Cake Creators

3543 Marietta Ave # I, Lancaster
(717) 285-7366

Recent Reviews

Maureen M.

Amazing every time! The cakes are moist. The flavor is delicious, and so many flavor combinations to choose from. She is so easy to work with and very friendly! Never disappointed, whether we order in person in her cozy cheerful bakery or over the phone she uses her creativity to create amazing cakes/cupcakes!

Christine Sheets

I love getting my special occasion cakes from Cake creators,Patty is a gem,kindness exudes from her..the cakes are absolutely amazing..decorated perfectly every single time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake, Yellow Marble Cake with White Icing, Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Icing, Wedding Cake

Gabby Miller

Absolutely phenomenal. Every year I get my fiance a cake for his birthday…The art work, the care and she remembers clients. She is so wonderful and thoughtful. See you next year! Thank you!Storyline of the design:We lived in Montana for awhile and I wanted to have a mountain landscape with a bear near a stream and she took my vision and made it reality!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Taylor Herr

Patty is the absolute best! We had her make our cake for our wedding and it was more than we could have ever imagined. The flavors were perfect along with the design of the cake being exactly what we wanted. Anytime I need a cake going forward she is definitely who I am going to! Definitely recommend her for anybody who needs a cake!

Ele T.

Cake Creators is The Best Patty Goes Above And BeyondListens to detail ! Her Cakes are So Good!!!

Melissa Gabriel

We chose Cake Creators for our wedding cake this past June, and we are so happy we did! When I started looking for a bakery I was shocked at the prices for wedding cakes, but I really wanted to have one. Patty's price was unbeatable! I showed Patty some inspiration pics and she nailed it! The cake was beautiful and delicious. I keep joking to my husband that I'm ready for our one year anniversary so I can eat the top tier we have in the freezer haha!

Deb D.

Requested certain forest animals as decorations on a baby shower cake for my daughter-in-law, to match the nursery decor, and the cake was beautiful- exceeded my expectations by a lot! And it was delicious!

Iantha Giostra

I love this place. Patty makes beautiful cakes and she made my daughters bday cakes amazing!!! Thank you patty your the only cake decorator I will ever go to!

Amy McHugh

Patty has made our family cakes/cupcakes for many years now, Her delightful personality is only matched by her spectacular work. She truly loves what she does and we are very blessed to have her creations be a part of some of our very special family events. We cannot recommend the Cake Creators enough! Thank you for everything!

Jackiee Laukhuff

Patty is amazing. Her cakes are made with love. Thank you for another wonderful wedding cake for our family!

Ele Townsley

The Owner went above and beyond for my Granddaughter's 13th Birthday Cake, She asked her what she wanted and made it to perfection! My Granddaughter was completely thrilled with her cake for her friends and then also an extra cake for her family! Thank You So much!Highly recommend Cake Creators!

Shannon Milley

Omg the cake was amazing , you did a wonderful job my son loved it . The icing was perfect it wasn’t to sweet . The cake was moist and just hands down one of the best cakes I have ever ordered. My husband loved the old school oven . Thanks so much your amazing!!!!!! You will be seeing us again.

Tanya Dinkel

Patty did an amazing job for our babies first birthday! A simple sweet design for our little girl. The cake was delicious and her customer service was exceptional.

Elizabeth Derr

I have no idea where to start with this review!!! From Patty’s fast, kind and very informative responses I was impressed from the start!! We communicated off and on as needed up until the date of the cake pickup. The day I went to pick it up I was blown away by how great it looked! This lady knows what she’s doing. I received so many compliments on how cool the cake looked and how great it tasted!i Patty is the absolute sweetest and she is very enthusiastic and excited about the work she’s doing. She has found herself a buddy in my son and a returning customer in is for our next event. Also I told party later I had a secret nervousness of having a cake with colored icing due to a prior cake from another bakery, Patty put those nerves to rest once I tasted the cake. No artificial taste no after taste at all. It tasted absolutely fantastic. We will definitely be returning and will recommend her shop to anyone who is in need of cakes.

Kari

Patty has been making cakes for my family my whole life, so it was an easy decision when it came to finding a wedding cake baker. Patty is so incredibly sweet and easy to work with. We had a plan to incorporate our pups into our cake, and Patty was genuinely excited to make our vision come to life. Her cake was a hit and one of the highlights at our wedding. Patty was also great at coordinating with some of our other vendors to help our day go seamlessly.

Load More