We arrived on time and seated for Fathers Day brunch, very slow service. Waited 10 minutes for water and another 15 to order. Have been going for 15 years and never had such slow service. Some brunch items like the French toast were too small so I advise a side of bacon. The indoor dining was only 1/3 seated but backyard patio full. I'll be sure to request outdoor seating and an earlier reservation the next time.
Megan Beaver
I'm finally able to leave a review for my wedding that took place here in December 2022. Tiffany was supposed to be my wedding coordinator from when I booked in 2020. 2 weeks before my wedding, she let me know she would be on vacation and gave me a random woman I had never met. The day of my wedding, it had snowed about 5 inches and was supposed to be outside, no matter the weather. The coordinator (who doesn't even work there anymore) told me to bring it inside to which I agreed, this was at 10am roughly with the ceremony at 3pm. When I arrived from hair and makeup, everything was smooth. I did not see my coordinator at all and had questions. I found her in the reception area having a panic attack of some sort. She then said she had to leave and gave me a super random server, claiming her to be my 'new coordinator'. This 'new coordinator' brought my ceremony inside on the porch and left it set for dinner claiming 'it can't be unset'. If my friend and officiant at the time didn't work there, it would've been a disaster. The team at Settlers never put out my picture station, stole my vase I brought for props, threw away my cake topper which was personal and a gift. My cake was also wrong and disgusting while falling off the table. They kept 80% of my favors and decor I worked for months on in the back kitchen. We had glass shatter on the dance floor twice and no staff came to help, so my guests had to pick it up by hand. The only way I didn't have a mental breakdown was because of my wonderful DJ and photographer. The 'coordinator' never came back or appeared again after 4pm. I would never ever recommend having a wedding here, ESPECIALLY if you previously worked there. I had reached out to multiple higher ups about my experience, and I was told by a previous worker 'not to answer her because she used to work here and got married for cheap'. It's not the point, the point was I spent all hard earned 6k of my money for my once in a lifetime wedding for it to be in shambles. I'm glad my guests had a great time but I sure didn't. I will always look back at my wedding as a disaster of a day because of The Settlers Inn. To top it off, I called Tiffany the day after to express my disappointment and she was super rude and told me it was my fault it was a disaster.
stone
The food and service were excellent. One improvement on the food is to serve more vegetables with the main course. The service was exceptional. The ambiance truly conducive for a wonderful dining experience. The menu had a broad range of choices which was an improvement over out last experience at Settlers' Inn.
JonK
Always a trusted place to dine for any special day such as a birthday. The salads were delicious. The seeded bread as outstanding as ever. The seafood entree of poached cod with mussels and shrimp was cooked perfectly. The lamb chops were easily enough for two people so only order this for a large appetite. The layered cake also was a serving for two people and outstanding. Even with a new chef this restaurant hasn't missed a beat in its presentation and quality.
MarkR
Excellent service and great food. I was quite taken aback by the $6 charge for ice in our drinks, not accustomed to paying $.50-.60 per cube! Perhaps the next time I will bring my own ice ( or not order a drink, $30 less revenue, $6 less in tips. ) All in all, I find it rather cheesy and don't get the purpose other than to annoy someone who will be paying $70+ plus for a meal and drinks which we did last night. As Dustin Hoffman in Hook would say “poor form “ Settlers Inn. MR Tafton
$50 ribeye steak wasn't charred and when it came out it was 80% mushy fat. Was offered a free coffee when we notified our server. Other than that my wife enjoyed her rack of lamb so it wasn't all bad. Just a shame about the steak
tote
the staff was incredible. had such a personable waitress. we had a delicious dinner. asked for crispy fries and they were crispy. was a nice evening and the staff was working hard the restaurant was busy. we were not rushed at all was a nice relaxing time. i had come in november and was disappointed. my fries were soggy and cool we were served within 5 mins i think food was sitting there. the waitress had little time for us despite how quiet it was. so i was impressed at last nites dinner. the restaurant was ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Nicole Williams
This is a reputable bitcoin investment Platform to invest in. I came in a skeptic but with the price point of $1,500, I made a profit of $19,750. The investment I made came out very good and I'm pleased with Mrs Craig Vanessa trading platform for it's the best I've ever come across and I have referred 6 customers who are also very happy with the results they got. I can recommend her to anybody that seeks help in investing. Her WhatsApp and Email contacts are found on her Facebook 👉 Mrs Craig Vanessa
SusanC
I've been going to Settlers Inn for years. One of my favorite places. I love holidays when the piano players is there, entertaining us. Food was very good, from the appetizers to the delicious desserts and coffee. Have many friends there over the years.
