The Upper Crust
19 York St, Gettysburg
(717) 549-2444
Customers' Favorites
Brick Oven Wood Fired Pizza
Yukon Fries with Aioli
Roasted Cauliflower
Mozzarella Sticks
The Cheesesteak
Beer Selection
The Margherita
Brisket Pizza
Chicken Wings
Great Pizza
Menu
Photos
+53 photos
+52 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This is a very interesting restaurant. It has a LOT of stimulation so if you are looking for a loud and busy place to go this is it. You can play skee ball, Foosball, and other games as well as a plethora of TV shows and sports to watch. The doors were all open so it was cold but the wood fired pizza was very good. It lacked the meat but it made up for for it with flavor. The hush puppies were good but the fried green tomatoes were too full of oil to enjoy any flavor from them....
The arugula pizza was disappointing, it had so much semolina on the crust that my plate looked like a sandy beach afterwards. The undercarriage was still white and the crust was not even browned. Sorry excuse for a 'neapolitan' pizza.. The wings and labneh/hummus were good, although the pita was crunchy because of how much semolina was on it. Cheesecake brownie is to die for! Our server was fantastic, unfortunately they didn't seem to have many tables.
Was really hoping the prices would reflect a real quality pizza. I knew being a brick wood fired oven the pizza would be small. But I didn't expect the top of the pizza to be so nicely done while the bottom was still under cooked. I really should have known better as order to ready was only 12mins, They have a lot of specialized pizza which I love as the same old toppings have lost their appeal. But the undercooked dough had me wishing I had tried somewhere else.
If...
If...
You May Also Like
BOROUGH BBQ - 15 York St
![]()
Barbecue, Barbeque, Cocktail Bar
Lulu's Finest Ice Cream - 11 York St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream
Chinatown Kitchen - 25 York St
![]()
Chinese