the Cake Bar

22 Carlisle St, Hanover
(717) 634-2140

Recent Reviews

Brad

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

MarkJenni A.

Beautiful cakes! Easy to work with and best of all taste delicious. I can't find all the pictures of cakes and cookies they have made for us.

Chloe Meyering

She made our wedding cake and cupcakes last night and they were absolutely perfect! They looked amazing and tasted even better. I would recommend her for any event!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcake

Nicky W

We had coffee and cake to split between two people. The coffee was very good, but the cake was very sad. The cake part was good, but the icing was flavorless and had a stale texture. I would recommend just getting a coffee.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Abigail Gehring

The cake tasted pretty good. It was moist and flavorful. Then… upon enjoying our slice, we found not one, not two, but six hairs, presumably nose hairs, in our single slice. I am appalled.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Brittney Motts-Pritt

I always call The Cake Bar for special occasion desserts including my kid's birthday cakes. They are very responsive, reasonably priced and ofcourse, delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wendee Lewis

I want to love this place. I've gotten a good latte here before. The slices of cakes, however, are not good. The flavor is usually there, but they are SO DRY, likely from being kept too long in a chiller. The frosting is not great and almost impossibly hard to eat anyway. I've tried it twice, so I'll stick to the grocery store when I want a slice of cake "just because."

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Kate Goodnow

Always has fantastic cakes and exceptional service!! Thank you!!!

Victoria Koontz

With the holidays almost here, there is nothing worse than showing up at someone's house with desserts in a plastic container like you purchased at the dollar store. With beautiful desserts comes presentation and the presentation is everything.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Kayleen

Cannot recommend them enough. Gave them an inspiration picture and the fully exceeded my expectations. Absolutely beautiful and their prices are amazing.Will return to business again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Margie Berman

I got an amazing Taylor Swift Eras cake. Every era represented. It’s the most impressive cake I’ve ever seen. The detail was incredible. I know a lot of hard work went into this cake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mitchell Reifinger

Beautiful people, great cakes and pies. And they have orders that you can pick up with a notice

Marc Foutz

I deffenetly got a dry slice, iceing was firm. meh.

Dave Plummer (PA Micro Midgets)

Amanda,Thank you for making our 40th surprise birthday party a smashing hit. Your custom cake and cupcakes were a show-stopper. ***I ordered a Highland Cow 6” cake (peanut butter mousse with chocolate icing) and sixty plus highland cow cupcakes (yellow, chocolate and pumpkin flavors) to supplement.The butter cream frosting had the perfect combination of flavor, smooth texture with just the right amount of sweet. The cake and cupcakes were fresh and moist (even after I had them in the refrigerator for an extended amount of time). The Cake Bar captured the perfect amount of frosting to cake ratio. Each treat was and simply scrumptious.The cake and cupcakes were delicately decorated and exploding with “WOW”. Your skill, creativity and artistic talent are remarkable. Each cupcake and the cake were a work of art of their own.From my initial inquiry, working through a concept and to final delivery, I was given a really personalized and professional service. I couldn’t be more impressed with the finished cake and cupcakes. Everyone loved them. The Cake bar is by far, comparable to none.I will sing the praises of The Cake Bar to anyone with a five star +++ rating an recommend no others. Thank you for your incredible work.Regards,Renee TuckerPA Micro Midgets

Emily Gingras

I was so impressed with my experience here! I sent a photo and my baby’s smash cake turned out better than the photo. It was beautiful and tasty and the customer service was great to work with! Thank you for making this so easy and painless!

Load More