Brickerville House Restaurant

Had two sandwiches, the Reuben and a chicken salad on cranberry walnut bread. Delish. Other restaurants could take lessons from them on how to make a Reuben. Where they fell short was with the overpriced drinks, Autumn rum runner and a martini. The martini came with a 2" square ice cube and not much drink. They need to take lessons from Penn's Tavern Restaurant on how to make a rum runner. No one has beat theirs yet.

No matter how many times I come here, I can never decide what to order because everything is that good. Their menu is stacked with classics and creative seasonal specials that always hit the mark. This visit, we had the mocha latte and honey nut latte (both made with Whiff Roasters coffee love that local touch), the pumpkin cinnamon roll pancakes, the breakfast BLT, and the Brick Griddle. Every single thing was delicious. The pumpkin cinnamon roll pancake was absolute perfection the right balance of sweet glaze and warm cinnamon spice. The breakfast BLT is one of my go-tos: hearty, fresh, and somehow comforting every time. The service is always top-notch friendly, attentive, and surprisingly quick, even when the place is packed (and it usually is!). I’ve been here for dinner and lunch too, but breakfast is where they really shine. If you’re anywhere near Brickerville, do yourself a favor and stop in. You’ll leave full, happy, and already planning what you’ll order next time.

I higher expectations but when we came for the first time we were quite disappointed. Water was brought out in plastic cups instead of glass. I ordered Italian organic coffee in a French press and the French press was plastic inside too. Very cheap. I looked at pics beforehand online and it was glass but unfortunately in person I didn’t get what I saw online. This was early lunch so very few people were there. Also the waitress was casually offering things seeming as if it was just a choice not an upgrade so on the check we see that those were actually extra charges for things we weren’t aware were extra. Cute atmosphere but quality wasn’t as expected.

It was a true delight to visit this place twice. Once for breakfast and once for dinner. The coffee is spectacular. I got the pumpkin latte (hot) and the Steak salad. The Gyro Omlette didn't disappoint either. They offer gf bread! I highly recommend this place for any dining experience. The atmosphere is great and every room is different!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always a good time with good food and drinks!

Like a bar when you come in but not...
I've been here a few times but not really sure what that entrance is supposed to be but gives the whole experience a nice vibe.
Food is excellent here. I've tried a number of menus items and have not been disappointed. So whatever your interest, it's going to be tasty. The new mountain smoke burger, I requested the jam on the side. It was a nice flavor thick blue berry jam.
Waitresses are very pleasant.
My number one is the coffee. Has a great flavor. Top 5 of all time coffee I have had the pleasure to meet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Outstanding service and food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food is excellent and the staff always so wonderful. Beautiful location

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I really wanted to enjoy this place after seeing great reviews, but I had the same poor experience twice, years apart. 4 years ago my husband and I arrived during breakfast hours but there was a bit of a wait. We happily waited and wanted to order once we were seated. We were handed lunch and dinner menus and told that the menu had switched over while we were waiting and we could no longer order the foods we wanted to. The waitress basically said we were SOL. We swore off the place for the next 4 years due to this poor customer experience. Then, this weekend we decided to give it another chance! From what I could tell, they had stepped up their menu offerings and it looked delicious! Again, there was a wait when we showed up at 10:30am but we were happy to wait. We were seated at 11am on the dot and again, was handed the lunch and dinner menus. We asked our waiter about the switch over and he told us we had just missed it, even though the only reason we missed it was because of their own waiting times. We were about to walk out without ordering when the waiter talked to the manager. We were somewhat accommodated but were still told there were items we could not have. I’m just not sure why the customer would be punished for showing up within the breakfast hours, but the restaurant’s own wait times are the reason we missed the menu switch over.

To be clear, nowhere on their website do they state that the breakfast specials menu switches over at 11. Many of the reviews are misleading because they say “breakfast all day” but they don’t mention that you can only get eggs and pancakes after 11.

After all of this, the food is diner quality. It’s fine, not great. The best part of my meal was the cold brew bourbon mocha that was delicious and strong! However, since this poor customer service seems to be a regular occurrence, it has solidified that we will not be returning. Too many good brunch spots have opened in the last few years around Lititz that doesn’t make this place worth the time. Sorry, I really wanted to give this place another chance.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

A great find!!! We were staying near Lititz and found this place whilst out a drive. Lovely homemade quiche. Service great, staff friendly. In addition a quaint courtyard housing lots of different shops including a hair salon, nail bar, candle makers, women’s boutique, locally crafted gifts and an antiques barn. A great one stop shop for a day out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nothing to criticize here. Took my elderly (i.e. old) parents for lunch. Drinks were great, we all liked our meals from the extensive menu, and they commented on the pleasant atmosphere multiple times. Also, the restaurant plays appropriate music at a volume that you could easily talk over. We all really enjoyed ourselves.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great Atmosphere if you love colonial history and old buildings. Service was excellent and food was hearty. I especially liked the variety of specialty teas and coffees. The small village of shops outside the restaurant were a nice surprise and gave us a chance to walk off breakfast. Would definitely stop there again if in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

The food was great!! The service and atmosphere were great too!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always nice here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Unexpected gem. Menu options, food, drinks and service fare exceeded my expectations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5