Four Star Pizza

1119 Mercer Ave #2322, Hermitage
(724) 342-1171

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matthew Ryan

You seriously cannot beat their takeout prices. It's not the best pizza I've ever had but it is VERY GOOD. If you are trying to compare price and quality at the same time this is definitely the best quality you can get for the buck!

Jennifer Rieger

They need to change the prices on the menu on there website I was so disappointed in the food I use to love this place this time not so much and the onion pedals were soaked in grease it's a shame worst 50 bucks I spent

Natalie Koch

Just had a pizza delivered to my hotel room and I think it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had. I travel a lot and order pizza quite a bit. It’s easy and you pretty much know what to expect. Got a simple pepperoni and it’s amazing! I ate way too much because it’s just so good. Service was perfect too, from placing the order to the delivery everything was just… perfect! Sorry, can’t seem to find any other words.
Didn’t rate the atmosphere since it was delivery, but I’m guessing it’s probably good too.

shawn myers

Food is awesome great deals

Barb Mccracken

Take out large pizza and sandwiches. Absolutely loved my sub and pizza. The sauce was very good. Great service, friendly staff, and the prices were very reasonable.
Barbie

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Colleen Neidrauer

Good pizzeria food, fast and cheap.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isabella Brown

Good food but TERRIBLE Customer service

Food: 3

Tammy Coleman

Really good. Just got a pepperoni pizza. Price is good. The girl was so nice that took our order.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kimmie Ramey

Delicious pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Greg W

"Four Star Pizza: More Like 'Two-Star'"The name whispers culinary grandeur, but reality bites. Nestled between a discount wig store and a shady vape shop, the first hurdle is navigating the riffraff outside, seemingly drawn by the intoxicating aroma of, well, something.Inside, the ambiance is a trip down a forgotten 80s sitcom set. Plastic booths sport mysterious stains, and flickering fluorescents cast an unappetizing pall.The pizza itself is an experience. The crust boasts the texture of cardboard dipped in sadness, while the mystery meat topping offers a generous portion of, well, mystery. The cheese, a questionable shade of orange, delivers a unique blend of rubber and tang.If you crave a hauntingly memorable pizza experience and possess an iron stomach, Four Star Pizza might just be your destination. Just remember to bring cash, as the credit card machine seems equally suspicious of the clientele.

Gregory Watterson

Sure, here's a revised review of Four Star Pizza in Sharon, Pennsylvania:"Four Star Pizza: More Like 'Two-Star'"The name whispers culinary grandeur, but reality bites. Nestled between a discount wig store and a shady vape shop, the first hurdle is navigating the riffraff outside, seemingly drawn by the intoxicating aroma of, well, something.Inside, the ambiance is a trip down a forgotten 80s sitcom set. Plastic booths sport mysterious stains, and flickering fluorescents cast an unappetizing pall.The pizza itself is an experience. The crust boasts the texture of cardboard dipped in sadness, while the mystery meat topping offers a generous portion of, well, mystery. The cheese, a questionable shade of orange, delivers a unique blend of rubber and tang.If you crave a hauntingly memorable pizza experience and possess an iron stomach, Four Star Pizza might just be your destination. Just remember to bring cash, as the credit card machine seems equally suspicious of the clientele.

T. C.

Pretty good. We got the pizza and Italian hoagie

Kala 101

Their food was amazing as it always is. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Teresa Shellhammer

Great specials and great food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emilly

Has really great pizza sauce and the best chef salad that I can find around ??

Loading...