Amazing tasting pizza! I ordered the bruschetta slice; it was delicious — lots of flavor and crispy crust. I have tried pizza from many places and this was one of the best I’ve ever had!
Eric Britton
Great pie! Amazing flavor and excellent service over all. A little cramped for space, but not real complaints. 100% would go again.
Marcelo Garcia (CustomWorkNJ)
Everything was excellent!
Lucia Barthelemy
Today my husband bought there 3 slices of pizza for our kids. Plain, buffalo chicken and vegetables pizza (last one I tried and I must say never in my life I ate such TASTY PIZZA WITH PERFECT PIE! Amazing 🤩
Lesa Mercereau
This pizza was absolutely delicious!
David Rivera
Made a quick stop while passing through the beautiful town of Milford. The pizza was pretty good. Don’t sleep on the Tiramisu
Dennis Laverty
I have been getting pizza from this establishment for awhile. In my opinion, they are the BEST. Their pizza was perfect. I had one of their donuts too, Extraordinary. Compared to other places (I won't mention names) this was the best
Irasema Perez
Very calm and welcoming staff! The gelato and donuts are great!
Jean Facciarossa Kinneary
I just had their eggplant pizza! It was delicious. I'm from NY, so I'm picky about pizza. We will definitely be going back!
Sean Kolvenbach
Best pizzeria in town! Had the pepperoni and mikes hot honey pizza yesterday and the Burrata salad, highly recommend!
Pesto alla Carini was delicious but we felt the crust was over baked
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Walker
Asked for a reg cheese pie crispy just so it wasn't undercooked and got a horrible sheet of cardboard. No taste, no cheese, no flavor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Maggie Bites
Delicious
Paul J
This place looks like it's been here forever! And apparently it has been, off and on.
Carini is a small place, seating maybe 25 patrons. Decor is sparse and simplistic with a few watercolor paintings decorating the walls.
I remember walking in about 10 years ago or so and the center of the food walking through the air made me think, now this is going to taste good!
Little did I know I would not get back again because of life and other issues for another 10 years.
For my family it was definitely worth the wait. They didn't break the cardinal rule of chicken wings, NOT BAKED! but FRIED their wings. The Buffalo wings sauce taste was accurate but as I chose "Hot" ( between hot and mild available) I was pleasantly surprised to find the about a perfect medium; saucy, crispy, chewy and fantastic! Probably the best wings to date in the area.
For starters we had the fried zucchini, french fries, fried mozzarella and chicken roll. If fried zucchini, French fries and fried mozzarella were as to be expected, hot and crispy... definitely acceptable if not unusually hot.....thats a good thing.
The Chicken roll was very lightly seasoned chicken (if at all) but the real story of that dish was the crust, or the dough. Soft and chewy and everything you expected from a pizza crust. A little more salt and some Italian seasoning would probably do that wonders. For what it was it was definitely large enough and acceptable.
We ordered the plain pie, the New Yorker, and the bruschetta pie. Not being a fan myself of a New York style pie, (and full disclosure) Pizza in general, I wasn't crazy about the by itself, but my family seem to like it. The bruschetta pizza however, was a different story; with an ultra thin crispy crust, it was absolutely fantastic!
Our server Lexie was sweet, professional and attentive; really couldn't ask for more.
They have various flavors of gelato available, and we definitely tried the tiramisu, which even after stuffing ourselves, was deliciously decadent.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Tiramisu, Large
Amazing tasting pizza! I ordered the bruschetta slice; it was delicious — lots of flavor and crispy crust. I have tried pizza from many places and this was one of the best I’ve ever had!
Great pie! Amazing flavor and excellent service over all. A little cramped for space, but not real complaints. 100% would go again.
Everything was excellent!
Today my husband bought there 3 slices of pizza for our kids. Plain, buffalo chicken and vegetables pizza (last one I tried and I must say never in my life I ate such TASTY PIZZA WITH PERFECT PIE! Amazing 🤩
This pizza was absolutely delicious!
Made a quick stop while passing through the beautiful town of Milford. The pizza was pretty good. Don’t sleep on the Tiramisu
I have been getting pizza from this establishment for awhile. In my opinion, they are the BEST. Their pizza was perfect. I had one of their donuts too, Extraordinary. Compared to other places (I won't mention names) this was the best
Very calm and welcoming staff! The gelato and donuts are great!
I just had their eggplant pizza! It was delicious. I'm from NY, so I'm picky about pizza. We will definitely be going back!
Best pizzeria in town! Had the pepperoni and mikes hot honey pizza yesterday and the Burrata salad, highly recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great thin crust pizza. Good gluten-free pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Style
Pesto alla Carini was delicious but we felt the crust was over baked
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Asked for a reg cheese pie crispy just so it wasn't undercooked and got a horrible sheet of cardboard. No taste, no cheese, no flavor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Delicious
This place looks like it's been here forever!
And apparently it has been, off and on.
Carini is a small place, seating maybe 25 patrons.
Decor is sparse and simplistic with a few watercolor paintings decorating the walls.
I remember walking in about 10 years ago or so and the center of the food walking through the air made me think, now this is going to taste good!
Little did I know I would not get back again because of life and other issues for another 10 years.
For my family it was definitely worth the wait.
They didn't break the cardinal rule of chicken wings, NOT BAKED! but FRIED their wings.
The Buffalo wings sauce taste was accurate but as I chose "Hot" ( between hot and mild available) I was pleasantly surprised to find the about a perfect medium; saucy, crispy, chewy and fantastic!
Probably the best wings to date in the area.
For starters we had the fried zucchini, french fries, fried mozzarella and chicken roll. If fried zucchini, French fries and fried mozzarella were as to be expected, hot and crispy... definitely acceptable if not unusually hot.....thats a good thing.
The Chicken roll was very lightly seasoned chicken (if at all) but the real story of that dish was the crust, or the dough. Soft and chewy and everything you expected from a pizza crust. A little more salt and some Italian seasoning would probably do that wonders. For what it was it was definitely large enough and acceptable.
We ordered the plain pie, the New Yorker, and the bruschetta pie.
Not being a fan myself of a New York style pie, (and full disclosure) Pizza in general,
I wasn't crazy about the by itself, but my family seem to like it.
The bruschetta pizza however, was a different story; with an ultra thin crispy crust, it was absolutely fantastic!
Our server Lexie was sweet, professional and attentive; really couldn't ask for more.
They have various flavors of gelato available, and we definitely tried the tiramisu, which even after stuffing ourselves, was deliciously decadent.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Tiramisu, Large
Loading...