Shirley Rae's

1347 Saxton Wy, Mechanicsburg
(717) 516-8391

Recent Reviews

FireCracker3240

I'm shocked to see the bad reviews. I've been to this place maybe half a dozen times and I've always had a great experience. The owner, he's always been delightfully friendly & courteous, and I love the ice cream options. And the waffle bowl was delicious. I've never had their sandwiches, but I do really like coming here for the occasional ice cream treat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jesse Gate

Hands down the best ice cream in town! Shirley Rae's never disappoints. I appreciate that they use high-quality ingredients, and you can taste the difference in every bite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charles B.

Cute little small business, ice cream was delicious and service was great! They have plenty of indoor seating and a nice assortment of flavors

Diane Resh

Ice cream was smooth and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

2023 R

The sandwiches were delicious we had 3 sandwiches and a small ice cream bowl and it came up to $50 quite pricey. The taste and flavor was very good, there is limit sitting inside five sitting tables inside and a clean bathroom. There are some benches outside of the shop. Very nice area.Parking: Limited parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Shop

Will Smith

Fantastic and only a few minutes from lower allen park, the dog park and creek.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Shop

high FI

Would management please reach out to me? Thanks.Edit* I realized ownership may not care about the wildly rude worker.

Service: 1

Navya Voleti

Adorable ice cream place with a cute ambiance. They have a corny joke wall, which I love to read every time I go in. It is kid-friendly and dog-friendly, they have doggie treats!Their oreo ice cream flavor and blueberry swirl are delicious. They also have a great thai turkey panini which is a regular order for me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Navya V.

Adorable ice cream place with a cute ambiance. They have a corny joke wall, which I love to read every time I go in. It is kid-friendly and dog-friendly, they have doggie treats! Their oreo ice cream flavor and blueberry swirl are delicious. They also have a great thai turkey panini which is a regular order for me.

Rachel Alden

I love ice cream more than your average person. This is truly terrible ice cream. It was freezer burnt and we got three different flavors that all tasted the same. Couldn’t even finish it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Luke McAlister

Ice cream was good but portion sizes are much smaller than other places. Prices are higher too. Nice location though.

Craig M.

Store was clean, but staff wasn't super friendly and the prices were expensive. The scoop servings are really tiny for the cost. I would recommend other ice cream shops in the area over this one. They won't last long if they don't offer more for the money.

Merve Fetter

I want to give this place 5 star. It is a cute icecream/sandwich shop with outdoor seating ,within a walking distance from my house and their ice cream is really decent. But the owner is VERY RUDE! We had a very uncomfortable exchange, he was rude and disrespectful. Since I promised my kids icecream, I tried to let it go and went ahead placed the order anyway. He didnt even bother to use gloves as he grabbed cones. I let that go too.. Then we went outside and sat for maybe 5 minutes before he came outside and started closing umbrellas and pulling chairs- 40 min before they close. I quickly got up and we left so he is not once again talking to me with a disrespectful manner in front my kids.We won't be going there again for sure.

Shelia T

Very family oriented seating outdoors and parking1st time here, it was early evening stop on my way home treated myself to some very good fresh ice cream ?Kid-friendliness: Not just for ice cream menu available for children and adultsParking: This place is in close proximity to residential area some people drove others walked pushing a baby buggies.. gotta love ? sping time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brett Lardie

So many complaints about this place. The serving size was terrible. Our sandwiches had barely a slice of turkey. The plate was dusted with chips. The scoop of ice cream didn't even fill the waffle cone. The service was horrible. There was one person managing the cash register, ice cream and the kitchen. Definitely needs to learn customer service skills. Really sad because the atmosphere was great. Won't be a repeat customer for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 1

Load More