Love their NY style pizza and meatballs. Always perfectly done. And if you haven't tried the vodka pie, just do it! I still have to try the Sicilian and white pizza. My only complaint is that I wish that they were closer to my house, haha.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arrow Zinger
It's probably the best pizza I've had. Everyone is very friendly as well!Parking: Few spots out front of the shop or in the lot to the right.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, 18 Inch Vodka 8 Slice
Mike Repine
Best pizza in the area. They use fresh ingredients and the pizza is always ready at the agreed upon time. Also the owner is super nice so long as you don't trash the place like an animal.
Maria Noelle
I ate here with family last week for my husbands birthday. Our neighbor recommended this place. Pizza was decent, I ate 2 pieces and ended up getting food poisoning, along with my oldest daughter. We violently threw up for 2 days after this. Hard pass
Mike Evan
Great pizza and quick service.
Jimmy J.
Too expensive. People in this area won't pay those prices. There's a point where they go for quantity over quality. Younger people especially kids. To them pizza is pizza. They should offer coupons or discounts to get people to try their food.
Carrie C.
My new favorite pizza spot in the eastern burbs! I grew up in Jersey and this is as close as it gets! It's even good the next day!
Swede B.
By far the best pizza in the area. I'm a transplant from Philly and these pies are on par with anything from NYC/Philly/Jersey.
Jim H.
I finally got to this place yesterday about 2:30, and it was truly a great pizza. Came by today at 1:00 to get a second slice. The fellow before. me picked up the last slice assumed they would put more out as is normal around here. I asked (and this is a little garbled because of noise) Are you here to pick up? Did you make an online order? Can I get a slice? No. We only make a limited number of slices per day (?????) Uh..... (speechless) If you want to come back tomorrow, you should maybe try 11:00 for a slice. Unless you want to order a full size pizza.... If they were still cooking pizzas. Why couldn't they cook one and give me a slice? Or increase the amount they make for slices a day? This place is on a fast highway, away from communities. Definitely not walkable, and you'll have to take a jughandle U-Turn either coming or going. And the deal is "Make the effort to get her, and maybe if your lucky, we will sell you a slice." Maybe this is a Seinfield reference I'm missing? I'd love to give a 5 for the tastiness of the pizza, but you have to actually reliably deliver a product!
Julie Anna E.
Pretty good pizza! Not the best in the burgh like I have heard but definitely not bad. I'd put it in my top 10 list, but not top 5. Still a good pie and worth a try
This pizza was on my must try list! My husband and I stopped in around 1pm hoping to try a couple different slices. They were sold out of their slices for the day, so we ordered a whole pizza. The customer service was so great so extremely personable! We went the traditional route and got half pepperoni half cheese. It was great! The slices were huge. Every bite had a nice crunch, the cheese pull was there, and the crust was crunchy! You can tell it's a fresh pizza not like chain pizza places. I would visit more often if we lived closer, would definitely recommend very solid good slice!
Phil E.
Pizza was great. However, they have pizza making "time slots" and I was given 7:30 pm. The pizza was barely warm and it was obviously made well before the time I was given. That's the only negative thing I can say burger the price it shouldn't be almost cold when you pick it up on time.
Frank S.
Average at Best. Was really wanting to love this place with the style of Pizza they sell. The crust texture was good, but other than that, the Pizza didn't have much taste. Maybe I caught them on an off night, but for $25 for a one topping pie, I doubt it.
Brandi B.
If I was going to post this review last week after our first visit , I would have certainly given this establishment 4-5 stars easily. However, after my recent experience here, I am left to only give this place 1 star. My husband and I visited A Slice of New York and really enjoyed our experience initially. For that reason, we returned in hopes of trying some other things off of the menu. However, when we tried to call to place a pick up order, we were unable to get through. We do realize they were slammed as it was a Friday evening. Given this, we ventured to the restaurant in hopes of placing an order in-store. I entered the restaurant and see the owners wife working . I let her know of the trouble we had connecting and she informed me of the high call volume they experienced around the same time of my call. She and I had a very pleasant exchange about the situation and she began to ask me about my order. Well.. here's the bad part .. during this exchange with the wife, the owner bombarded into our conversation and cut me off mid sentence. He looked directly at me from the kitchen window and said, "Drop the attitude! Because we do not do that around here!" I was shocked and confused . I even asked another customer if the owner was speaking to him and he also was confused. The owners wife looked mortified. She then stormed to the kitchen where he was and was back there for some time. She came out with a puzzled and frustrated look on her face, but she also appeared to be trying to keep a straight face in front of the customers. I asked the wife if the owner was serious when he made that rude comment to me. She then said she was not sure and that he may have been playing, but it was okay . I said back to her that I did not have an attitude and I have no idea what he was talking about. In response, the wife said she told the owner that I was fine and did not have an attitude. She then told me that the wait time for an order would be about an hour. I declined to place and order and left the restaurant. Following that exchange, the vibe of the restaurant was weird and unsettled, and I was not about to spend my money there again. The owner is rude, poor-tempered, unprofessional and overall extremely weird. After reading through other reviews, I see that we are not the only ones who had an unpleasant experience here. Needless to say, we will never return or give this place any more business.
Ken C.
I would never eat here again. The pepperoni pizza tasted like school cafeteria pizza and only had 3 slices of Roni. Owner asked what I thought and I told him and I posted my review on his Facebook page. He then criticized me for posting a bad review and went on to try and belittle me on Facebook. While many may like his pizza, there are many styles of pizza and his is not to my liking.
