The Italian Oven Restaurant of Johnstown

Louie was awesome, Great waiter!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Not really any complaints!
Out of the handful of times I’ve gone here, only once did they miss a single ingredient, and it really didn’t change the taste of the dish I ordered. They ended up providing it after I asked.
Great experience each time I go there.
I also perform there every Saturday and the customer service plus food never disappoints! I usually get either a chicken broccoli Alfredo, pizza, panini, or spaghetti and meatballs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

We’ve gone here several times in the last 14 years. We have our faves, and something has changed in their recipes. It’s still okay, but not like it used to be.

I have been an Italian Oven fan for years. There used to be one in my area, but I now drive the 2 hours to go to this location. The food is always amazing, especially the Italian Wedding Soup. I can’t recommend this place enough. One of the best Italian restaurants there is.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Great food great waitress!!!!

Ever since the new owner took over Italian oven the food has been so bad. I’ve been going since I was a kid.. and I will never go back.

Always got the fettuccine Alfredo with broccoli, and now it tastes sour and completely different. I’m never someone to complain but this is so disappointing. I loved their food. It was the first place my now husband and I went when we first got together, it was the place I went when I graduated high school, so I hold a lot of memories there but I refuse to go back until the new owner takes some responsibility and fix what he broke.

Came here on a Saturday was traveling from Virginia visting family. Ordered a soup took well over 30 mins to get my order while dinning in. When I got my fries they were cold. Was a little displeased everytime I visited Johnstown in the past this restaurant was subsrb. Seems like something changed to make the sevcie worse.

Would not recommend the Pasta Alfredo. Salad was good and very big.

Absolutely amazing food. Portions are huge for the prices. You will not leave hungry or unsatisfied.

Marked my pickup order as ready before having my family and I wait another 20 minutes (told me it would be a couple more minutes) for 1 stromboli. 50+ minute wait for a single stromboli that was less than good.

Best Italian I've had around here! Definitely a must go if you're in Johnstown. It's keeping the mall alive

4 stars for atmosphere because it's in the mall and open on two sides.
The food is terrific. This was my favorite restaurant as a kid because I loved the paper tablecloths. I recently moved back and decided to give it a try. I had heard they went out of business so I wasn't too hopeful. I was WRONG! The food is still great! We've gone a few times now and we always get the bell pepper soup as an appetizer so we can dip out bread in it. Try it!

Favorite place to sit down and eat dinner in Johnstown. Cozy atmosphere. Massive portions of incredible Italian food. Everything on their menu is so good it's actually heartbreaking to settle on just one dish. Order a bottle of wine and dessert for the full experience.

Great creamy red pepper soup and huge stromboli.

I used to adore the food here! The staff are still great and super friendly and kind, but I have an issue with the food now. Since Leo took over they changed their sauce for all their pasta which had caused me and my grandma to go from eating there every thursday to very rarely ever going there. not only dad they change their sauces but also how they cut their bread, the loafs used to be cut in halfs and were often still warm and soft! Now they cut them a lot smaller which causes them to be harder and to stale faster if I ever take them home, this has really put a damper on my enjoyment of the restaurant! Again though, the staff are very lovely!