Lulu's Finest Ice Cream is so good! So many amazing flavors!
Stephanie T
The menu lists 25+ flavors but only had 10 or so. Had three freezers of all the same flavors. Ice cream tasted like sunscreen…maybe freezer burnt. Definitely not the “finest”
Brooklynn Fitzsimmons
I would give negative stars if I could. We stopped here after dinner and no one was behind the counter. We waited and finally a man came from the back. He immediately had an attitude. He told us what you see is what they have and not to read the board behind him with all the flavors. We looked at the ice cream for a second and it was all starting to melt. BUT THEN the look this man gave my deaf son who yelled because he was excited for ice cream, was enough for me to turn around and walk out. Absolutely not. Learn some manners. We went to Cone Sweet Cone up the road and they were so kind to my kids and the ice cream was amazing.
Andrew Olsen
Flavor of ice cream was off and it had a terrible texture.
Sarah De Felice
Something is off about the flavor. My daughter ordered cookies and cream, took one bite, and quietly asked us to take it and let her order another flavor. It had a spice flavoring to it. Almost like too much extract was used. Her second choice, cookie dough, also tasted off to us. Both of my girls have never had ice cream they didn’t like and unfortunately, they didn’t like this. I enjoyed the homemade waffle cone.
Kandice Avery
The lovely girl working was handling it like a boss. She was slammed!! Ice-cream was delish!!
Mary Youngblood
Ice cream sounded good so decided to try this place but won't be going back. Ice cream was freezer burnt and cones are stale
Kai Tilvan
What a sweet little sweet spot!
But the adjoining lounge is looooong. I was surprised and impressed by the bar.
Oh, the ice cream was 10/10 and a thousand chef kisses. The perfect treat for a hot day.
Glenn Landstrom
Ice cream tasted fine. Quite expensive though for the smallest single scoops I've ever seen (possibly just the server). Also probably not the best idea for an ice cream place to be connected to a wood fire BBQ restaurant... quite warm in there with limited seating.
Stephanie Robles
The ice cream was melted and looked disgusting. Serving that trash for $5 a cup is outrageous. The girl working there was really sweet. I don’t remember her name but she wore a bandana, and I felt so bad that she had to stand back there all day in a non-air conditioned parlor unable to sell any product. DO NOT go here if you want quality ice cream. I decided to take my daughter to Mr. G’s instead. There’s plenty of other options in Gettysburg, don’t waste your money here.
Wow! 5.50 for a tiny scoop in a cup. My bad for not reading the reviews or the price before I ordered. The server was very nice but, I've never been charged that for next to nothing. Never again.
Seanna m
Went in and it felt like it was 100 degrees inside. We felt so bad for the poor girl working. She was so obviously uncomfortable. Then we got our ice cream, and it was so close to completely melted it was nearly inedible. I don't believe for a moment that those in charge aren't aware of the conditions inside.
Christian Spitler
Service was poor. Lady was not behind the ice cream counter for a while... Not sure where she was. Ice cream itself was a nice consistency and good flavor, but will not be going again. They were out of their homemade waffle cones by 7pm on a Saturday. Too small portions as well.
Kyle Sweeney
Upon entering Lulu’s Finest Ice Cream, I was greeted by a nice woman named Amelia. She was very welcoming and actually was personable with flavor recommendations and was great with service even with it being busy! She recommended the toasted coconut as well as the cherry vanilla flavor to me; which are flavors I would never go for. They both were seriously good flavors! But, the service was better. Thank you Amelia for all of your help today and thank you Lulu’s. I will be back.
Kylee Heider
The ice cream was good but the young lady behind the counter could use a sense of humor and a couple of smiles.
Lulu's Finest Ice Cream is so good! So many amazing flavors!
The menu lists 25+ flavors but only had 10 or so. Had three freezers of all the same flavors. Ice cream tasted like sunscreen…maybe freezer burnt. Definitely not the “finest”
I would give negative stars if I could. We stopped here after dinner and no one was behind the counter. We waited and finally a man came from the back. He immediately had an attitude. He told us what you see is what they have and not to read the board behind him with all the flavors. We looked at the ice cream for a second and it was all starting to melt. BUT THEN the look this man gave my deaf son who yelled because he was excited for ice cream, was enough for me to turn around and walk out. Absolutely not. Learn some manners. We went to Cone Sweet Cone up the road and they were so kind to my kids and the ice cream was amazing.
Flavor of ice cream was off and it had a terrible texture.
Something is off about the flavor. My daughter ordered cookies and cream, took one bite, and quietly asked us to take it and let her order another flavor. It had a spice flavoring to it. Almost like too much extract was used. Her second choice, cookie dough, also tasted off to us. Both of my girls have never had ice cream they didn’t like and unfortunately, they didn’t like this. I enjoyed the homemade waffle cone.
The lovely girl working was handling it like a boss. She was slammed!! Ice-cream was delish!!
Ice cream sounded good so decided to try this place but won't be going back. Ice cream was freezer burnt and cones are stale
What a sweet little sweet spot!
But the adjoining lounge is looooong. I was surprised and impressed by the bar.
Oh, the ice cream was 10/10 and a thousand chef kisses. The perfect treat for a hot day.
Ice cream tasted fine. Quite expensive though for the smallest single scoops I've ever seen (possibly just the server). Also probably not the best idea for an ice cream place to be connected to a wood fire BBQ restaurant... quite warm in there with limited seating.
The ice cream was melted and looked disgusting. Serving that trash for $5 a cup is outrageous. The girl working there was really sweet. I don’t remember her name but she wore a bandana, and I felt so bad that she had to stand back there all day in a non-air conditioned parlor unable to sell any product. DO NOT go here if you want quality ice cream. I decided to take my daughter to Mr. G’s instead. There’s plenty of other options in Gettysburg, don’t waste your money here.
Restaurantji Recommends
Wow! 5.50 for a tiny scoop in a cup. My bad for not reading the reviews or the price before I ordered. The server was very nice but, I've never been charged that for next to nothing. Never again.
Went in and it felt like it was 100 degrees inside. We felt so bad for the poor girl working. She was so obviously uncomfortable. Then we got our ice cream, and it was so close to completely melted it was nearly inedible. I don't believe for a moment that those in charge aren't aware of the conditions inside.
Service was poor. Lady was not behind the ice cream counter for a while... Not sure where she was. Ice cream itself was a nice consistency and good flavor, but will not be going again. They were out of their homemade waffle cones by 7pm on a Saturday. Too small portions as well.
Upon entering Lulu’s Finest Ice Cream, I was greeted by a nice woman named Amelia. She was very welcoming and actually was personable with flavor recommendations and was great with service even with it being busy! She recommended the toasted coconut as well as the cherry vanilla flavor to me; which are flavors I would never go for. They both were seriously good flavors! But, the service was better. Thank you Amelia for all of your help today and thank you Lulu’s. I will be back.
The ice cream was good but the young lady behind the counter could use a sense of humor and a couple of smiles.
Loading...