Restaurants in Greencastle

“Casa Agave catered my daughter’s 2025 graduation party and everyone went back for seconds. We had an absolutely delicious nacho bar. We could not have been more pleased!”

“I was shocked at the freshness of the food. There's no a chain-style eatery that can compare!5⭐️I'll travel the 3.5hrs to eat there again.”

“First visit to the restaurant. We went for a birthday celebration with family. The owner went the extra mile to make our time special PLUS the food was great. Highly recommend.”

“Absolutely hands down one of the best if not the best restaurants in Greencastle, PA!! AJ has done a superb job with taking over ownership not to mention keeping the fantastic chefs and I am sure adding new chefs too!

Drinks, alcoholic or nonalcoholic are superb as well! The atmosphere is amazing, great customer service staff, with the choice to eat casual in the bar or restaurant side of the bar or enhance your evening with date night to enjoy the more formal dining experience.

Plus BONUS, for all your event needs you can also book their banquet room for special occasions. We held our daughter’s graduation party here years ago!

Check out these images”

“Great place to eat! Seat yourself, and then our waitress Jessica came over to greet us within minutes! Service was fast, friendly and the food was delicious! Decently priced too! Great atmosphere and kid friendly! Definitely recommend Brother's Pizza- we will be going back again! Thank you Jessica ☺️”

“It has been years since we had been here (no reason other than it hadn't been top of mind) and decided to give it a try and was very glad we did. The steak tips and the haddock were absolutely delicious, along with the roasted potatoes and green beans, plus the fresh baked bread. Stacey, our server was friendly and attentive. Will definitely be back again soon.”

“Best pizza in the area by far”

“I love Hardee’s but seriously 4 onion rings!!!!”

“I have to say, wow, we are very impressed with the new old bay chicken tenders. Keep up the excellent work. I highly recommend eating here—my 3 yr. Old is tough to please and very picky, but he loves the food also. Thank you for everything. Enjoyable environment. The people are so kind. If you have high expectations of cleanliness and love home-cooked meals, Gibbles is the place to go. Ps, the cupcakes are out of this world delicious.”

“I've been going here for so long and should have reviewed long ago but better late than never! Truly they've got great food and with costs rising everywhere you can still get delicious dinner for a reasonable cost when you decide to head here for dinner.

Their pork lo mein is delicious, always hot and fresh and with the perfect amount of sauce. Oh, and the crab rangoon? Delicious. Perfectly crispy on the outside and hot and creamy on the inside. I get take-out and always end up eating a few on my way home because they're just that good, who can wait to dig right in?

I feel really lucky that we have such a tasty place in town and so accessible. I fully recommend it if you're craving tasty food.”

“Godfathers has always been my favorite pizza since my childhood.

I have tried every pizza place in Hagerstown before starting to look in adjacent towns before discovering that this quaint lil gas station serves pizza as good as I remember it.

English is not the first language of the employees I spoke to, but they were incredibly kind and got the orders right over the phone and in person. That's what counts at the end of the day.”

“it was great to find a truck stop with a real restaurant. food was great and large portions”

“Shirley is hands down one of the main reasons we stop at Burger King in the evenings! My kids always say how kind she is! She is a gem! She always thanks us for coming, is so friendly, always smiling. I have never had this service from a drive thru employee before! She also keeps the drive thru moving, makes sure order is correct, and makes sure food is fresh.”

“The best subway around ?”

“The person who helped me over the phone had an excellent phone presence and was very helpful. When I picked up my order, she was pleasant, cheerful and communicated very well. I cannot remember her name, but would return again and again to receive this level of customer service.”

“Mikie's has been a fantastic family environment for over 20 years! Whenever I visited my family up north as a kid we would come to Mikie's for ice cream after running around all day. I hadn't been there in over 20 years but, when I walked through the doors it was exactly the same feeling. Same look, same great service. The place I enjoyed as a child I was able to share with my son. Definitely stop by Mikie's! I know I will always make a trip through whenever I'm in town!”

“It's absolutely fantastic. There's got to be a hundred or so coffee bean varieties from around the world, each with a specific description. So, you can learn a little bit before asking questions. All days, all employees, always friendly. And of course, it smells fantastic as well.”

“Just a wonderful place! You'll love their offerings!”

“The coconut cream pie and pecan sticky buns are awesome! The customer service is just as awesome. Highly recommend! 😃”

“First time here! This place is a hidden lil gem. definitely a must!!”