Nicky's Deep Dish & Classic Traditional Pizza

I wanted to try a new place, and this one had great reviews, and for great reasons. I was skeptical at first, because it is as everyone else mentioned, a residential place. Definitely unique, the price was par for the area, and the wait time a little longer than usual. The food though, was absolutely incredible, and so I had to leave a review. The ingredients were noticeably fresh, and the owner took time to describe the origins, and how the dish was made/cut. They went on to describe future deals, and events they were having as well.

Take a chance on this place, it's certainly unusual, but very much worth it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Outstanding pizza and lovely folks. Got the Detroit style and St. Louis, both were cooked to perfection. We will definitely be back! Thanks Nicky & Marie!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Margaretta pizza. I will be going back to try the rest of the menu. Customer service was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Coming through town and saw the four star rating So we ordered a Deep dish pizza. A little unconventional but the best I’ve had outside of Chicago. Thanks again Nick God bless.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Chicago style deep dish pizza was delicious.

Best Customer Service!! EVER! And the pizza is out of this World!!!❤️❤️❤️👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

Awesome pizza. The owners run it out of their house so it is truly homemade. One of the owners even delivers the pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time trying today and I wasn't disappointed. I tried the deep dish which was my first time ever having one and it was delicious! Also tried the St. Louis style which was also very good. The fries were outstanding! They did forget the cheddar cheese sauce on the fries (which costs extra) but they were still so good.

My dad and I stopped here to satisfy his craving for a deep dish pizza local to our area! Our experience was fantastic from the kind service to the pick up, everything went smoothly. We tried the Jersey fries as well, really yummy boardwalk fries feel.

Very tasty! Will be back!

First timer I haven’t even picked up my pizza yet, but I wanted to say how incredibly kind and patient they were with me on the phone trying to figure out my order and the time I needed to pick it up. They were very busy and not once was I rushed off the phone or anything. So that being said I’m already a huge fan and this will be our new Friday night pizza spot for sure!

Finally found a pizza spot that does it right! Real deep dish, flavorful and clearly made with love! Consider myself a pizza snob and I 100% approve.

My family and I were in the area for a Christmas event and wanted to order a pizza after. Nicky’s came up on Google with great reviews so we decided to give it a try since I haven’t seen deep dish pizza anywhere else! We were a little surprised it was a residential address/ghost kitchen situation but the reviews were great so we didn’t want to hold that against them.

The location was well marked with a sign out front and a pizza light in the window. The owner brought the food out and he was super nice and the food was hot and fresh.

The pizza was GREAT. The sauce and cheese blend they use is amazing. So flavorful! We also had the wings which were hot but not unbearable and the fried were very good with a crunchy batter on the outside. I would be interested to try their other styles of pizza as well.

I took a photo of the pizza but not before I ate a slice… I couldn’t wait.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza

We ordered door dash and got the Chicago style deep dish. We were pleasantly surprised at how delicious it was. It was sooo filling. We commented that after one slice we were stuffed- so plenty of leftovers since it was just the two of us. The crust was very good as well. Looking forward to trying other menu selections.

Was an amazing Chicago style deep dish pizza. The ratios and flavors were great!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza