The Upper Crust
19 York St, Gettysburg
(717) 549-2444
Customers' Favorites
Brick Oven Wood Fired Pizza
Yukon Fries with Aioli
Sweet and Spicy Pizza
Roasted Cauliflower
Mozzarella Sticks
The Cheesesteak
Beer Selection
The Margherita
Brisket Pizza
Chicken Wings
Menu
Photos
+60 photos
+59 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We went for a class field trip, 130 8th graders. They had archade games to keep them entertained and I loved how spacious it was for all of us. We only had pizza and salad for food which is the reason for the rating. The pizza was okay but the salad had a strange dressing on it. I would definitely go back to try something else though with a different environment.
We came here for my granddaughter’s 12th birthday. We had a great time, playing games, the spinach pizza was amazing, as well as their Syrian shawarma. Had a great conversation about the history of the building with the manager, Erin, what a great experience!! Alexis was our server and she was amazing!! Will recommended to everyone I know!!
You May Also Like
BOROUGH BBQ - 15 York St
![]()
Barbecue, Barbeque, Cocktail Bar
Lulu's Finest Ice Cream - 11 York St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream
Chinatown Kitchen - 25 York St
![]()
Chinese, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
But dear god, expect to wait hours for your order. There’s clearly WAY too many tables for the kitchen to properly support.
Only to get home and discover an entire dinner was left off the Togo portion of the order. So wasted money on top of all that …