You cannot go wrong here. The cheesesteaks are excellent, pizza is thin, the taste is superb!
Mary Claire Brossman
For 4 people, we had 2 subs, 2 slices of cheese pizza, and a ravioli dinner. The pizza slices were tough (as if reheated with a microwave.) The ravioli dinner somehow had dry hard edges on each raviolo (like freezer burn.) Our Italian sub with oil/vinegar, the Turkey had mayo, but there was just no flavor to either of them. We'd not been to this pizza shop before, and will try others in the area instead. They had no problem reimbursing us for the ravioli dinner, so that was great.
Mick Miller
A calm Sunday afternoon we went for a dinner - 3 adults, 1 child: a Turkey sub, an Italian sub, 2 slices of cheese pizza and a ravioli dinner. The pizza slices were tough, minimal sauce & cheese (tough/gummy as if reheated with a microwave) The ravioli dinner somehow had dry hard edges on each raviolo (resembled freezer burn or over reheated) Italian sub with oil/vinegar, Turkey with mayo, but there was just no flavor... really concerning. Had not been to this pizza shop before, will try other options in the area alternatively. They had no problem reimbursing me for the ravioli dinner, so that was 100% stand-up. Staff seemed personable the entire experience, so that seems to have improved from some of the previous reviews.
Brenna Holland
We absolutely love Brother Joe’s Pizza! We didn’t use to come here much, but ever since the new owners took over, it’s become one of our favorite spots. The difference is night and day—the food is consistently delicious, and the staff is amazing. Everyone is friendly, welcoming, and truly seems to care about your experience. Highly recommend!
Kenny Powers
Being from the Youngstown, OH area, we’re a little spoiled by the large selection of family owned pizza shops that put the chains to shame. With that said, I’m sometimes a little leery about trying local shops while traveling. This place, however, did not disappoint. The NY style is comparable to what I can get visiting Long Island, the pepperoni and ham Stromboli was delicious, and the service was A+. Would definitely visit again if I’m in the Hershey area.
EEB
This is a fantastic place to grab dinner or lunch! The food is tremendously delicious and pricing is good too. I love the fact that I can get half of a sub not too many places offer that! Definitely worth a try to eat here.
Derek Seaman
Great food highly recommended
Clayon Dahl
First time here. I had the cheesesteak, and it was absolutely delicious. The bread is nice and soft, filled with meat sauce and onions. I definitely recommend this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dave Harris
I stopped by this pizza place after a long sunny day at Hershey Park. I was very impressed with the pizza, very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Emily
Came in for slices a couple times after grocery shopping at giant next door! Nice thin crust. (3$ for a plain slice - closer to $5 for a slice w toppings)
Horrible customer service, food was horrible, they don’t wash their hands after handling money which really turned me off. Will NEVER return
Fishing and Trains
Awesome food. Great staff! There subs are freaking great! Best sub rolls around. We love their cheesesteaks and Italian subs. Try one you will love it.
Christopher Blanchard (Blanchardtech)
Old School Pizza Place. If you want a "true slice" of Americana, this is a throwback to what pizza places were like in the 70s and 80s before chains took over. Their sub roll bread is absolutely the best. The Stromboli is amazing too, All that is missing from this place is a Pac Man or Galaga machine to make it a complete throw back.
Wheelchair accessibility: Street level in strip mall
You cannot go wrong here. The cheesesteaks are excellent, pizza is thin, the taste is superb!
For 4 people, we had 2 subs, 2 slices of cheese pizza, and a ravioli dinner. The pizza slices were tough (as if reheated with a microwave.) The ravioli dinner somehow had dry hard edges on each raviolo (like freezer burn.) Our Italian sub with oil/vinegar, the Turkey had mayo, but there was just no flavor to either of them. We'd not been to this pizza shop before, and will try others in the area instead. They had no problem reimbursing us for the ravioli dinner, so that was great.
A calm Sunday afternoon we went for a dinner - 3 adults, 1 child: a Turkey sub, an Italian sub, 2 slices of cheese pizza and a ravioli dinner. The pizza slices were tough, minimal sauce & cheese (tough/gummy as if reheated with a microwave) The ravioli dinner somehow had dry hard edges on each raviolo (resembled freezer burn or over reheated) Italian sub with oil/vinegar, Turkey with mayo, but there was just no flavor... really concerning. Had not been to this pizza shop before, will try other options in the area alternatively. They had no problem reimbursing me for the ravioli dinner, so that was 100% stand-up. Staff seemed personable the entire experience, so that seems to have improved from some of the previous reviews.
We absolutely love Brother Joe’s Pizza! We didn’t use to come here much, but ever since the new owners took over, it’s become one of our favorite spots. The difference is night and day—the food is consistently delicious, and the staff is amazing. Everyone is friendly, welcoming, and truly seems to care about your experience. Highly recommend!
Being from the Youngstown, OH area, we’re a little spoiled by the large selection of family owned pizza shops that put the chains to shame.
With that said, I’m sometimes a little leery about trying local shops while traveling. This place, however, did not disappoint.
The NY style is comparable to what I can get visiting Long Island, the pepperoni and ham Stromboli was delicious, and the service was A+.
Would definitely visit again if I’m in the Hershey area.
This is a fantastic place to grab dinner or lunch! The food is tremendously delicious and pricing is good too. I love the fact that I can get half of a sub not too many places offer that! Definitely worth a try to eat here.
Great food highly recommended
First time here. I had the cheesesteak, and it was absolutely delicious. The bread is nice and soft, filled with meat sauce and onions. I definitely recommend this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped by this pizza place after a long sunny day at Hershey Park. I was very impressed with the pizza, very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Came in for slices a couple times after grocery shopping at giant next door! Nice thin crust. (3$ for a plain slice - closer to $5 for a slice w toppings)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Horrible customer service, food was horrible, they don’t wash their hands after handling money which really turned me off. Will NEVER return
Awesome food. Great staff! There subs are freaking great! Best sub rolls around.
We love their cheesesteaks and Italian subs. Try one you will love it.
Old School Pizza Place. If you want a "true slice" of Americana, this is a throwback to what pizza places were like in the 70s and 80s before chains took over. Their sub roll bread is absolutely the best. The Stromboli is amazing too, All that is missing from this place is a Pac Man or Galaga machine to make it a complete throw back.
Wheelchair accessibility: Street level in strip mall
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Combo, Cheese Steak, Sicilian
Nice place, nice owners. Sandwiches are very good, pizza is average.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak
They have great food, reasonable prices. The staff is absolutely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Steak, Tuna Fish, Italian, Cheese Steak, Spinach Rolls
Loading...