Lizzy's

2753 Buchanan Trail W, Greencastle
(717) 597-2888

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Megan Krepps

We stopped at this diner since we were in the area and saw other reviews stating how good the burgers and shakes were and they did not disappoint. The burger was the best I've ever had. The service was great and super friendly. This was a gem of a find. I will make the 1 hour trip down just for another burger. Do yourself a favor and get the peanut butter milkshake ( though the raspberry was pretty good too!)

Chas

Will not order again....had surf n turf sub....chicken reminded me of cheap Chinese restaurants chicken...ie...cat meat...sorry

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Doug O'Neal

This place doesn't look like much from the outside. But the food was great, but the service was better and that's rare to find nowadays.

Tiffany Malone

10/10 recommend lizzys we order from them all the time and they never disappoint!! Staff is super friendly, the food is always delicious and piled with toppings!! And they are super quick never wait more than 5-10 mins for pick-ups! They are also very reasonably priced! I’ve had several things off of their menu and haven’t been disappointed! I highly recommend their fries with toppings on them I’ve had a few different ones they are always super delicious!! (The crabby fries and the bacon cheddar ranch fries are my favs)

Tom King

Wanting a good burger and they didn't disappoint. Mac and cheese BBQ, who'd think? It was great.

Ryan Carpenter

Best place you can get a burger from Pennsylvania

Laurie Webb

I had ice cream today from their food truck it was absolutely delicious! I can’t wait to try the Restaurant!!

Tammy Knott

We ordered from Lizzys last night . I got cheeseburger sub with fries & hubby got chicken cheese steak. These was one of the best subs we ever got . They was delicious and we wanted more !! The fries were ok there was more tiny over crispy pieces that we just didn’t care for . I still gave them 5 star bc I can live with some bad fries but those subs were fantastic. I pulled in and service was quick and easy and she was so extremely kind and constantly smiling .

Aleister

This place is great! Cozy little dining area, great customer service, and awesome food! I'll be back for sure!

Lindsay Stotler

Everything was so good and we can't wait to go back again!! Staff is very friendly and helpful

Richard coleman

Ice cream is always good 👍

Chad Mania

The staff are incredible! The food is amazingly delicious and the atmosphere is pleasant. We live an hour away and we will go there just to eat. We did this past Friday afternoon! Thank you to everyone at Lizzy's!👊🙂👍🏻

Amanda Daymude

Great food! I love their burgers but having the healthier options like the bowls was a win for me! The cheesesteak bowl is the bomb!!!!

Steven Wiesen

Small local restaurant. Quick service, excellent dining experience.

Missy D

We come here on occasion and always get the burgers. Last night we went and the burgers were over cooked. We ate them but were not as good as usual. The waitress had many tables and was busy but she did a good job keeping up. Not sure if it’s a new cook or if they were over whelmed with quality control but definitely disappointed this time around.

Update: we went back with a gift card for our previous experience and they redeemed themselves. Thank you!

Loading...