Tomato Pie Cafe

885 E Ingomar Rd, Allison Park
(412) 364-6622

Recent Reviews

Sort by
jan i

menu prices need to be updated. The last pizza I got was medium with 2 toppings, sausage, hot peppers and ithe bill for that was almost $25.00 l

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Marc Mitterer

When someone tells you it’s a “local gem”, that often means that they have come to love a spot despite its failures. This is definitely the case.

It’s never a good thing when the word “no” prefaces so many necessary items:

NO air conditioning
NO soft drinks
NO credit cards

When we were greeted the server told us they were out of medium pizza shells.

NO medium pizza

Which immediately revealed that they are using ready-to cook shells and not fresh dough. Yuck.

Oh, and then they got our pizza wrong too, but we couldn’t send it back because… you guessed it, they ran out of large pizza shells too!

So you can imagine my shock when I paid $60, -SIXTY- for two large, sloppy pizzas with 6 cups of water.

I was told by the server that most people bring their own wine as a beverage. Because that’s what the kids want after swimming all day at the North Park Pool, a nice glass of Merlot.

Never going back again, if you locals like it so much you can have it. I’ll pick one of the other hundreds of local pizza places in Pittsburgh that don’t say NO so often.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Maria B

Amazing!! One of my all time places to eat!!

Mark D

I finally decided to come here after many many years of driving by on the way to North Park. The food was pretty good, not exceptional. Be prepared for a very limited menu, as well as the fact that it is BYOB. This includes soft drinks. I had the beans and greens, it was ok, but definitely lacked in flavor. Someone recommended the pizza, and I am a little disappointed that I didn't go with that. Unfortunately that being the case I have no ability to review the pizza. They are also cash only. Follow for more...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Elmo dragonFIR3

5 stars because Guillermo likes this restaurant

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Connie Finnegan

We went for the first time tonight for dinner and it did not disappoint! The staff was super friendly and the service was prompt. And the food 😋 we had the beet salad which was absolutely delicious, I highly recommend getting it and we also ordered their tomato pie and it was amazing as well. We will definitely be back!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Kiser

Got a plain cheese pizza for takeout. It was good, but I wasn't blown away.

Food: 3

Service: 4

Teresa Smoot

I was visiting from out of town and came across this place while actually going to another restaurant that ended up being closed. We back tracked to this place I saw and I was so glad we did! The cute red house with the beautiful front patio surrounded by flowers and plants drew me in. The pizza had me coming back the next day to bring a tomato pie home! Fresh tomatoes and basil, mozzarella cheese, and an amazing crust! The owner and staff were so nice and even though they weren’t open yet when we got there they invited us in. Family friendly neighborhood place. I wish I lived closer! Next time I’m in town this is the first place I’m going!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Signature Pizza, Pizza with Fresh Tomatoes

Julie Ann Smith

One of my all time favorite restaurants ever! Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Barrionuevo

The service here is terrible, the vibe is "why are you bothering us?". Though the pizza is good for North Park area--that does not say much. The attitude leaves a lot to be desired.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Shirl Ransley

Not dog friendly. They are an outside restaurant and can't bring my 5 pound dog.

Food: 4

Service: 2

Kaylyn Kraus

The best pizza. The pink leek sauce and salads are also incredible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Penne Primavera, Fresh Beets Salad, Beans & Greens Salad

Jacob Rupert

Food was awful, has completely gone down hill and will never recommend.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jill Huber

Arrived at 12:05pm on Tuesday. Large sign outside says open Tue - Sat 12pm.No one in sight. Door was unlocked, no lights on. Bread works bags on tables. 2 cars over on side parked but no one answered phone or to our call outs. Unfortunately lost some business today.

Christy O'Connell

This was the first time we ate here. We shared a pizza and it was amazing. The pizza was very delicious and the service was awesome. Just a heads up it is cash only.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Loading...