We enjoyed it but service was slow, was seated and sat there for almost half hour before our waitress came and asked us for drunk ordered maybe should of had another server on hand. Just a suggestion
JoshuaH
We chose the Settlers in for a place to dine in celebration of our anniversary. The Settlers Inn was highly recommended by a friend of mine. We arrived for an early dinner. The atmosphere was quaint the attention of the staff to our needs was superior to most places. The food was amazing! We give the chef our compliments. In short if you are looking for a dinning experience with charm, here is the place.
TheHappyEater
Settlers Inn, Hawley, PA. 2024: The night my partner and I went it was a special Jazz Night, with a wonderful Jazz Band playing (do not know their name). There was a prefix menu just for that event. We're from Queens, NY, so we have attitude and can be hard to please (sorry to admit, but being honest). I LOVED MY EVENING THERE. The woman attending to us checked my coat in, and the evening began. The menu was not overly extensive, so it was easy to narrow down and pick what we wanted. The decor (we sat in the main dining room) gave me the feeling that I was in an elegantly rustic world, a bit from the past. Exactly what we wanted based on the exterior of the Inn. The food was delicious and innovative. The portion was not too much, not too little. Looking forward to going back.
MichaelP
We were treated immediately and we're acknowledged about our anniversary and request to be seated by the fireplace. The server created us and also wished us a happy anniversary. The food was delicious, but took a little longer than expected.
What an outstanding valentine's day dinner experience!! This rivaled the best dinners we have experienced in the Philadelphia restaurants. The ambiance was spectacular and the service outstanding!! This was truly one of the best dining experiences we have had!!!
Great burgers and brew Tuesday nights.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We arrived on time and seated for Fathers Day brunch, very slow service. Waited 10 minutes for water and another 15 to order. Have been going for 15 years and never had such slow service. Some brunch items like the French toast were too small so I advise a side of bacon. The indoor dining was only 1/3 seated but backyard patio full. I'll be sure to request outdoor seating and an earlier reservation the next time.
I'm finally able to leave a review for my wedding that took place here in December 2022. Tiffany was supposed to be my wedding coordinator from when I booked in 2020. 2 weeks before my wedding, she let me know she would be on vacation and gave me a random woman I had never met. The day of my wedding, it had snowed about 5 inches and was supposed to be outside, no matter the weather. The coordinator (who doesn't even work there anymore) told me to bring it inside to which I agreed, this was at 10am roughly with the ceremony at 3pm. When I arrived from hair and makeup, everything was smooth. I did not see my coordinator at all and had questions. I found her in the reception area having a panic attack of some sort. She then said she had to leave and gave me a super random server, claiming her to be my 'new coordinator'. This 'new coordinator' brought my ceremony inside on the porch and left it set for dinner claiming 'it can't be unset'. If my friend and officiant at the time didn't work there, it would've been a disaster. The team at Settlers never put out my picture station, stole my vase I brought for props, threw away my cake topper which was personal and a gift. My cake was also wrong and disgusting while falling off the table. They kept 80% of my favors and decor I worked for months on in the back kitchen. We had glass shatter on the dance floor twice and no staff came to help, so my guests had to pick it up by hand. The only way I didn't have a mental breakdown was because of my wonderful DJ and photographer. The 'coordinator' never came back or appeared again after 4pm. I would never ever recommend having a wedding here, ESPECIALLY if you previously worked there. I had reached out to multiple higher ups about my experience, and I was told by a previous worker 'not to answer her because she used to work here and got married for cheap'. It's not the point, the point was I spent all hard earned 6k of my money for my once in a lifetime wedding for it to be in shambles. I'm glad my guests had a great time but I sure didn't. I will always look back at my wedding as a disaster of a day because of The Settlers Inn. To top it off, I called Tiffany the day after to express my disappointment and she was super rude and told me it was my fault it was a disaster.
