New Story Coffee House

352 E Main St, Mt Pleasant

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I stopped by, as recommended by family. The owners are a lovely couple who explained the coffee they had for sale, shared a shot from beans they had been testing, and were generally very attentive. You can feel the passion they have to make their business more than just another coffee shop.

The coffee and breakfast sandwich I bought were incredible and the interaction I had with the owners was a highlight of my year so far. My only complaint is that they're...
Took a short detour on a 7+ hour road trip to grab some coffee. After looking at the reviews, I decided to preorder a double shot caramel latte since they make their flavor shots in house. I kid you not...this was possibly one of the best espresso drinks I've had in a while (no exaggeration!). The syrup to espresso to milk ratio was perfect. 💯

The only regret is that I didnt get a bigger size or another drink for later.

I couldn't...
Full disclosure: i am a coffee snob. I had a cup of coffee from them today (black) and it was one of the best coffees I've had! Not bitter at all and it leaves a really amazing after taste that just makes you want more! Will be adding them to my regular stops!

More Reviews

New Story Coffee House

352 E Main St, Mt Pleasant, PA 15666