Coffaros' Pizza

116 S Broad St, Grove City
(724) 458-7900

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Meatball Sub
Calzone

Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham.
Cheese Pizza
Our unique cheese blend gives this pizza its full flavored taste.
Steak Pizza
Steak, onions, and green peppers with ranch.
Plain Cheese Pizza
The Works Pizza
Italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, smoked ham, mushrooms, black pearl olives, green peppers, white onions, and banana peppers.
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham and pineapple.
Deluxe Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, white onions, and green peppers.
Veggie Pizza
White onions, green peppers, olives, mushrooms, and banana peppers.
Chicken Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Diced chicken breast, bacon, and ranch.
Chicken and Spinach Pizza
Garlic butter sauce. Topped with garlic, spinach, and chicken.

The Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Red sauce, our unique cheese blend, and topped with pecorino romano.
Sicilian Veggie Pizza
Ranch sauce, broccoli, cauliflower, and cheddar cheese.

Breadsticks

Cheesy Breadsticks
Covered with garlic butter and imported romano cheese, oregano, and a generous portion of our been of shredded cheese. Served with both Coffaro's red sauce and garlic butter.
Breadsticks
Covered with garlic butter and imported Romano cheese and oregano. Served with both Coffaro's red sauce and garlic butter.
Cinnamon Breadsticks
Hot dough bread covered with butter, cinnamon, sugar, and smothered with icing.

Calzones and Stomboli
Calzone
Virginia smoked ham, pepperoni, white onions, banana peppers, green peppers, shredded cheese, and Coffaro's red sauce.
Chicken Calzone
Diced chicken breast, white onions, green peppers, banana peppers, shredded cheese, and Coffaro's red sauce.
Steak Calzone
Steak, white onions, green peppers, shredded cheese, and ranch dressing.
Meatball Calzone
Meatballs, mushrooms, white onions, shredded cheese, and Coffaro's red sauce.
Veggie Calzone
White onions, green peppers, black pearl olives, mushrooms banana peppers, shredded cheese, and Coffaro's red sauce.
Sausage Calzone
Italian sausage, white onions, green peppers, shredded cheese, and Coffaro's red sauce.
Stromboli
Smoked ham, pepperoni, and shredded cheese.

Mains
Wings

Subs
Italian Sub
Smoked ham, cappicola, salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, white onions, and Italian dressing.
Meatball Sub
Sliced meatballs, provolone cheese, and Coffaro's red sauce.
Ham and Cheese Sub
Virginia smoked ham, provolone cheese, white onions, sliced tomato, lettuce, and Italian dressing.
Pizza Sub
Pepperoni, provolone cheese, and Coffaro's red sauce.
Veggie Sub
Tomatoes, white onions, mild peppers, black pearl olives, green peppers, lettuce, provolone cheese, and Italian dressing.
Chicken Sub
Breaded fried chicken, provolone cheese, sliced tomato, lettuce, and mayonnaise.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Breaded fried chicken, bacon, provolone cheese, sliced tomato, lettuce, and ranch dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Breaded fried chicken covered in buffalo sauce, sliced tomato, lettuce, and ranch dressing.
Steak Sub
Steak, white onions, green peppers, provolone cheese, lettuce, and ranch dressing.
Turkey Club
Turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, sliced tomatoes, lettuce, and ranch dressing.

Sides
French Fries
Served with a side of ketchup.
Mozzarella Sticks
Six mozzarella sticks. Served with Coffaro's red sauce.
Jalapeno Poppers
Cream cheese stuffed poppers served with a side of ranch.
Breaded Mushrooms
Breaded portabella mushrooms served with Coffaro's red sauce or ranch.
Zucchini Planks
Battered zucchini planks. Served with a side of ranch.
Onion Rings
Battered onion rings. Served with a side of ketchup.
Chicken Tenders
Breaded chicken tenders served with two sides of barbecue sauce.

Salads
Green Salad
Green peppers, white onions, tomatoes, sliced black pearl olives, and shredded cheese.
Chef Salad
Smoked ham, hard salami, pepperoni, green peppers, white onions, tomatoes, black olives, and shredded cheese.
Chicken Salad
Chicken, fries, onions, tomatoes, and pizza cheese.
Steak Salad
Steak, fries, green peppers, white onions, tomatoes, and shredded cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Fried buffalo chicken, fries, white onions, green peppers, tomatoes, and shredded cheese.

Drinks
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Mountain Dew
Sierra Mist
Dr Pepper
Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+16 photos
Photo credit: google
+15 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Wanted to try some new food while I was in Grove City. Ordered a nice and simple pepperoni pizza, and got it after only 10 minutes. The workers seemed to be having a great time with one another while I was inside, which I love to see at places I visit. I unfortunately had to drive home afterwards, and didn’t get to enjoy my pizza while it was still hot. It was still phenomenal, a typical pizza place pizza, which isn’t a bad thing at all! I would definitely stop by again if...
September 2025
Ordered carryout pizza that was ready in 20 minutes. Arrived at the designated time and the pizza was just out of the oven. The crust was fresh made and cooked nicely, brown and crusty on the ends, but firm and chewy throughout, very evenly cooked.
The toppings were very good, though fresh sliced mushrooms would have been preferred over the canned mushrooms.
That was the only criticism as the pizza was really good. I did prefer it to other pizzas available in...
August 2025
I've been traveling all day and I was really craving some good pizza. The front desk lady at my hotel suggested this place.
If you are in the area, order from here!
This is probably the best pizza I've ever had. Or at least top 2!
The crust was crispy on the outside, warm and chewy on the inside. Perfect tasting sauce, a well balance of sweet to savory.
And the cheese was very fresh and delicious.
I'll be traveling...
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

JIN SUSHI - 138 S Broad St
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegetarian
Parker's Parlor - 113 N Broad St
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Hot Dogs, Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Fox's Pizza Den - 120 N Broad St
Pizza

Coffaros' Pizza

116 S Broad St, Grove City, PA 16127
(724) 458-7900