The food and service were excellent. One improvement on the food is to serve more vegetables with the main course. The service was exceptional. The ambiance truly conducive for a wonderful dining experience. The menu had a broad range of choices which was an improvement over out last experience at Settlers' Inn.
Always a trusted place to dine for any special day such as a birthday. The salads were delicious. The seeded bread as outstanding as ever. The seafood entree of poached cod with mussels and shrimp was cooked perfectly. The lamb chops were easily enough for two people so only order this for a large appetite. The layered cake also was a serving for two people and outstanding. Even with a new chef this restaurant hasn't missed a beat in its presentation and quality.
Excellent service and great food. I was quite taken aback by the $6 charge for ice in our drinks, not accustomed to paying $.50-.60 per cube! Perhaps the next time I will bring my own ice ( or not order a drink, $30 less revenue, $6 less in tips. ) All in all, I find it rather cheesy and don't get the purpose other than to annoy someone who will be paying $70+ plus for a meal and drinks which we did last night. As Dustin Hoffman in Hook would say “poor form “ Settlers Inn. MR Tafton
$50 ribeye steak wasn't charred and when it came out it was 80% mushy fat. Was offered a free coffee when we notified our server. Other than that my wife enjoyed her rack of lamb so it wasn't all bad. Just a shame about the steak
the staff was incredible. had such a personable waitress. we had a delicious dinner. asked for crispy fries and they were crispy. was a nice evening and the staff was working hard the restaurant was busy. we were not rushed at all was a nice relaxing time. i had come in november and was disappointed. my fries were soggy and cool we were served within 5 mins i think food was sitting there. the waitress had little time for us despite how quiet it was. so i was impressed at last nites dinner. the restaurant was ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This is a reputable bitcoin investment Platform to invest in. I came in a skeptic but with the price point of $1,500, I made a profit of $19,750. The investment I made came out very good and I'm pleased with Mrs Craig Vanessa trading platform for it's the best I've ever come across and I have referred 6 customers who are also very happy with the results they got. I can recommend her to anybody that seeks help in investing. Her WhatsApp and Email contacts are found on her Facebook 👉 Mrs Craig Vanessa
I've been going to Settlers Inn for years. One of my favorite places. I love holidays when the piano players is there, entertaining us. Food was very good, from the appetizers to the delicious desserts and coffee. Have many friends there over the years.
Restaurantji Recommends
We enjoyed it but service was slow, was seated and sat there for almost half hour before our waitress came and asked us for drunk ordered maybe should of had another server on hand. Just a suggestion
We chose the Settlers in for a place to dine in celebration of our anniversary. The Settlers Inn was highly recommended by a friend of mine. We arrived for an early dinner. The atmosphere was quaint the attention of the staff to our needs was superior to most places. The food was amazing! We give the chef our compliments. In short if you are looking for a dinning experience with charm, here is the place.
Settlers Inn, Hawley, PA. 2024: The night my partner and I went it was a special Jazz Night, with a wonderful Jazz Band playing (do not know their name). There was a prefix menu just for that event. We're from Queens, NY, so we have attitude and can be hard to please (sorry to admit, but being honest). I LOVED MY EVENING THERE. The woman attending to us checked my coat in, and the evening began. The menu was not overly extensive, so it was easy to narrow down and pick what we wanted. The decor (we sat in the main dining room) gave me the feeling that I was in an elegantly rustic world, a bit from the past. Exactly what we wanted based on the exterior of the Inn. The food was delicious and innovative. The portion was not too much, not too little. Looking forward to going back.
We were treated immediately and we're acknowledged about our anniversary and request to be seated by the fireplace. The server created us and also wished us a happy anniversary. The food was delicious, but took a little longer than expected.
What an outstanding valentine's day dinner experience!! This rivaled the best dinners we have experienced in the Philadelphia restaurants. The ambiance was spectacular and the service outstanding!! This was truly one of the best dining experiences we have had!!!
Loading...