Consistently good. Garlic knots are absolutely delicious (get them fried!!) pizza is great. Chicken cutlet sandwich is very tasty! We were hoping to go on Sunday for our anniversary but they had sold out and had to close early, so we tried somewhere else and were hugely disappointed. We won’t be straying again, mikes is the only pizzeria for us!
Harvey Bessonett
Pizza pizza and more pizza
Robert Recker
I got charged for 4 dressings ($3.00) with my wings. I got 3 ($2.25). I got charged $1.50 for 4 small pieces of celery. I was supposed to get 10% off for "braving the cold" per the FB page. I didn't. I didn't want bring it up to bc it was only about $4.00 and thought I would just be more aggravated with the explanation so I just left.
Brian Mccarthy
Expensive. Food is above average.
Poconos Resident
Delicious! We are pizza snobs and this is one excellent pie. I will pass up our closer pizza joint for one of these every single time
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Loniak
Great pizza. My first time going and I’ll Be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots
Lars
First time coming here with my family. We enjoyed the food and the prices weren’t too bad. The servers were nice and made sure to check on us. The only issue I noticed was neither of the doors in the female bathroom stalls locked.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Fingers
Chris Crocker
Great food - definitely worth stopping at for a quick bite with kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frank Sorokach
Very good food.
Food: 5
Sam D.
A kind owner who makes a great burger. My dad and I ate here in an untraditional sense. We were on our way to jet ski on the lake when our trailer blew a flat tire. It was early on a Sunday morning so we pulled into the empty parking lot. We were changing the tire when the owner came out and gifted us an everything bacon cheeseburger on an everything bagel. Let me tell you, the burger was delicious and flavorful. The owner's kindness was such a bright spot in the midst of our bad luck. We are definitely going back soon to try their pizza. Though we'd love to have that burger again.
We love Mike's Pizza. The owners and staff are always friendly and the food is always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susie Byman
This is one of the best pizza spots I have ever been to. And I say that as a New Yorker who LOVES pizza. They really know what they’re doing when it comes to making those pies! Not only is the pizza fantastic but the customer service is beyond any I have experienced. The girls are super nice and friendly and the guy making the pizza the day we went was so nice. The claw machine broke the day we were there I was trying to get a ball for my son (2) and he not only put in a dollar out of his own wallet when they fixed it, but when it broke again he went in the back and got the ball that he wanted from the machine. I’m not used to that kind of experience where I’m from and it was so kind and unexpected. Then my son pulled one of the girls to the front with him as she left the bathroom because he wanted to play catch and she did not seem bothered one bit even tho she had to get back to work! Such wholesome family vibes from this place. I’ve never been more happy to stumble upon a place the way I did with Mike’s Pizzeria! We will definitely be back next time we’re in the area!
Kid-friendliness: The staff is so sweet when it comes to the little ones it really made the difference! Thank you!
Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap spots and no stairs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pie of the Day
Wanda Grinder
Mike’s restaurant looks like its open door was open on Fourth of July. We were hungry and Lake Wallenpaupack is packed so good to see that they were open but when we went to get a slice, there was no food. We asked if they had any food and they said no, very unfortunate
Denise Yorn
We have been trying out all the local pizza places since our spot closed. Let me say we finally found our new place! The pizza was perfect! And the Stromboli was soo stuffed!. A++
Consistently good. Garlic knots are absolutely delicious (get them fried!!) pizza is great. Chicken cutlet sandwich is very tasty! We were hoping to go on Sunday for our anniversary but they had sold out and had to close early, so we tried somewhere else and were hugely disappointed. We won’t be straying again, mikes is the only pizzeria for us!
Pizza pizza and more pizza
I got charged for 4 dressings ($3.00) with my wings. I got 3 ($2.25). I got charged $1.50 for 4 small pieces of celery. I was supposed to get 10% off for "braving the cold" per the FB page. I didn't. I didn't want bring it up to bc it was only about $4.00 and thought I would just be more aggravated with the explanation so I just left.
Expensive. Food is above average.
Delicious! We are pizza snobs and this is one excellent pie. I will pass up our closer pizza joint for one of these every single time
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza. My first time going and I’ll
Be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots
First time coming here with my family. We enjoyed the food and the prices weren’t too bad. The servers were nice and made sure to check on us.
The only issue I noticed was neither of the doors in the female bathroom stalls locked.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Fingers
Great food - definitely worth stopping at for a quick bite with kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good food.
Food: 5
A kind owner who makes a great burger.
My dad and I ate here in an untraditional sense. We were on our way to jet ski on the lake when our trailer blew a flat tire. It was early on a Sunday morning so we pulled into the empty parking lot. We were changing the tire when the owner came out and gifted us an everything bacon cheeseburger on an everything bagel. Let me tell you, the burger was delicious and flavorful. The owner's kindness was such a bright spot in the midst of our bad luck. We are definitely going back soon to try their pizza. Though we'd love to have that burger again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We love Mike's Pizza.
The owners and staff are always friendly and the food is always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is one of the best pizza spots I have ever been to. And I say that as a New Yorker who LOVES pizza. They really know what they’re doing when it comes to making those pies! Not only is the pizza fantastic but the customer service is beyond any I have experienced. The girls are super nice and friendly and the guy making the pizza the day we went was so nice. The claw machine broke the day we were there I was trying to get a ball for my son (2) and he not only put in a dollar out of his own wallet when they fixed it, but when it broke again he went in the back and got the ball that he wanted from the machine. I’m not used to that kind of experience where I’m from and it was so kind and unexpected. Then my son pulled one of the girls to the front with him as she left the bathroom because he wanted to play catch and she did not seem bothered one bit even tho she had to get back to work! Such wholesome family vibes from this place. I’ve never been more happy to stumble upon a place the way I did with Mike’s Pizzeria! We will definitely be back next time we’re in the area!
Kid-friendliness: The staff is so sweet when it comes to the little ones it really made the difference!
Thank you!
Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap spots and no stairs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pie of the Day
Mike’s restaurant looks like its open door was open on Fourth of July. We were hungry and Lake Wallenpaupack is packed so good to see that they were open but when we went to get a slice, there was no food. We asked if they had any food and they said no, very unfortunate
We have been trying out all the local pizza places since our spot closed. Let me say we finally found our new place! The pizza was perfect! And the Stromboli was soo stuffed!. A++
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent burgers ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...