Infinito's Pizza

874 Plaza Blvd, Lancaster
(717) 295-4994

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Bread Sticks and Dessert Pizza
Chocolate Chip Dessert Slice
Variety of Pizza and Salad
Spinach Artichoke Slice
Broccoli Alfredo Slice
BBQ Cheeseburger Slice
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chocolate Chip Pizza
Spicy Meatball Pizza
White Garlic Slice

Menu

Pizzas
Alfredo Pizza
Our #1 selling pie. Our rich and creamy Alfredo sauce is topped with a hand-shredded mozzarella. Vegetarian.
Bacon Pizza
C'mon, it's bacon. Of course, it's awesome!
Bacon Cheese Fry Pizza
This bad boy has smoked bacon, crispy potatoes, mozzarella and cheddar cheese - all on a zesty layer of ranch. It's absolutely ridiculous.
BBQ Cheddar Burger Pizza
Ditch the bun and eat your burger on a pizza! Beef, cheddar, and mozzarella join a sweet and tangy BBQ sauce that'll make you think you're at a mid-summer cookout. Oh, and did we mention there's also bacon?!
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Tender pieces of chicken are smothered in the world-famous Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce and then topped with a layer of mozzarella.
Broccoli Alfredo Pizza
It's our original Alfredo pizza but with - wait for it - broccoli on it. Vegetarian.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Tantalize your taste buds with our bold flavors of chicken and Buffalo sauce. One bite and you're hooked. Spicy.
Cheese Pizza
Sometimes a plain cheese pizza is all you crave. We totally get it. Vegetarian.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Bursting with flavor, this pizza is piled high with mouth watering chicken, a hint of smoked bacon, mozzarella and finished with a layer of ranch to really make it pop.
Ham and Pineapple Pizza
The choice pie for strumming your ukulele on the white sandy beaches of Hawaii. Okay, maybe it's an acoustic guitar and maybe you're in Pennsylvania. That's fine too.
Ham Hoagie Pizza
Thinly-sliced ham, juicy tomatoes, red onions, a dash of herbs and spices team up with our mozzarella to make this crazy pie. Is it a hoagie? Is it a pizza? Don't worry about it - it's delicious.
Margherita Pizza
Fit for the queen of savoy, this classic features our homemade garlic butter, fresh basil leaves, juicy tomatoes, which all sit under a layer of mozzarella. Vegetarian.
Mushroom Pizza
We use only the freshest button mushrooms, Mario and Luigi are total fans. Vegetarian.
Pepperoni Pizza
Who doesn't love pepperoni?
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Because 1 meat on your pizza just isn't enough.
Rosé Pizza
This pie features a luscious blush sauce that blends tomatoes, Romano cheese, cream and a garnish of traditional herbs and spices. It's easily the sexiest pie we make. Vegetarian.
Sausage Pizza
A staple for sure, sausage is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and spice.
Sausage, Peppers and Onion Pizza
Our crumbled sausage, fresh red onion, and sweet banana peppers are like a 3-part harmony on a 1980's rock ballad. Maybe it's the onions, but you'll definitely shed a tear.
Sensa Formaggio Pizza
Dairy-free. This our take on Philly's tomato pie. It features our homemade crust, traditional pizza sauce and a medley of hand-cut veggies. There's no cheese on this pie, so it's perfect for vegans or someone with a milk allergy. Vegetarian.
Spicy Meatball Pizza
Diced Italian meatballs, tossed in cayenne pepper. It packs a punch - trust me!
Spinach & Artichoke Pizza
LIMITED TIME ONLY! Your favorite restaurant appetizer has found its way onto a pizza! Creamy Spinach & Artichoke dip, topped with mozzarella cheese, is the best thing you never knew you needed. Vegetarian.
Tuscan Taco Pizza
This pie starts with our homemade pizza crust. It's then topped with a mild taco sauce, seasoned beef and then smothered in mozzarella and cheddar. Spicy.
Veggie Pizza
A fresh medley of hand-cut mushrooms, green peppers and red onions piled on top of mozzarella. Vegetarian.
White Garlic Pizza
I'm going to make you a pizza you can't refuse. Served with garlic. Lots of garlic. Vegetarian.

Dessert Pizzas
Apple Pizza
We begin with our homemade crust, spread a layer of cream cheese, add our apple fruit filling, and then top it off with our irresistible streusel. You'll swear your grandmother commandeered our kitchen and baked a homemade pie for you.
Cherry Pizza
We begin with our homemade crust, spread a layer of cream cheese, add our cherry fruit filling, and then top it off with our irresistible streusel. You'll swear your grandmother commandeered our kitchen and baked a homemade pie for you.
Chocolate Chip Pizza
Loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips, this dessert pie brings you back to childhood when you insisted on eating cookies that came right out of the oven. Now that you're all grown up, it's totally okay to do that!
Oreo Pizza
We managed to get our hands on the actual Oreo filling used to make those insanely amazing cookies - we start with that, and then we crush some authentic Oreo crumbs over it! It tastes exactly like an Oreo (mainly because it's an Oreo)!
S'mores Pizza
Ooey-gooey marshmallow cream topped with semi-sweet chocolate chips and graham cracker crumbs. Boom. Instant campfire in-your-mouth.

Extras
Breadsticks (10)
Our light and fluffy golden-brown breadsticks are coated in a delicious blend of garlic, butter, oregano, and romano cheese.
Cinnamon Rolls (16)
Nothing quite compares to a fresh-baked cinnamon roll. Sweet and gooey, ours are topped with icing and served warm, as they should be.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+38 photos
Photo credit: google
+37 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Every time we go there the service is amazing, the female manager is always ontop of everything. She always has great customer service and no matter how busy they are the pizza is always flowing.
February 2026
Loved the food, loved the people, loved the place. The only thing I’d say is don’t get the drink option, it’s not worth it. I got many different slices of pizzas, and their little cinnamon rolls were fresh and incredible. While a few of the pizzas weren’t as fresh, there was literally only one other group there when we ate so it was super quiet.
January 2026
All you can eat pizza that tastes amazing,n doesn't cost too much, and they churn them out quickly so there's always hot and fresh pizzas ready to go. They will take requests as well.

Dining room was clean and the bus boy was around often to get rid of used plates and restock the plate/napkin area.

Associates were busy, but looked happy.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Park City Diner - 884 Plaza Blvd
Diner, Coffee & Tea
Auntie Anne's - Lower Level - Food Court, 1201 Park City Center
Pretzel Store, Pretzels, Fast Food, Bakery
Great American Cookies - 1205 Park City Center
Bakery

Infinito's Pizza

874 Plaza Blvd, Lancaster, PA 17601
(717) 295-4994