Lancaster Cupcake

24 W Orange St, Lancaster
(717) 435-3084

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Milkshake
Strawberry Champagne Cupcakes
Cupcake Split - Build Your Own
Birthday Cake Milkshake
Birthday Cake
Red Velvet
Tiramisu
Cannoli
Apple

Menu

Cupcakes
Vanilla Party
Vanilla cake topped with our signature vanilla frosting and rainbow sprinkles Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Chocolate Party
Wilbur chocolate cake topped with our signature vanilla frosting and rainbow sprinkles Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Strawberry Champagne
Our strawberry champagne cake with house-made strawberry filling topped with strawberry frosting - everyone's favorite cupcake! Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat, Gelatin
Red Velvet
Classic red velvet cake topped with cream cheese frosting and a red sprinkle heart Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Pumpkin Roll
Pumpkin cake topped with cream cheese frosting and a dash of cinnamon Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Caramel Apple Pie
Apple cinnamon cake with Biscoff cookie crust and apple pie filling topped with caramel frosting and caramel drizzle Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat, Tree Nuts
Peanut Butter OREO®
Wilbur chocolate cake with peanut butter filling topped with OREO® Cookie frosting, peanut butter drizzle, and OREO® Cookie pieces Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat, Peanuts
Apple Cider Donut
Apple cinnamon cake with apple pie filling topped with apple cider frosting, cinnamon-sugar, and a donut hole Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Double Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Wilbur chocolate cake with edible, homemade cookie dough filling topped with cookie butter frosting, fudge drizzle, and cookie dough pieces. Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Lemon Lush
Vanilla cake with house-made lemon curd filling topped with lemon frosting Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Cannoli
Vanilla cake with traditional cannoli cream filling topped with light cinnamon frosting and mini chocolate chips Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Blueberry Buckle
Vanilla cake with blueberries baked inside topped with cookie butter frosting and streusel topping Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Cookies & Cream - GF & Vegan
Gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) Wilbur chocolate cake topped with gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) cookies and cream frosting and a full gluten-free OREO® Cookie on top Made with no Gluten, Dairy or Nut containing ingredients, Vegan. Contains: Soy
Strawberry Champagne - GF & Vegan
Gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) strawberry cake with our house-made strawberry filling topped with gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) strawberry frosting Made with no Gluten, Dairy or Nut containing ingredients, Vegan. Contains: Soy
Apple Crisp - GF & Vegan
Gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) cinnamon cake with gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) apple pie filling topped with gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) cinnamon frosting and house-made gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) crisp topping Made with no Gluten or Dairy-containing ingredients; Vegan. Contains: Soy, Almond Flour
Pumpkin Roll - GF & Vegan
Gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) pumpkin cake topped with gluten and dairy friendly (vegan) vanilla frosting and cinnamon dusting Made with no Gluten, Dairy or Nut containing ingredients, Vegan. Contains: Soy

Cupcake Dozens
Baker's Choice Dozen
A variety of cupcake flavors (1 of each) from our current weekly menu.  *May include Nuts, please note if you would like us to exclude them from your dozen.
Seasonal Dozen
A dozen cupcakes with a variety of our seasonal flavors. *May include Nuts, please note if you would like us to exclude them from your dozen.
Lancaster Cupcake Classic Dozen
A dozen cupcakes with 3 each of our most popular flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, and Strawberry Champagne
Happy Birthday Dozen
A dozen cupcakes topped with edible fondant discs that say "Happy Birthday" Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat May contain Peanuts, Tree Nuts, etc. Please contact us if you would like us to avoid certain allergens or package them separately.

Jar Cakes
Vanilla Party JarCake (8oz)
Layers of vanilla cake, our signature vanilla frosting, and rainbow sprinkles Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat
Strawberry Champagne JarCake (8oz)
Layers of strawberry cake, fresh strawberry puree, and strawberry frosting Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat, Gelatin
Peanut Butter OREO® JarCake (8oz)
Layers of Wilbur chocolate cake, peanut butter filling, cookies & cream frosting, & OREO® Cookie pieces Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat, Peanuts

Fresh Baked Cookies
Salted Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookie Salted Caramel Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Freshly baked cookies with chocolate chunks, sea salt caramels and sprinkled with coarse salt Contains: Eggs, Milk, Wheat, Soy

