Tomato Pie Café – A Charming and Delicious Experience
Tomato Pie Café is a must-visit for anyone looking for a cozy atmosphere and incredible food. Their seasonal tomato pies are absolutely delicious—cheesy, flavorful, and filled with fresh ingredients that make each bite a delight. If you’re in the mood for something sweet, the snickerdoodle pancakes are a dream—soft, fluffy, and perfectly spiced with cinnamon and sugar.
For those with dietary restrictions, the café offers a variety of gluten-free options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a fantastic meal. They also carry Olio oils, adding a gourmet touch to their selection. Plus, the servers are often dressed to theme, adding a fun and unique charm to the experience. Whether you’re stopping in for breakfast, lunch, or just a coffee, Tomato Pie Café never disappoints!
Tim Egersheim
Great food and staff. Good location in downtown Litiz
I'm a very picky eater and have yet to find anything on the menu I don't like.
Their seasonal specials are always worth the wait.
J L
Today was my first time at tomato pie and all I can say is wow! I was greeted by the sweetest Ukrainian boy at the door. It was quite empty and it seemed that everybody was eager to serve me. I was sat right away. My server came over with water (thank goodness because I was parched) and she told me about the quiche and where to locate a wonderful selection of beverages on the menu. She recommended the chai steamer so that’s what I got and it was delicious. I trusted her with my drink so I asked what should I get and because it’s my first time she recommended the tomato pie and a few other dishes. I started with the mini pie and got the quiche of the day that was “Greek”(spinach tomato feta). It was the best quiche I have ever had in my life and the tomato pie is excellent! I have never had any thing quite like it. The service was very friendly and fast and the server Jenna reminded me of a sweet witch with her large brimmed hat.
The interior of the restaurant is beautiful. Charmy small bathrooms but clean and stocked. It smelled of fresh laundry. I’m happy I tried something new today and I will definitely be back when I’m in the lititz area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Robert
The tomato pies are fabulous. The coffee is horrible! Ordered a latte and it tasted heavily like chicory. I did hear that they use Passenger Coffee from downtown Lancaster, and that is unfortunately one of the worst coffees in the City. No wonder I didn't like it. The bathrooms are also deplorable. So tiny you can hardly turn around.
Gren Ville
The staff were rude and inattentive. Food was just ok. It’s a “pass” for us. New Holland Coffee right around the corner is definitely a better choice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Zaiteach Zaiteach
Since the moment we walked in it was terrible.,but we stayed to give it a chance.... The place was nearly empty and they gave us a table were the sun was beaming on. We asked to be moved..and she said.. " to sunny there ah?" A while later the waitress came to take our order. While taking our order she seemed to be unhappy, angry that she had to answer a couple of questions regarding the menu. Finally,because she was in a bad mood, she dropped one of our menus..(which the back of it is a piece of wood). She then proceeded to kick the menu on the floor, and the menu hit an old gentleman 's chair. This made the older man jumped. The waitress picked up the menu and walked away. That's when we decided to cancel our order and left the place. I felt awful for the old person and wasn't going to stay longer to eat in an environment with poor customer service with people that are miserable.
Service: 1
Andy Goldsmith
Bad day at the Tomato Pie restaurant on Friday, 11/08/24, between Noon and 1. We had Victor, waiter 28. 3 out of 4 orders were wrong. 1 order very late. My wife and I live in Lititz. We were embarrassed by taking our 2 friends here at this time. Asked for more water. We had to ask 3 times. I asked for sliced tomatoes with my greens. Never got them. Victor said that they have no tomatoes. Tomato pie has no tomato’s..say what? My food and my friends food were not good also. Any problem brought to Victor’s attention was just laughed off…what a comedian ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 1
hannah fishman
Tomato Pie dish was absolutely phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carrot Fries, Pie
Jennifer Rhoades
Always a great place to eat when in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad
melissa leppert
I wanted to like this place. However, to go order took a very long time and the food was just okay... Staff were not very friendly. I’d recommend another place in town.
Unique building and friendly staff. Had the tomato pie and was very disappointed, my friend had the same and had the same issues. Very under baked crust, oil oozing every where around the little paper circle around the crust. Couple diced tomatoes swimming in oily cheese. With more cheese browned on top. Also ordered the herb biscuit with a flight on compound butter. Tiny grilled biscuits with a heavy hand of an herb blend that we did not find a compliment to any of the 3 butters. Server asked how everything was right after it came, dropped the checks, and never returned. We paid at counter no big deal there. Surprised at their namesake dish was that poor.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Sheri Milcarek
Loved the tomato pie and pumpkin latte
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allison Cambre
A classic--tomato pie. Stuffed with tomatoes and cheese. Sure to delight the palate of anyone who loves those ingredients!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Signature Tomato Pie
Mina Dakovic
A very cute spot, definitely a must visit if you’re in the area. Servers were super friendly and food arrived quickly. Everything was very tasty and pumpkin pancakes are the best fall pick!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: TPC Grilled Cheese, Pumpkin Pancakes, Signature Tomato Pie
Neil JoeB
The food and drinks are always delicious and well crafted. Many options to choose for any taste. If the day is nice enjoy the patio. A must stop for breakfast or lunch if you are spending time in Lititz
Dietary restrictions: Keto options
Parking: Parking lot is behind the building. Drive in the alley next to the restaurant to get access to it.
