Jay's Pizza Shop
$ • Pizza, CheesesteaksAbout Jay's Pizza Shop
Customers' Favorites
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pan Pizza
Jay's Original Pizza 6 Cuts
White Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Jay's Pizza Shop Reviews
110 ratings
Share your opinion about Jay's Pizza Shop
Let me start by saying, I LOVED Jays/McDonald Pizza. Easily in my top 5. Imagine my sadness when I learned the new owners weren’t given the recipe 🙁
BUT tonight, we gave Lenny’s a shot. You can tell they are new because they are still nice over the phone when placing an order! Easily one of the nicest guys I’ve ever conversed with.
Shop is CLEANed out! Looks great! Lenny himself greeted me at the door! What a cutie!
We received our order in about...read full review
BUT tonight, we gave Lenny’s a shot. You can tell they are new because they are still nice over the phone when placing an order! Easily one of the nicest guys I’ve ever conversed with.
Shop is CLEANed out! Looks great! Lenny himself greeted me at the door! What a cutie!
We received our order in about...read full review
I stopped by this new hometown pizza shop and was so impressed! The owner and staff were incredibly nice, welcoming, and friendly, which made the experience even better. The pizza was absolutely delicious with a unique flavor that really stands out. The crust was perfectly crisp, just the way I love it, and every bite was outstanding.
It’s always great to support a local family-owned business, especially when the food and service are this good. I loved everything about...read full review
It’s always great to support a local family-owned business, especially when the food and service are this good. I loved everything about...read full review
We ordered from Lenny’s tonight for dinner for the first time since the opening, I definitely recommend trying this new pizza shop in town. You won’t be disappointed.
Hours
| Monday | 4:30 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Friday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 4:30 - 9PM |
Jay's Pizza Shop offers a unique, homemade square-cut pizza with carefully prepared toppings. The owner and staff are friendly and attentive, taking the time to explain the pizza's distinctive style. The OG pepperoni pizza is highly praised and considered one of the best in Pittsburgh, with many customers enjoying it for over 30 years. The deep dish pizza is also highly recommended, with some saying it is the best they've ever had, even in places like McDonald. The pizza is made fresh and ready quickly, making it a popular choice for those looking for good food at a good price. Customers also enjoy the steak hoagie and chicken bacon ranch hoagie, which are suggested as tasty options. While the pizza is well-loved, the wedding soup has been disappointing for some, due to its heavy spinach flavor and lack of chicken. Overall, Jay's Pizza Shop is a favorite for many, with friendly service and quality food.