Original Italian Pizza and Restaurant

Simple neighborhood family restaurant. Nothing fancy but the food is tasty and the service was very friendly.

Super nice place! The food is absolutely amazing! Talked to the owner while he was there, super down to earth guy. Nice decorations to look at while waiting for the food. Hands down the best pizza in the area.

In comparison to other OIP’s in the central PA area their food portions are mediocre at best. With the cost of the food my Stromboli was made with barely had any meat. It was all dough and veggies. 2 weeks ago I ordered a Stromboli at the Mill Hall OIP and I couldn’t believe how amazing it was. It was worth the price. When I told someone how much the Muncy one cost they couldn’t believe it and felt like it should have been 10 dollars based upon the contents. I stopped ordering sandwiches from the Muncy OIP bc of the lack of meat as well. Stop raising prices and continue to cut down on ingredients. I will not be ordering from here again. I’ve had a lot of bad experiences and this is the last time I waste my money here. Go elsewhere.

Apparently, this restaurant prefers to cater to door dash and other delivery services. We sat in the dining room. Got drinks and ordered. Then proceeded to wait for over an hour for our food. All I could hear from the waitress were apologies to all of the dining room patrons. No one was happy. The whole time we were waiting, my wife and I observed dozens of door dash food pick ups. My wife got her dinner first. I had to ask where mine was. I was then served with someone else's dinner. My wife finished hers. I still had nothing. I just wanted to leave at this point. The owner came over and offered to make my dinner asap. When it came out, it was undercooked and ice cold in the middle. I told him and he seemed indifferent. This is really a shame because we used to enjoy the food at this place. I really do not want to go there again.

Good hoagies. Italian dishes are good. Friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings with Bleu Cheese or Ranch BBQ Mild Hot Honey Mustard Garlic Butter or Plain, Lasagna, Salad, Cheese Steak, Baked Ziti

Would give it 5 but you guys forgot my tea in my order and also put jarred mushrooms on my veggie pizza. Please use fresher mushrooms. Aside from that all good ❤️?

Good food. Nice waitress

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Pizza was hard and crunchy had to ask for refills on drinks won't go again got me once won't get me twice yuk

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The pizza and the sauce was very good and different, especially their garlic bread. The Service is great.

I stopped in for lunch. Was able to have two pieces of pizza and an order of fries ready to go pretty quickly for me so I'm Happy overall!

Always good Buffalo pizza ? and barbecue chicken Pizza ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken

I am so disappointed with them I order the same thing every time I go there I never had an issue before I always get tortellini and white sauce they gave me red I called to see if they fixed it an Heather argued with me and refused to fix it for me said I had to pay for it all over agin if I wanted it fixed I spend atlest 100$ a week there not no more you lost my bussiness an all my family’s business you will never get a dollar from us again that was unacceptable an unbelievably rude try being more polite to your turning cu

Extremely undercooked pizza. Very doughy and floppy. Owner will rave about how good the pizza is but he’s tooting his own horn. It’s a 5.5 at best.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Had a really good meal with great service. Always enjoy catching up with the owner, Frank.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Called in to get a pizza, Trisha took my information and told me 15 minutes. I arrived promptly 15 minutes later and my order was never put in. The girl behind the counter mocked me when I stated I had called and spoke to Trisha, and the man cooking the food didn't care at all. There was not a single person who acted professionally about the situation. They offered to have me wait even longer to make me a pizza on the spot. I had a very hungry child with me and that was not an option, hence why I called and placed an order ahead of time. This is not the first time that I've had bad customer service, and from the same people. I love their food, but the customer service isn't worth it anymore.

Service: 1