Love their NY style pizza and meatballs. Always perfectly done. And if you haven't tried the vodka pie, just do it! I still have to try the Sicilian and white pizza. My only complaint is that I wish that they were closer to my house, haha.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's probably the best pizza I've had. Everyone is very friendly as well!Parking: Few spots out front of the shop or in the lot to the right.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, 18 Inch Vodka 8 Slice
Best pizza in the area. They use fresh ingredients and the pizza is always ready at the agreed upon time. Also the owner is super nice so long as you don't trash the place like an animal.
I ate here with family last week for my husbands birthday. Our neighbor recommended this place. Pizza was decent, I ate 2 pieces and ended up getting food poisoning, along with my oldest daughter. We violently threw up for 2 days after this. Hard pass
Great pizza and quick service.
Too expensive. People in this area won't pay those prices. There's a point where they go for quantity over quality. Younger people especially kids. To them pizza is pizza. They should offer coupons or discounts to get people to try their food.
My new favorite pizza spot in the eastern burbs! I grew up in Jersey and this is as close as it gets! It's even good the next day!
By far the best pizza in the area. I'm a transplant from Philly and these pies are on par with anything from NYC/Philly/Jersey.
I finally got to this place yesterday about 2:30, and it was truly a great pizza. Came by today at 1:00 to get a second slice. The fellow before. me picked up the last slice assumed they would put more out as is normal around here. I asked (and this is a little garbled because of noise) Are you here to pick up? Did you make an online order? Can I get a slice? No. We only make a limited number of slices per day (?????) Uh..... (speechless) If you want to come back tomorrow, you should maybe try 11:00 for a slice. Unless you want to order a full size pizza.... If they were still cooking pizzas. Why couldn't they cook one and give me a slice? Or increase the amount they make for slices a day? This place is on a fast highway, away from communities. Definitely not walkable, and you'll have to take a jughandle U-Turn either coming or going. And the deal is "Make the effort to get her, and maybe if your lucky, we will sell you a slice." Maybe this is a Seinfield reference I'm missing? I'd love to give a 5 for the tastiness of the pizza, but you have to actually reliably deliver a product!
Pretty good pizza! Not the best in the burgh like I have heard but definitely not bad. I'd put it in my top 10 list, but not top 5. Still a good pie and worth a try
Restaurantji Recommends
This pizza was on my must try list! My husband and I stopped in around 1pm hoping to try a couple different slices. They were sold out of their slices for the day, so we ordered a whole pizza. The customer service was so great so extremely personable! We went the traditional route and got half pepperoni half cheese. It was great! The slices were huge. Every bite had a nice crunch, the cheese pull was there, and the crust was crunchy! You can tell it's a fresh pizza not like chain pizza places. I would visit more often if we lived closer, would definitely recommend very solid good slice!
Pizza was great. However, they have pizza making "time slots" and I was given 7:30 pm. The pizza was barely warm and it was obviously made well before the time I was given. That's the only negative thing I can say burger the price it shouldn't be almost cold when you pick it up on time.
Average at Best. Was really wanting to love this place with the style of Pizza they sell. The crust texture was good, but other than that, the Pizza didn't have much taste. Maybe I caught them on an off night, but for $25 for a one topping pie, I doubt it.
If I was going to post this review last week after our first visit , I would have certainly given this establishment 4-5 stars easily. However, after my recent experience here, I am left to only give this place 1 star. My husband and I visited A Slice of New York and really enjoyed our experience initially. For that reason, we returned in hopes of trying some other things off of the menu. However, when we tried to call to place a pick up order, we were unable to get through. We do realize they were slammed as it was a Friday evening. Given this, we ventured to the restaurant in hopes of placing an order in-store. I entered the restaurant and see the owners wife working . I let her know of the trouble we had connecting and she informed me of the high call volume they experienced around the same time of my call. She and I had a very pleasant exchange about the situation and she began to ask me about my order. Well.. here's the bad part .. during this exchange with the wife, the owner bombarded into our conversation and cut me off mid sentence. He looked directly at me from the kitchen window and said, "Drop the attitude! Because we do not do that around here!" I was shocked and confused . I even asked another customer if the owner was speaking to him and he also was confused. The owners wife looked mortified. She then stormed to the kitchen where he was and was back there for some time. She came out with a puzzled and frustrated look on her face, but she also appeared to be trying to keep a straight face in front of the customers. I asked the wife if the owner was serious when he made that rude comment to me. She then said she was not sure and that he may have been playing, but it was okay . I said back to her that I did not have an attitude and I have no idea what he was talking about. In response, the wife said she told the owner that I was fine and did not have an attitude. She then told me that the wait time for an order would be about an hour. I declined to place and order and left the restaurant. Following that exchange, the vibe of the restaurant was weird and unsettled, and I was not about to spend my money there again. The owner is rude, poor-tempered, unprofessional and overall extremely weird. After reading through other reviews, I see that we are not the only ones who had an unpleasant experience here. Needless to say, we will never return or give this place any more business.
I would never eat here again. The pepperoni pizza tasted like school cafeteria pizza and only had 3 slices of Roni. Owner asked what I thought and I told him and I posted my review on his Facebook page. He then criticized me for posting a bad review and went on to try and belittle me on Facebook. While many may like his pizza, there are many styles of pizza and his is not to my liking.