Jimmy John's

4955 Carlisle Pike A, Mechanicsburg
(717) 761-4914

Recent Reviews

alb ben

Frequent customer here at Jimmy John’s but I was disappointed on the serving at this location today. I tried the new caprese salami pesto sandwich and the sandwich came out disgusting and unappetizing. It was smothered with balsamic glaze and can’t taste the other ingredients. Very disappointed!

Tingy

Not only is there a lot of empty vape devices littering the parking lot outside, when i walked in it smelled like marijuana heavy. This is a sub shop, not a dispensary.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Connor Altigieri

so let me get this straight. i call and after you block my number so i can’t ask where my check is. you refuse to give me the owners number so i can locate it, and then your manager blocks my number after lying to me that i had a check ready and calling me a sped? deadass worst business ever, and it’s all thanks to the hypocritical idiots in management

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Conner Haddaway

Wow. I didn't think I'd ever be writing a review for Jimmy John's of all places, but I received some of the best customer service by a nice teen named Max. I wasn't sure what to order, and Max recommended me the #9 (delicious btw) and was super friendly during my whole experience. We had a nice chat and he truly just seems like a genuine guy who loves his job. Don't know how much they make but he definitely needs a raise. Will be back just to see Max again.

Aaron Rissinger

Popped in for a quick sub. On point like usual.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Sub

Kirk Stein

Very, very good sandwich. The neat, cheese, bread, and veggies are very fresh. I cut the rating by 1 star as the chips were chewy and way too salty. Prices are reasonable.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Erin Napoli

First time at JIMMY JOHN'sStaff was helpful with suggestions on what to order. Forgot the pickle on the side.. damn really feeling that pickle.The bread is the best sub roll bread I have ever had. I haven't seen to a sub sandwich place in a while but DAMN... I recommend highly the Italian, they call it something else. Just get it with JIMMY PEPPERS

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew Hoover

Where’s the meat? Terrible sub

Jeremy Gresham

Easy to order. Quick, fast, and friendly

Drew Diadem

I was intentionally given hard stale bread, it was not baked and I did not ask for bake, it definitely was stale. I threw it away and will not be going back to this location. I did not see management present unless the manager was a teenager. To be fair on my previous visit the food and service was excellent so I do not know what changed.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Laurie Barnes

I have been a JJ fan for years..haven't had one in a few years...very disappointed...2 pieces of meat 1 piece of cheese..my roll was hard enough to play hockey with it..don't think I'll be coming back anytime soon...

Food: 2

P Longhall

I just wanted to know why do u only put 3 slices of meat on 17 dollar sandwich

Jeremy Bush

Had an order online/App issue. Spoke with the manager on-site. She didn't give us time or day. She was very rude and didn't resolve our financial issue. No longer a Jimmy John fan!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Emily Ellison

The staff is children that play around and waste products. they go against there word. They pick favorites.

Borderlandman/Jack

Staff were really nice and suggested me a sandwich since it was my first ever time in there. The inside was really cool

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Load More