Anthony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Great food and a nice atmosphere for a quiet lunch.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I get take out. Best pizza I have ever had in my life and I have traveled quite a bit! I usually order more than I will eat so I can wrap and freeze for later (yes heating up in oven will work! Not as good as night of fresh but still even reheated better than any other pizza. Some family says better reheated it’s an ongoing debate). My only hope is if the owner ever doesn’t want to own anymore they find another family to run it keep recipe same cause I can’t live without this pizza. ◡̈

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant – NED Review

✅ Noteworthy
- Praised for authentic New York-style pizza, flavorful sauce, and crispy yet chewy crust.
- Italian entrees like chicken parm, baked ziti, and lasagna get high marks for taste and portion size.
- Friendly, family-run vibe with consistent service.

⚠ Expected
- Casual, no-frills atmosphere; focus is on the food, not fancy décor.
- Dine-in area may be small or basic, depending on location.

⛔ Disappointments
- Some say pizza can be greasy or salty, depending on preference.
- Occasional longer wait times during dinner rush or weekends.

Verdict: A reliable neighborhood spot for hearty Italian meals and classic pizza. Great for takeout or a low-key dine-in meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I thought a meatball parm from an Italian restaurant would be above average. It wasn’t. Actually below. Disappointing

Food: 1

Service: 2

First time here and WOW!! Food was authentic and amazing!!! servers and bus help were super attentive and fast!! We will be back! Thank you!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Red Top Pizza and their Pasta is amazing ! All of the food here is fantastic and it has real hospitality....you might even get to meet Anthony as he moves throughout the restaurant which is why the vibe is so special. You can just feel that a homestyle vibe.

so glad I decided to visit during my short stay in Malvern! Delicious pasta made fresh daily using authentic Italian technique and recipe. The seafood linguine was spectacular and my wife loved her pasta. Karolanne was so nice to ua, she made us feel welcome as soon as we walked inside. Will visit again!

Went there for a celebration. They have very good homemade food and they get you very generous portions. We always end up taking leftovers home. Very good price and great food.

Wonderful Italian Food....Everything from the Lobster Ravioli to the Mannacotti to the Gnocchi was Outstanding!!

The portions were generous.

I ate here solo while on business. Set at the bar. Started with Chicken Pastina soup a bowl, which was really a larger cup not a bowl. Soup was good, but was a tad below hot, but not cold. The bread with olive oil was excellent. Although I was not drinking the bartender kept my water filled constantly which I rarely see. I did the Chicken Pesto with Mozzy, tomatoes on focchia bread. It was very good. Even though I didnt eat the top bread (diet), it was so good. Really a nice filling sandwich. Bar got a little crowded so space got a little tight at the end of my dinner but overall a pleasant experience.

Used to be excellent - used to be reasonably priced for superior quality and taste extraordinaire! Previously my only negative about the place was their poor take-out customer service. Not sure who they get to answer the phones, but NEVER have I called and received pleasant, courteous service. It is always as if you are bothering them - terse to the verge of almost rude! BUT the food was so good you could excuse it - the last few times the food as been sub-par and that mixed with the horrendous service has turned me off this place. The menu has changed slightly - trying to be more than a hole-in the wall Italian eatery I suppose.

Always great food and service! We have been enjoying Anthony's for 20+ years. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Pasta Di Mare, Bruschetta

My family and I were absolutely delighted to experience Anthony’s this evening! We actually went to listen to my son’s amazing music teacher Mr. Tony and to our delay the drinks and the food was exquisite! Even the bread basket was excellent along with the dipping oil my children got pizza and french fries and loved everything my spouse got chicken Parm and I got the seasonal risotto with mushroom sausage and chestnuts. For dessert the children got gelato and we split the ricotta cheesecake which was divine! The risotto was enough for a couple of meals and I’ve never had chicken Parm taste that good it was very light and fresh!! My aperol spritz was perfect! Cannot wait to go again!!

Parking: Definitely Street parking is great if the lot is full

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Risotto, Chicken Parmesan

Terri & I love our Monday night dinners at Anthony’s. Ya won’t get a better server than Jade, she’s the best.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5