Goodfella's Pizza Italian Restaurant

I never leave a bad review but I left this place very mad. I ordered 4 slices to share with my wife and 2 sodas, it cost me $36.00 and then I had to leave a tip because the slices were brought to me. The pizza was so over cooked and hard as a rock. Terrible experience and I will never go there again.

Great food. Great service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I just want to say these guys make the best garlic knots in the area period. I just tried their garlic knot pizza knowing how good the knots are and it really hit the spot. Also great place to grab a slice because the slices are always huge!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice

Wonderful place. Great team,
Especially their extra cheese pie!
Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My boyfriend and I went to a dinner/comedy show special. We'd never been here before, and the price felt pretty reasonable. The atmosphere was nice. I think it’d be better if it were just the two of us; I was disappointed that we had to sit with others because we’re both introverts, but it wasn’t intrusive. They seemed to have a plan for how to handle the evening — I think they mentioned this was the first time they had done something like this and that they weren’t fully prepared for the night. Apparently, the pizza side got slammed, and the kitchen got backed up, which caused our dinner and the show to be delayed.

Our server was alright but perhaps overwhelmed because she was somewhat inattentive. We ordered a few sodas, which took quite some time to arrive and were flat, but once they noticed, they brought fresh drinks. The group seating also caused problems with our bill, but they fixed it immediately and said that if there were any issues, we could just call. The food was pretty good — I had bruschetta, salad, and chicken parm with pasta (I gave the dessert to my boyfriend, so I can’t speak to that). The bartender was somewhat curt when I ordered a soda after waiting so long for the waitress, who was noticeably losing her patience with the evening's mishaps.

We weren’t fans of the comedy, but that’s not the restaurant’s fault, of course. Overall, we had a nice evening — a little longer than we expected — but we understood the situation was out of their control. Unfortunately, the restaurant isn’t local for us, so I’m not sure if or how often we’ll be back, but I would recommend the food to anyone who is local. I can’t speak for the service due to the series of unfortunate events that night, but I’ve chosen to believe it’s normally better based on other reviews.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Food is good but the service is terrible. They take orders and forget or mix them up. We’ve had take orders mixed up on two occasions and dine in dinners where three people got theirs and the fourth was forgotten. Totally clueless.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

The food is always amazing!! Pizza slices are HUGE! Staff is always friendly and provides quick service. Great prices!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Pizza Slice

I really cannot even say enough stuff about this place! The food was incredible, our waitress was very attentive,even the leftovers were good the next day! Highly recommend people to stop in!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very disappointing….. attempted to shoot for dinner…. Waited 12 minutes for the waitress to acknowledge us. 30 minutes later we walked out….. she never even brought our drinks to us. I understand it’s busy but instead of cleaning tables she could’ve at least brought our drinks.

Very good pizza awesome portions and reasonable prices. Can't wait to go back.

The food is pretty good here. They need to work on service. Our server didn't came back to check on us once our meals came out. I would still recommend giving them a try. They were busy. They just could have been overwhelmed.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Wings, Lasagna

Potrei fare complimenti all'infinito. I grew up right outside of Palermo, and their chicken bbq pizza tastes like my childhood. I know it's such a simple thing to make, but so many things here in the states don't taste the same even if the recipe is right. But something about that pizza was special, enough to make me emotional from thinking about my middle school days. I took one bite and was instantly transported back to the little hole in the wall place my best friend and I used to go to on the weekends to share a pizza. Keep up the good work!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Goodfellas is a pizzeria with very good food, friendly staff and a much cozier than expected ambiance. It's not trying to be anything it isn't. The several times I passed by when in/around the plaza I assumed it was gonna be a sub-par pizza for no reason at all. We stopped in one night when we were driving later than usual and thought there'd be no other options. Well, we were so glad we did. The dining room is very accommodating and clean. The pizza and hero that we ordered were delicious! So flavorful.
BUT to be totally honest it was when we returned two weeks later (the other night) that I really was sold. I got the white spinach slice. Forget about it! Game over! This slice was so flavorful. I loved the sausage and peppers slice I got too, but it was this white spinach slice that blew me away.
Long story less long, Goodfellas is going to be a regular stop for us.
Thank you for the wonderful experiences!

Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian options

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: It is wheelchair accessible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice

This is the first and last time I will order from them. Placed my order at 6:35pm and when I called at 8pm. because they were taking forever, they said they just marked it complete for pick up. It's 8:42pm and still we have no pizza.

Service: 1

So mad at myself for never stopping in here before today. I ate lunch in. Service was friendly, food was amazing. Menu has a broad selection. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5