Tomato Pie Café – A Charming and Delicious Experience Tomato Pie Café is a must-visit for anyone looking for a cozy atmosphere and incredible food. Their seasonal tomato pies are absolutely delicious—cheesy, flavorful, and filled with fresh ingredients that make each bite a delight. If you’re in the mood for something sweet, the snickerdoodle pancakes are a dream—soft, fluffy, and perfectly spiced with cinnamon and sugar. For those with dietary restrictions, the café offers a variety of gluten-free options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a fantastic meal. They also carry Olio oils, adding a gourmet touch to their selection. Plus, the servers are often dressed to theme, adding a fun and unique charm to the experience. Whether you’re stopping in for breakfast, lunch, or just a coffee, Tomato Pie Café never disappoints!
Great food and staff. Good location in downtown Litiz I'm a very picky eater and have yet to find anything on the menu I don't like. Their seasonal specials are always worth the wait.
Today was my first time at tomato pie and all I can say is wow! I was greeted by the sweetest Ukrainian boy at the door. It was quite empty and it seemed that everybody was eager to serve me. I was sat right away. My server came over with water (thank goodness because I was parched) and she told me about the quiche and where to locate a wonderful selection of beverages on the menu. She recommended the chai steamer so that’s what I got and it was delicious. I trusted her with my drink so I asked what should I get and because it’s my first time she recommended the tomato pie and a few other dishes. I started with the mini pie and got the quiche of the day that was “Greek”(spinach tomato feta).
It was the best quiche I have ever had in my life and the tomato pie is excellent! I have never had any thing quite like it.
The service was very friendly and fast and the server Jenna reminded me of a sweet witch with her large brimmed hat.
The interior of the restaurant is beautiful. Charmy small bathrooms but clean and stocked. It smelled of fresh laundry.
I’m happy I tried something new today and I will definitely be back when I’m in the lititz area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The tomato pies are fabulous.
The coffee is horrible! Ordered a latte and it tasted heavily like chicory. I did hear that they use Passenger Coffee from downtown Lancaster, and that is unfortunately one of the worst coffees in the City. No wonder I didn't like it.
The bathrooms are also deplorable. So tiny you can hardly turn around.
The staff were rude and inattentive. Food was just ok. It’s a “pass” for us. New Holland Coffee right around the corner is definitely a better choice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Since the moment we walked in it was terrible.,but we stayed to give it a chance....
The place was nearly empty and they gave us a table were the sun was beaming on. We asked to be moved..and she said..
" to sunny there ah?"
A while later the waitress came to take our order. While taking our order she seemed to be unhappy, angry that she had to answer a couple of questions regarding the menu. Finally,because she was in a bad mood, she dropped one of our menus..(which the back of it is a piece of wood). She then proceeded to kick the menu on the floor, and the menu hit an old gentleman 's chair. This made the older man jumped. The waitress picked up the menu and walked away. That's when we decided to cancel our order and left the place. I felt awful for the old person and wasn't going to stay longer to eat in an environment with poor customer service with people that are miserable.
Service: 1
Bad day at the Tomato Pie restaurant on Friday, 11/08/24, between Noon and 1. We had Victor, waiter 28. 3 out of 4 orders were wrong. 1 order very late. My wife and I live in Lititz. We were embarrassed by taking our 2 friends here at this time. Asked for more water. We had to ask 3 times. I asked for sliced tomatoes with my greens. Never got them. Victor said that they have no tomatoes. Tomato pie has no tomato’s..say what? My food and my friends food were not good also. Any problem brought to Victor’s attention was just laughed off…what a comedian ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 1
Tomato Pie dish was absolutely phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carrot Fries, Pie
Always a great place to eat when in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad
I wanted to like this place. However, to go order took a very long time and the food was just okay... Staff were not very friendly. I’d recommend another place in town.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Unique building and friendly staff.
Had the tomato pie and was very disappointed, my friend had the same and had the same issues. Very under baked crust, oil oozing every where around the little paper circle around the crust. Couple diced tomatoes swimming in oily cheese. With more cheese browned on top.
Also ordered the herb biscuit with a flight on compound butter. Tiny grilled biscuits with a heavy hand of an herb blend that we did not find a compliment to any of the 3 butters. Server asked how everything was right after it came, dropped the checks, and never returned. We paid at counter no big deal there. Surprised at their namesake dish was that poor.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Loved the tomato pie and pumpkin latte
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A classic--tomato pie. Stuffed with tomatoes and cheese. Sure to delight the palate of anyone who loves those ingredients!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Signature Tomato Pie
A very cute spot, definitely a must visit if you’re in the area. Servers were super friendly and food arrived quickly. Everything was very tasty and pumpkin pancakes are the best fall pick!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: TPC Grilled Cheese, Pumpkin Pancakes, Signature Tomato Pie
The food and drinks are always delicious and well crafted. Many options to choose for any taste. If the day is nice enjoy the patio. A must stop for breakfast or lunch if you are spending time in Lititz
Dietary restrictions: Keto options
Parking: Parking lot is behind the building. Drive in the alley next to the restaurant to get access to it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Curry Chicken Salad
Loading...