on it.
They also decorated for Halloween so don’t be scared walking to the side of the building to get your treats!
This ice cream is average at best. Ordered butter pecan I cream and could not find pecans. The one I found were few and small crumbs. The flavor was average. My wife makes better homemade butter pecan.
Very disappointed, do better. I thought it was Mr G's, not even close
Very disappointed, do better. I thought it was Mr G's, not even close
You May Also Like
Farnsworth House Inn - 401 Baltimore St
![]()
Tours, American, Bed & Breakfast, Vegetarian
Reid's Winery Tasting Room and Cider House - 400 Baltimore St
![]()
Wineries, Cideries, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Sweney's Tavern - 401 Baltimore St
![]()
Bar, American, Pet Friendly