Windy Hill Bake Shop

Windy Hill fry pies are the best!! It's usually self service and the dogs will just bark at you, but that's pretty much it.

The journey to this bake shop is a story.

We drive into an Amish farm and saw no cars parked, nor a sign telling us where the bakery is. We drive deeper into the barn, almost knocking over the family dog. There were some dogs in cages barking at us, not sure if it was to welcome us, or to warn us.

We saw a guy who seem to work there, or owns the place. He told us that we went too far in, and said “turn around, it’s the red shed”.

We turned the car around, again, looking around to see which of those could be the bakery. We saw a hand written board “open”.

We go in. Shelves were almost empty except for a few trays of whoopie pies and some fry pies in the refrigerator. No one was inside except a box saying “self service”. “Interesting” we thought. Never have we seen such an establishment that was based on trust.

OH yes, how were the pies you say? SO GOOD. Just gotta bake them real good for a little. The whoopie pies are also really moist and cream not coyingly sweet.

Not much in the self serve shop to choose from.

Attended an auction and bought fry pies (apple, blueberry, peach, strawberry, lemon). They are so incredibly delicious!!! Wish i lived closer, but will definitely find a way to drive back and get more.

I want to say I had one of your vanilla iced buns it was the best I have ever eaten

Awesomeness absolutely ?

I met Windy Hill products at The Apple Festival in Unicom, TN the weekend of Oct. 7, 2023. The Pumpkin Cream Fried Pie is out of this world delicious!

Have not been there but I am willing to drive there ,had a blueberry fry pie I picked up at local orchard,my God it was delicious, need to try others.

If you want to fry pie they have it Amish run.

Cinnabar buns are out of this world

I have not been to this establishment personally but am a devoted follower of Von Thun Farms in Washington NJ. I saw these Iced Cinnamon Buns for Sale in their farm store. I thought my partner would enjoy these. I was correct they are extraordinarily good. This kind of dessert is not my thing but I did enjoy these Cinnamon Buns too! It is the Maple Icing for me! I would like to purchase another item from your bakery another time I stop by the farm. I hope to see this bakery label so I can try another dessert. I recommend you try- you will not be disappointed.

I went to my local farm in White Marsh, Maryland and pick up a Coconut Crème Fry Pie made by Windy Hill Bake Shop and goodness I think I about died and went to heaven! I love that little pie so much I’d be willing to travel for quantity and freeze them. I really enjoy the mixture inside! So creamy and coconuty! Rich and oh so delicious, they should change the name to heavenly pie because that’s exactly what it is!

I went to my local farm in White Marsh, Maryland and pick up a Coconut Crème Fry Pie made by Windy Hill Bake Shop and goodness I think I about died and went to heaven! I love that little pie so much I’d be willing to travel for quantity and freeze them. I really enjoy the mixture inside! So creamy and coconuty! Rich and oh so delicious, they should change the name to heavenly pie because that’s exactly what it is!

Absolutely amazing maple cinnamon buns. Can’t get enough of these wonderful buns. Always fresh and full of cinnamon and maple icing. Yum.

Incredible coconut creme fry pie. Absolutely delicious!