Ice Cream
Cupcake Split - Build Your Own
Your favorite cupcake, cut in half and filled with your choice of ice cream and toppings. Get creative to make the BEST combinations! Allergens Vary based on choice. May include: Eggs, Milk, Tree Nuts, Peanuts, Wheat.
Ice Cream 9oz Dish
Our signature soft-serve ice cream is served in a dish Regular Soft Serve - Contains: Milk (Gluten Free)
Birthday Cake Milkshake
(16 oz) Celebrate your birthday anytime with our Birthday Cake Milkshake. Birthday Cake Ice Cream blended with rainbow sprinkles. Contains: Milk
Chocolate Milkshake
(16 oz) Enjoy the rich chocolate flavor and creamy texture of our classic Chocolate Milkshake. Chocolate ice cream mixed with mocha sauce. Contains: Milk
Cookies & Cream Milkshake
(16 oz) Try a classic taste of Cookies & Cream with our delicious milkshake made with real Oreo® cookies. Satisfy your sweet tooth and enjoy the creamy, rich flavors of this timeless treat. Contains: Milk & Wheat
Dirt Pudding Milkshake
(16 oz) Treat the kid in you with our Dirt Pudding Milkshake - perfect for kids and nostalgic adults. Decadent chocolate ice cream mixed with flavors of mocha and cookie crunch topped with the perfect addition - gummy worms! Contains: Eggs, Wheat, Gelatin
Ferrero Rocher® Milkshake
(16 oz) Indulge with our delicious take on a classic chocolate truffle treat. Rich and nutty, hazelnut and chocolate milkshake made with Nutella® and topped with a classic Ferrero Rocher® Contains: Milk, Wheat, Tree Nuts
Mint Cookies & Cream Milkshake
(16 oz) Indulge in the refreshing flavor and creamy texture of our Mint Cookies & Cream Milkshake. This delicious combination made with real Oreo® cookies and mint will satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving more. Contains: Milk, Wheat
Peanut Butter Oreo® Milkshake
(16 oz) Every chocolate & peanut butter fan's dream come true. Enjoy the creamy goodness of our Peanut Butter Oreo® Milkshake, made with real Oreo® cookies and drizzled with Reese's® peanut butter sauce. Contains: Milk, Wheat, Peanuts
Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake Milkshake
(16 oz) Indulge in the ultimate fall treat with our Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake Milkshake. This creamy and decadent milkshake combines the rich flavors of pumpkin ice cream, luscious caramel, and a hint of graham for a unique twist. Contains: Milk, Tree Nuts
S'mores Milkshake
(16 oz) Our S'mores Milkshake is a decadent blend of rich chocolate, graham crackers, and toasted marshmallows. It's a perfectly balanced creamy and refreshing milkshake. Contains: Milk, Wheat
Salted Caramel Milkshake
(16 oz) With the perfect balance of sweetness and a touch of salt, our classic Salted Caramel milkshake hits the spot. Caramel ice cream blended with our delicious caramel sauce to create a delightful ice cream experience. Contains: Milk
Strawberry Champagne Milkshake
(16 oz) Refreshing and delicious, this combination of a creamy milkshake and fruity strawberry is a delightful treat that offers a burst of flavor that will satisfy your cravings. Contains: Milk
Vanilla Milkshake
(16 oz) A classic milkshake. Simple, yet so good. Try our delicious vanilla soft serve perfectly blended for you. Contains: Milk
Frozen Chai
(16 oz) Try the refreshing and spiced flavor of our Frozen Chai, the perfect beverage to enjoy during the fall season. Treat yourself to this delightful taste of autumn. Contains: Milk
Frozen Espresso
(16 oz) A double shot of espresso over espresso ice cream blended together like a milkshake for a perfect combination of coffee and ice cream! Contains: Milk
Frozen Hot Chocolate
(16 oz) Who says hot chocolate can't be enjoyed frozen? Made with rich chocolate and toasted marshmallow flavor, experience the cozy comfort of a hot chocolate in a cool and refreshing way. Contains: Milk
Frozen Pumpkin Espresso
(16 oz) Our famous frozen espresso mixed perfectly with a seasonal favorite...pumpkin! Enjoy the best of both worlds and try it today! Contains: Milk

Coffee Bar
Americano
A fresh cup of coffee made just for you. Made with espresso roast.
Cold Brew Iced Coffee
Freshly roasted from our friends at Open Seas Coffee Roasters - Cold brew coffee fixed just the way you like it Allergens Vary based on choice.
Latte Latte
Freshly roasted from our friends at Open Seas Coffee Roasters. Espresso with your choice of steamed milk.
Iced Latte
Freshly roasted from our friends at Open Seas Coffee Roasters. Espresso with your choice of milk served over ice.
Signature Lattes
Check out our unique drink creations, seasonal favorites, & more! Freshly roasted from our friends at Open Seas Coffee Roasters.

