The Upper Crust

19 York St, Gettysburg
(717) 549-2444

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Roo Mathieu

Came in and my kids wanted to sit at the window , I asked nicely if we could since there were 2 tables open, the lady chuckled and said you'll have to wait a few minutes! I said nevermind its fine. Waitress came and wasn't friendly either. Brought out our cheese fries not even warm at all. Then brought our pizza and then never came back. Our drinks were empty the whole time. We were done eating and I waited 25 minutes until I went up to the front desk to ask the lady if I could get my bill. Still nothing. Waited a while longer and got another lady and she brought me a box and took our credit card. I was kind to the Waitress the whole time. She literally just didn't come back. Will not be coming back.

Shawn Kint

Hmmmm, arrived at 10 and was told their signature drink was dumped for the night with 2 hours left until close. At 11 they started collecting drinks and kicking people out, guess they aren’t open until 12. Very rude management, not the first bad experience here, won’t be back.

Ernie Ruiz

Evangeline is awesome. Helped serve ice cream at Lulu's for my tour group. We all love Evangeline now.

Isabelle Gaydon

Upper crust is amazing, bartender Maddy is awesome!!!

Khaliq Coleman

Food is 🔥 great vibes…games in the back..good bartenders ask for Maddie she’s awesome

Oliver Adley

Maddie was great

Logan Sneed

Very Good

Doty McDowell

Awesome atmosphere and fantastic pizza!

Tony

My bartender was Bailee she was very friendly and courteous. She kept my drinks flowing and continued to check in with me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane Holland

Good afternoon. My server was Bailee she was amazing and the food was incredible We had the spinach pizza .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sue Alongi

Bailee was our server. We had the margherita pizza it was superb and so was the service. Bailee was an absolute sweet heart. We will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

onthegoboomer

This is a very interesting restaurant. It has a LOT of stimulation so if you are looking for a loud and busy place to go this is it. You can play skee ball, Foosball, and other games as well as a plethora of TV shows and sports to watch. The doors were all open so it was cold but the wood fired pizza was very good. It lacked the meat but it made up for for it with flavor. The hush puppies were good but the fried green tomatoes were too full of oil to enjoy any flavor from them. We didn’t like the wings. The brisket was okay. I would say if you come here stick with the pizza and you’ll be very happy. It’s a good place to come with kids, they can enjoy the games while you try and get a conversation but be aware it’s loud here. ?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Griffin Idk

Food came out fast. But it was undercooked and honestly they ignored us for long enough that it really made sense why they rushed it. Then waited 20 min at bar for to finally have to flag down a manager to checkout. The bartenders are just plain and stupid.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sarah Veraldi

The experience I had yesterday (Tuesday) was different than the one I had a few months ago. Our server, Jen, was nice. The appetizer was good (macaroni and cheese balls-you get three but enough for two people to split), my bfs gyro was generous and tasty ( he keeps talking about that) however my $20 pizza was a complete let down. I got the Brussel sprout and bacon jam etc. The Brussel sprouts were NOT cooked so they were literally hard, chunk, sliced Brussel sprouts with a half tsp of bacon jam on each slice. The pizza was over all disappointing. We had it boxed and left. Everyone who tried it said the same thing that this isn't the "standard" over there and I should of said something but at that point it...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Ronald Clark

The arugula pizza was disappointing, it had so much semolina on the crust that my plate looked like a sandy beach afterwards. The undercarriage was still white and the crust was not even browned. Sorry excuse for a 'neapolitan' pizza.. The wings and labneh/hummus were good, although the pita was crunchy because of how much semolina was on it. Cheesecake brownie is to die for! Our server was fantastic, unfortunately they didn't seem to have many tables.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loading...