Had this pizza for the first time. Have to say one of the best I've ever tried hands down. If you like the messy square cut with the cold four peps you're sure to love Jays. Staff and owner were present while I walked in and did an amazing job of explaining the pizza. Please give this a try. Support local businesses.
Jess McGinnis
We ordered takeout a couple of days before Christmas. We had a taste off with a few other pizza places, all square cut. My in-laws had told us how good Jay’s was. We were not disappointed. It was the favorite that night and we have ordered takeout a few times since :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jay's Original Pizza 6 Cuts
maureen lavorgnema
Both very good sandwiches and pizza ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Deep Dish Pan Pizza
Randy A.
They have the freshest ingredients. Italian hoagie is amazing. Great Pizza and the owner is such an awesome person!
Michael Shaffer
12 cut pizza with pepperoni was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim S.
The pizza was outstanding. I would say in the top 2 pizza places in Pittsburgh. Well worth the drive. You have to try it.
Ronald Johnson
Today Jay's brought me back to when I was 8yrs old. Trying to be the first customer in to get the free fish dinner. Jay's Pizza has always been amazing and a staple in the comunity. It took the new owner a while to perfect the recipes. I can now say with certainty that they have. Great job Jay's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brittany Boeltz
The food was absolutely amazing! Portions are huge and we had lots of left overs. Staff are friendly and building is clean. My sons 16th was catered by Michele at Jays Pizza and my guests raved about the food. I had people call me after asking wheee the food was from because they want to book future parties. The price is totally responsible and I promise you the quality/taste is out of this world. Your guest will go home happy and full! Thank you Jays pizza for going the extra mile and writing a birthday message to my son! We will be back! Can’t wait to try to the pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Allyn
We called to order fish sandwiches every Friday for a month only for the owner to tell us that they werent serving them until “maybe October” and were upset with us for calling “too early” even though it was just before 11am! Tried getting sandwiches when they “available” and they were always sold out. They told us to preorder the fish sandwiches ahead of time, and then got angry that we called them too early in the day ? we will make our own fish sandwiches.
Somehow three pizzas run you 75 bucks here. The pizza was half baked and was basically raw. Will not order from here ever again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Deep Dish Pan Pizza, White Pizza
David A.
Amazing food love the pizzaAlways get the fish , it huge and delicious Ordering is slow at times but everything is made fresh to order, great food!
Sam Evans
It was like eating a soggy brick. The crust was incredibly overcooked and rock hard. It was drowned in grease to the point most of the cheese had slid off by the time it made it home. The grease had actually spilled out of the pizza box and onto my passenger seat. Tremendous disappointment.
Richard Lazzini
This place is like stepping into the past I've been getting pizza here since I was 10 years old and even know there is a new owner it still tastes like it always been for ever so good I would highly recommend eating here you won't regret it ??????
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Chu-Yi Tan
Giving one star solely on the fact that the owner lady was horrible at customer service and was not at all helpful she cant even write my order down right. After she passed the phone to the manager, i found out she didn't even write my order down. The gentleman who helped me after that was extremely helpful and kind. Worse customer service from who was supposed to be the owner on the place.
Best pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jay's Original Pizza 6 Cuts
Had this pizza for the first time. Have to say one of the best I've ever tried hands down. If you like the messy square cut with the cold four peps you're sure to love Jays. Staff and owner were present while I walked in and did an amazing job of explaining the pizza. Please give this a try. Support local businesses.
We ordered takeout a couple of days before Christmas. We had a taste off with a few other pizza places, all square cut. My in-laws had told us how good Jay’s was. We were not disappointed. It was the favorite that night and we have ordered takeout a few times since :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jay's Original Pizza 6 Cuts
Both very good sandwiches and pizza ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Deep Dish Pan Pizza
They have the freshest ingredients. Italian hoagie is amazing. Great Pizza and the owner is such an awesome person!
12 cut pizza with pepperoni was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was outstanding. I would say in the top 2 pizza places in Pittsburgh. Well worth the drive. You have to try it.
Today Jay's brought me back to when I was 8yrs old. Trying to be the first customer in to get the free fish dinner. Jay's Pizza has always been amazing and a staple in the comunity. It took the new owner a while to perfect the recipes. I can now say with certainty that they have. Great job Jay's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was absolutely amazing! Portions are huge and we had lots of left overs. Staff are friendly and building is clean. My sons 16th was catered by Michele at Jays Pizza and my guests raved about the food. I had people call me after asking wheee the food was from because they want to book future parties. The price is totally responsible and I promise you the quality/taste is out of this world. Your guest will go home happy and full! Thank you Jays pizza for going the extra mile and writing a birthday message to my son! We will be back! Can’t wait to try to the pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We called to order fish sandwiches every Friday for a month only for the owner to tell us that they werent serving them until “maybe October” and were upset with us for calling “too early” even though it was just before 11am! Tried getting sandwiches when they “available” and they were always sold out. They told us to preorder the fish sandwiches ahead of time, and then got angry that we called them too early in the day ? we will make our own fish sandwiches.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Somehow three pizzas run you 75 bucks here. The pizza was half baked and was basically raw. Will not order from here ever again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Deep Dish Pan Pizza, White Pizza
Amazing food love the pizzaAlways get the fish , it huge and delicious Ordering is slow at times but everything is made fresh to order, great food!
It was like eating a soggy brick. The crust was incredibly overcooked and rock hard. It was drowned in grease to the point most of the cheese had slid off by the time it made it home. The grease had actually spilled out of the pizza box and onto my passenger seat. Tremendous disappointment.
This place is like stepping into the past I've been getting pizza here since I was 10 years old and even know there is a new owner it still tastes like it always been for ever so good I would highly recommend eating here you won't regret it ??????
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Giving one star solely on the fact that the owner lady was horrible at customer service and was not at all helpful she cant even write my order down right. After she passed the phone to the manager, i found out she didn't even write my order down. The gentleman who helped me after that was extremely helpful and kind. Worse customer service from who was supposed to be the owner on the place.