Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Good take out. Quality of dining in has slipped since the pandemic.

Ended up here by mistake, and it was the best thing to happen all week. Fantastic food!

Great quality food and friendly people

I’ve been here twice now for lunch. Good service, food is pretty solid. Gladly will come back again.

This is our go to pizzeria place of all time.

Nice little spot on the way home from Chambersburg. Wife and I each got a salad. Nothing spectacular, but still enjoyable. Service was quick and kind.

Our first visit to this restaurant was delicious! I ordered the manacotti with salad and bread, and couldn't eat it all that was served. There restaurant side is so clean and cozy. The take out side is separate to eliminate traffic. I liked that idea. Try it out. The smell of Italy cuisine will make your belly growl.

I love their pizzas and subs

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered 4 slices of pizza, went to the bathroom, it was a mess, no soap no toilet paper for my fiancée, things like that make unpleasant but to say the least the food and people were amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 1

Sub had hardly any meat in it!
A/C was not working!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Very hot in the restaurant but their food is awesome!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak

the entrees were okay but the appetizers were better

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

I love to support local. I also have years of customer service. We met my parents halfway. We had reservations. It started out ok. He couldn’t understand I wanted a soda for our 11yr old. He kept saying they had apple juice, I was asking for sprite. Then he brings our 5yr old a huge cup of lemonade with no lid. Our salads didn’t come without onions, dressing took 3x to get. The stuffed shells were dry. Everyone got their food except me. Other tables were being served. We never got our French fries. I tried to cancel my food and fries 3x he just kept saying “oh yes it’s coming “ the whole table is done. I just want to go. They didn’t have soup even though that is a choice with your meal. They never brought garlic bread that is to come with your meal. They gave my aunt the wrong order. They only good thing was the cheese bread. I’m not one to leave a bad review but come on. It was like 1 cook and 1 other man taking orders it’s a holiday. It was a terrible Mothers Day lunch. Took 1.5hrs for pizza, spaghetti and stuffed shells.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

We ordered a cheese pizza and two cheese steaks. They were actually very good. The pizza has a unique flavor and the subs are super good. I recommend their pizza and the steak and cheese.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Honey BBQ wings barely had sauce on them and the wings were so dry and brittle it was like eating splinters. Wasn't happy at all . My son's wings same thing.

Food: 1