Papa's ice cream cottage
1800 Fair Ave, Honesdale
(570) 616-4449
Customers' Favorites
Ice Cream Sundaes
Banana Split
Hot Fudge
Menu
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Papa's ice cream is REALLY good. The ice cream is very smooth a creamy. Lots of toppings and creative sundaes. We spent $15 on a brownie sundae, small vanilla cone and a small Dirt sundae (pictured)
I started going to this ice cream stand this summer, while working at a nearby summer camp. Growing up near many local farms that produce their own dairy, including ice cream, and trying as many ice cream shops as I can in my time, I have to say this is in one of my top 5.
Not sure if it’s the dairy specifically, but the ice cream creations, whether milkshakes or sundaes, are always made well. Not overly saturated with nuts, toppings or whip, but just a perfect...
Not sure if it’s the dairy specifically, but the ice cream creations, whether milkshakes or sundaes, are always made well. Not overly saturated with nuts, toppings or whip, but just a perfect...
You can tell from all of my photos, I go here a lot. My favorite ice cream place. They always switch up the specials too which I like because I like to try something different every time!
You May Also Like
Honesdale Golf Club Restaurant - 121 Golf Hill Rd
![]()
American, Vegetarian
Market 13 - 1230 West St
![]()
Sandwich Shop
Paulie's Hot Dogs - 403 Park St
![]()
Fast Food, Hot Dogs