The Original Italian Pizza - Tyson Hill

27171 Rte 75 N, Mifflintown
(717) 436-2184

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Big Jay

Best OIP for pizza and stromboli.

Sonja Maneval

Subs are absolutely delicious

Danielle Jackson

Very friendly waitress, the food came out fast and hot. The food was good, not great. We had a stromboli, a steak sub, and the chicken Alfredo.

The Professional

Subs are nothing but lettuce tomato and onion .. there is very little next to no meat in them .. pizza is always undercooked almost raw dough yet .. ridiculous prices for the crap food they send out .. my advice go to harshburgers .. way better

Nina Phoenix

Great meal and awesome service!!!

Glen Mast

Large Stromboli enough for 2 people.

Rob Shonk

Another bland meal in Pennsylvania. I'm beginning to wonder about the local palate. I had the spaghetti, and while it was fair, it had zero zest. And if you know Italian... You know it is usually a zesty, full flavor event.

Larry Miller

Best pizza around the area..

Denny Rohrer

Great food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Salad with Fries

Tonya Smarsh

Excellent service, pizza was perfect, and the environment was above expectations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Dorian

3 times in a row they completely screwed my order. I spoke to the manager (name unknown, a man.) I explained the situation, and he proceeded to actually cuss me out. I'm completely appalled by how I was spoken to. I will never go there again. I'm literally shaking as I write this I am so angry at the way I was treated and disrespected by "an actual manager".

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

David Speicher Sr

We stopped by to dine in with a pizza and drinks. The store was clean, the service was friendly and fast. However, we were both disappointed with the pizza as we both agreed they were really short on the amount of pepperoni for the price and the overall taste of the pizza was just okay. The bottom dough was chewy. It was done, but It's the only way to describe it. I would consider dining with them again when we are camping at buttonwood. But we wouldn't order pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Tiffany Gill

I was craving a turkey sub. Normally they're very good from here but tonight was not like normal. I paid $11 for a sub that had 4 thin, I mean very very thin, slices of meat on the entire sub. It was absolutely not worth $11.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Jody Hartman

Went there before the sprint car race food was good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks w Sauce

Misty Snook

Very poor service. We were told to sit anywhere so that’s what we did. While waiting 20+ minutes with no waitress- a few other people came and sat after us. Finally we asked politely if there was a waitress- the lady went and got our waitress from the back but we were the last ones to put an order in because she stopped at all the front tables first. She didn’t give us straws for drinks- we had to ask for silverware and napkins. One of the kiddos ordered Alfredo and asked for alfredo sauce on the side which she did get but we weren’t told it would cost almost $4 for a little cup of Alfredo sauce. One of the other kids asked for ranch and we got charged extra for that too! We will not go there again.

Loading...

The Original Italian Pizza - Tyson Hill

27171 Rte 75 N, Mifflintown, PA 17059
(717) 436-2184