Drinks
Lemonade
Our Signature Lemonade made fresh with only 3 ingredients - Lemons, Sugar, and Water No Allergens.
Water Bottle
16 fl. oz bottle
Diet Coke Bottle
16 fl. oz bottle
Coca-Cola Bottle
16 fl. oz bottle
Sprite Bottle
16 fl. oz bottle
Iced Tea (Pure Leaf) Sweetened
16.9 fl. oz. bottle.

Pup Treats
PupBiscuit
Our house-made Puppy Treats! Made with all-natural, simple ingredients that are proven to please your pup!
Cupcake PupTreat Cupcake
The perfect treat for your Pup! All natural, pet-safe ingredients and puppy approved. Contains: Eggs, Milk, Peanuts
Donut PupTreat
The perfect treat for your Pup! All natural, pet-safe ingredients and puppy approved. Contains: Eggs, Milk, Peanuts
Happy Birthday Bone PupTreat
The perfect treat for your Pup! All natural, pet-safe ingredients and puppy approved. Contains: Eggs, Milk, Peanuts

Merchandise
Hand Soap - Lemon Lush
Modeled after our well-loved cupcake, Lemon Lush, our hand and body soap is made locally here in Lancaster.
Hand Soap - Strawberry Champagne
Modeled after our well-loved cupcake, Strawberry Champagne, our hand and body soap is made locally here in Lancaster.
Body Lotion - Lemon Lush
Modeled after our well-loved cupcake, Lemon Lush, our hand and body lotion is made locally here in Lancaster.
Body Lotion - Strawberry Champagne
Modeled after our well-loved cupcake, Strawberry Champagne, our hand and body lotion is made locally here in Lancaster.
Lip Balm - Lemon Lush
Modeled after our well-loved cupcake, Lemon Lush, our lip balm is made locally here in Lancaster! It tastes great and won't dry out your lips.
Lip Balm - Strawberry Champagne
Modeled after our well-loved cupcake, Strawberry Champagne, our lip balm is made locally here in Lancaster! It tastes great and won't dry out your lips.
16 Spiral Assorted Candles
Pack of 16 - includes pink, yellow, blue, and green
Gold Happy Birthday Letter Candles
13 candles that spell "Happy Birthday"
Neon Pastel Glitter Birthday Candles
Pack of 10
Naughty Cat Sticker
The perfect sticker to add to your water bottle, laptop, or overall collection!
Possum Trash Sticker
The perfect sticker to add to your water bottle, laptop, or overall collection!
Pretzel & Cheese Dip Sticker
The perfect sticker to add to your water bottle, laptop, or overall collection!
Raccoon Sticker
The perfect sticker to add to your water bottle, laptop, or overall collection!

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: foursquare
+95 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+94 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Lovely little place with a great selection of cupcakes, milkshakes and cupcake splits! They are two vegan cupcakes for individual sale, I got both flavours - both extremely tasty! They also had a selection box of mini GF and vegan cakes! My daughter had a cupcake split which looks really good and she enjoyed a lot. Everyone else had a selection of cupcakes and milkshakes which everyone really enjoyed. Staff were friendly and the eating are and bathroom were very clean. Would return...
November 2025
Lovely little place with a great selection of cupcakes, milkshakes and cupcake splits! They are two vegan cupcakes for individual sale, I got both flavours - both extremely tasty! They also had a selection box of mini GF and vegan cakes! Staff were friendly and the eating are and bathroom were very clean. Would return and recommend!
November 2025
Came here late on a Saturday for gluten free cupcakes. Even though the GF cupcakes were in the same display case as the regular items, they were at the top of the display to prevent cross contamination from falling crumbs.

My best friend (who isn’t on a gluten free diet) said that she wouldn’t have known the cupcakes were gluten free if I hadn’t informed her.

Regarding Staff: Elise (if I remember correctly) was incredibly sweet — no...
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Cafe One Eight - 18 W Orange St
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Vegan
Issei Noodle - 38 W Orange St
Japanese, Ramen, Noodles, Soup, Gluten-Free
The Lancaster Dispensing Company - 33 - 35 N Market St
American, Bar, Vegetarian

Lancaster Cupcake

24 W Orange St, Lancaster, PA 17603
(717) 435-3084