Pierogies Plus
$ • Family, Polish, VegetarianAbout Pierogies Plus
Customers' Favorites
Stuffed Cabbage with Potato and Cheese Pierogi
Four Pierogies and One Stuffed Cabbage
Four Pierogies and One Piece Kielbasa
Potato Cheese Pierogies and Haluski
Pierogies Stuffed Cabbage Haluski
Kielbasa Pierogies and Haluski
Potato & Cheese Pierogies
Stuffed Cabbage and Pierogies
Potatoe and Cheese Pierogies
Potato Dumpling Haluski
Pierogies Plus Reviews
305 ratings
Share your opinion about Pierogies Plus
Bought lots of perogies and some stuffed cabbage, all were delicious! 😋
I live in NYC and am always getting good quality Pierogis and Vareniki out there, and I must say, Pierogies Plus in McKee was better than them all! Best pierogis I ever had. So fresh and flavorful, and also very large! You get bang for your buck. I tried the spicy sausage ones, potato and cheese, and potato and pickle. So so amazing. I would recommend this spot to anyone and I wish it was located in NYC! Haha!
Some of the best polish food I have ever had. The halupki (stuffed cabbage), handmade pierogi and halushki were simply amazing. Food that good coming out of a converted gas station is mind blowing!!!! The only drawback is very limited on site seating.
Hours
| Monday | 10:30AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 10:30AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 10:30AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Pierogies Plus offers authentic and fresh food that is worth the short wait. The walk-up window allows for quick ordering and pickup, making it easy for customers to enjoy their meals. The restaurant features a great selection of pierogies, including the Mystery Pierogi Dozen, which offers an adventurous meal paired with onion sauce on the side. The Hunters Stew remains a popular choice among diners. They also serve other delicious items such as stuffed cabbage and haluski, as well as nut horns and lady locks, along with Turner's ice tea. The food is cooked in butter and onions, providing a very tasty experience. Customers appreciate the fast service, filling portion sizes of the pierogies, and the comforting flavors that remind many of home cooking. Vegetarian options include potatoes, cheese, cabbage, noodles, and crab cakes, with gluten-free options available if ordered in advance. Parking can be tight during busy times, so arriving early is recommended to avoid sold-out flavors. Despite limited parking, many find the food worth the wait and highly recommend it as the spot for authentic Eastern European comfort food. There is no indoor seating, so take-out is preferred, although a few tables are set up outside for those who wish to eat nearby.