Restaurants near Mayport

1 Woodlands Tavern

4.4 Superb 54 Reviews

8631 PA-28, Mayport

• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“I've spent some of the best (and worst) nights of my life at this place. Stiff mixed drinks, cold beer(with an ever-changing selection) and great bar food at more-than-reasonable prices have made this my local go-to spot for 10+ years. Tacos Tuesdays and Wing Wednesdays are aways a good time, and Barb's cheese steak pizza is a must try! They have a DJ every Wednesday and generally have another that comes every other Friday or Saturday. I have had trouble enjoying time there while sharing the space with the bar owner, Kevin, do to his sexist jokes and overall inappropriate behavior toward female clientele when he is too intoxicated, but thankfully he isn't there often. The bar manager, Barb, and the other bartenders are an awesome bunch! 😉 Definitely check out Woodlands Tavern for some yummy food, cold draft pitchers, and good times!”

2 Sweet Delights Ice Cream

4.9 Superb 144 Reviews

3210 PA-28, New Bethlehem · 6.82 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“Delicious! Everything is large portions & very reasonably priced, you won't be disappointed. Half salads are 2 meals for me, the best ranch dressing, my hubby loves all the burgers, only ordered a double once he needed a fork! We can't wait for them to open in the spring & we visit weekly. The wraps are huge, my daughter turns that into 2 meals as well. Well worth the stop!!!”

3 Canyon Coffee Co.

4.9 Superb 71 Reviews

227 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.84 miles

• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Just stopped by Canyon Coffee Co. for the first time (long overdue!) and had a cappuccino… and wow. It was perfect—smooth, rich, exactly what I wanted. ☕️😍 I’m officially in love. 5⭐️ As someone who works from home and occasionally needs a change of scenery, I think I just found my new spot to spend the day working—I’ll definitely be back as often as I can!”

4 Joe's Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant

4.6 Superb 248 Reviews

710 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“This place has such friendly service and the best pizza I have ever eaten! Everything is home made and fresh! The price is great too! We hear EVERYTIME before we go up to our camp! All I can say is DELISH!!!! 😋”

5 Country Palace Bar

4.7 Superb 85 Reviews

139 Fairview Road, Dayton · 8.57 miles

• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Food was great friendly staff”

6 Zack's Catering and Events

4.5 Superb 172 Reviews

301 Wood Street, New Bethlehem · 4.71 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Zack’s catered our small micro wedding 9/21/25. We were blown away by them! Everyone was so personable and the food was DELICIOUS! They made our day extra easy by taking care of setting up, serving, packing up, and cleaning up! 10/10 would recommend!”

7 Village Pizza & Subs

4.6 Superb 67 Reviews

228 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.84 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“Absolutely worth every cent! I just moved here from Texas and this was the first sandwhich shop I tried. Don't waste your time at a subway, go here first. I got a BLT with no tomato and it had onions - I will be coming back for more. Thank you guys so much”

8 Snug Harbour

4.5 Superb 126 Reviews

6447 PA-66, Fairmount City · 5.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“We absolutely love our local bar, it’s not only great food but the service is fantastic! Come check it out, you will love that you did!”

9 New China King

4.5 Superb 28 Reviews

716 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.32 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“My husband and I had dinner there tonight. I thought the food was good. They have a platter you can get with fried rice and an egg roll for about $11 and it is a good size serving for one. thumbs up for both the hot and sour soup and the wontons”

10 Ever Moore's Restaurant

4.3 Superb 123 Reviews

341 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.75 miles

• Drive-Through

“Great place to eat ! Love the all day breakfast & pies are delicious !”

11 Blue Town Tavern

4.3 Superb 22 Reviews

5609 PA-66, New Bethlehem · 4.63 miles

• Delivery

“Very awesome people n nice job it's a big difference”

12 Grandma's Kitchen

4.2 Good 148 Reviews

12680 PA-36, Brookville · 8.07 miles

• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Awesome food, friendly staff, the owner greeted us. Great little restaurant for our community!”

13 Desperado's

3.7 Good 29 Reviews

425 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.7 miles

• Drive-Through

14 Subway

3.6 Good 71 Reviews

945 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.04 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“To be fair when you are in a small town I don't think you should be asking too much of subway but this Subway always goes above and beyond and I feel bad as my job is across the street and if I'm in a bind they rescue me if I forget my lunch. Anyways, I am so happy because if I put in a mobile order Amy had always been kind to tell me if they're out or discontinued an ingredient. Worried if she made me angry, I'm no picky person and I roll with it, I worked food, retail, the works! So I know they're always so sweet in there and they're trying really hard. So I will give props to all the girls, especially Amy. She's probably sick of my face 😂😂😂”

15 Fox's Pizza

3.3 Good 90 Reviews

300 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“I've been eating at foxy's for a long time their food is really good they have the best places and the people there are very friendly I highly recommend Fox's Pizza for good food”

16 Burger King

3.3 Good 179 Reviews

702 Broad Street, New Bethlehem · 4.39 miles

• Delivery

“I ordered a fish sandwich and fries, neither one was fit to eat. The fish and bun was dried out the fries were undercooked. My friend also ordered a double stacker and onion rings. Meat was dried on his sandwich and his onion rings were soggy. I went inside and got my money back. I will never eat at any Burger King in any state that we are in.”