Pretty good pizza, certainly the best we've found so far in Gettysburg. Professional tip, always look for the oldest surviving pizza shop in a college town. It's been there that long for a reason.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tara Thurston
We had pizza delivered . Because we are vacation. It was delicious. Order x-cheese. Didn't need to. But it was AMAZING. Also gluten free pizza was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. THANK YOU. ALSO WAS STILL STEAMING HOT WHEN IT GOT HERE.WOW. A MUST TRY.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ethan Edinger
Awesome small pizza shop with really good variety. Awesome staff and overall an amazing experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza House, Pepperoni Pizza
Carmine Linguini
I guess if you're a drunk college kid it's ok 🤷🏻♂️... Cheese was ok i guess!?! Why was the sauce sweet 😩 Please take me back to New York 😭
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Fred McDowell
We have tried all the other pizza places in town, saving Pizza House for last; we kinda had low expectations because it’s so close to the college. Tonight we tried the pizza and we honestly think it’s the best around! Crispy crust, good ingredients and great flavor has made THIS our place of choice. Thanks PH!
Wesley King
Place sucks
John Druin
Showed up an hour before closing lady was rude and said they’re out of pizzas. How is a pizza place out of pizzas? Asked if she could make one she said no and laughed at me.
Edit: owner your response was absolutely pathetic and when I say an employee laughed at me the first thing that should come out of your mouth is a lengthy apology. Learn from this. Or I’ll get the health inspector out there and we will see who’s really laughing. (Not a chance that place passes health inspection)
Grace
Pizzas are the best and the subs are a must for us, too! Our favorite place in town with quick, friendly service!
John Caccioppoli
Keep away. The pizza's are small for their size. If you want something edible, go when the owner is there during the day. His aunts work the night shift, and they are not as good at making pizza.
I was in town for a wedding and needed to get something to eat. This looked good. Let me tell you, it was not. If I could give zero stars, I would. I ordered through their website but it was delivered by door dash. My delivery person was great. The people at the store, were not. The food showed up cold. It wasn't the delivery person's daily. It was literally right around the corner from where I was staying. The food was cold, not very tasty and all around just lacking. They didn't have the onion rings or diet mountain dew that we ordered which caused a delay in receiving our order. The manager was upset that he had to deal with substitutions. Honestly, I definitely wouldn't recommend this place to anyone unless you're going to eat there. But the taste overall was severely lacking so I'm not even sure that it would be good if you ate there. The price you pay is most definitely not equal to the quality of food you receive. I spent well over $50 and the food was more equal to $20 worth.
Tammy Hughes
Nice service. Great pizza! Super quick. The Hawaiian pizza was the best I've had on this area.
Susan Shroyer
Food was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christian Reed
Reminds me of the small town pizza place from when I was growing up. Extremely nice staff, good pizza and very fair prices. Wife was starving after a rainy day and this hit the spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
darah gardner
Really hard to rate this trip. . The food tasted amazing- the issue was for $10, the grilled chicken salad absolutely left me wanting a bit more. A layer of iceberg lettuce, which is fine, with eight less then bite size pieces of cut up chicken breast… My kid loved the cheesesteak Stromboli. It’s been a little bit since I’ve been to Pizza House, but I’ve been eating there since 1995. We will definitely eat there again soon, but will stick with pizza items
Pretty good pizza, certainly the best we've found so far in Gettysburg. Professional tip, always look for the oldest surviving pizza shop in a college town. It's been there that long for a reason.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
We had pizza delivered . Because we are vacation. It was delicious. Order x-cheese. Didn't need to. But it was AMAZING. Also gluten free pizza was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. THANK YOU.
ALSO WAS STILL STEAMING HOT WHEN IT GOT HERE.WOW. A MUST TRY.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome small pizza shop with really good variety. Awesome staff and overall an amazing experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza House, Pepperoni Pizza
I guess if you're a drunk college kid it's ok 🤷🏻♂️... Cheese was ok i guess!?! Why was the sauce sweet 😩 Please take me back to New York 😭
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
We have tried all the other pizza places in town, saving Pizza House for last; we kinda had low expectations because it’s so close to the college. Tonight we tried the pizza and we honestly think it’s the best around! Crispy crust, good ingredients and great flavor has made THIS our place of choice. Thanks PH!
Place sucks
Showed up an hour before closing lady was rude and said they’re out of pizzas. How is a pizza place out of pizzas? Asked if she could make one she said no and laughed at me.
Edit: owner your response was absolutely pathetic and when I say an employee laughed at me the first thing that should come out of your mouth is a lengthy apology. Learn from this. Or I’ll get the health inspector out there and we will see who’s really laughing. (Not a chance that place passes health inspection)
Pizzas are the best and the subs are a must for us, too! Our favorite place in town with quick, friendly service!
Keep away.
The pizza's are small for their size.
If you want something edible, go when the owner is there during the day. His aunts work the night shift, and they are not as good at making pizza.
Delivery on time - great pizzas !
Restaurantji Recommends
I was in town for a wedding and needed to get something to eat. This looked good. Let me tell you, it was not. If I could give zero stars, I would. I ordered through their website but it was delivered by door dash. My delivery person was great. The people at the store, were not. The food showed up cold. It wasn't the delivery person's daily. It was literally right around the corner from where I was staying. The food was cold, not very tasty and all around just lacking. They didn't have the onion rings or diet mountain dew that we ordered which caused a delay in receiving our order. The manager was upset that he had to deal with substitutions. Honestly, I definitely wouldn't recommend this place to anyone unless you're going to eat there. But the taste overall was severely lacking so I'm not even sure that it would be good if you ate there. The price you pay is most definitely not equal to the quality of food you receive. I spent well over $50 and the food was more equal to $20 worth.
Nice service. Great pizza! Super quick. The Hawaiian pizza was the best I've had on this area.
Food was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Reminds me of the small town pizza place from when I was growing up. Extremely nice staff, good pizza and very fair prices. Wife was starving after a rainy day and this hit the spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really hard to rate this trip. . The food tasted amazing- the issue was for $10, the grilled chicken salad absolutely left me wanting a bit more. A layer of iceberg lettuce, which is fine, with eight less then bite size pieces of cut up chicken breast…
My kid loved the cheesesteak Stromboli. It’s been a little bit since I’ve been to Pizza House, but I’ve been eating there since 1995.
We will definitely eat there again soon, but will stick with pizza items
Service: 5
Loading...